3 ms·
No, this is the one written by a guy that just wanted to make "secure chat" accessible. And went on to have plenty of flaws. (And no, Telegram is another one, w
by MichaelGG 13y ago
No, this is the one written by a guy that just wanted to make "secure chat" accessible. And went on to have plenty of flaws. (And no, Telegram is another one, where they came up with their own scheme and brushed off all criticism by saying they had some math PhDs so that's that.) IIRC the web version does JS crypto and tries to sell that as more secure.
Cryptocat and Telegram seem to be very popular though, proving again that technical superiority isn't really a good indicator of product success. (WhatsApp had terrible security too, at least for a while, but they never went on about how secure they were.)
- fossuser 13y agoI think that's unfair - both text secure and cryptocat are interested in making secure chat more accessible. Making security applications accessible is an important problem to try and solve. Security is difficult and I think they were fairly up front with the potential issues with what they were building. They've also been doing it for a few years now, the code is open source, they've had professional security audits - what more could they possibly be doing?
- phaer 13y agoYour parent was talking about Telegram, not TextSecure. The quality of the formers crypto is much more controversial than the latter.
- MichaelGG 13y agoTextSecure is solid as far as I know. What I meant with my comment is that Cryptocat/Telegram put marketing and accessibility over security. They rather sell a veneer of security in a cute package instead of actual security, along with the difficult problems it brings. Both products ignored (and actually told off) expert advice, which is quite telling. IIRC, TextSecure was created by crypto expert[s].