4 ms·
But algorithms don't create an economy – people do (and I actually have a degree in Mathematics). I don't have a problem with Bitcoin being hacked: that can and
by pron 13y ago
But algorithms don't create an economy – people do (and I actually have a degree in Mathematics). I don't have a problem with Bitcoin being hacked: that can and will be fixed. I do have a problem with the very notion of a "trustless" economy for two reasons: first, there ain't no such thing (it's like a worshipper-free religion). Economy equals trust. An economy needs credit and it needs insurance, and you can't have those without trust (heck, the word "credit" literally means "to believe"). Second, even if you could imagine such a thing, where a robot would compel you to pay up, or an algorithm would make decisions for you, why in god's name would you even want to? Why take away the freedom of people to come together and make collective decisions about the economy (say, like devaluating a currency) for their society's benefit? Why, because some people are crooks? The kind of society you picture is, literally, an autistic one.
While you don't want people to think that Bitcoin is failing after ceaseless thefts, you call our institutions "failing" based on what? I don't know about you, but my institutions aren't failing. They just require regular maintenance.
Also, if you think Bitcoin is about creating a new kind of trustless economy (in other words, the very same economy that existed prior to the modern one or in lawless frontiers like the Wild West), you are mistaken in believing that most people will follow you. That is precisely the libertarian politics that hangs around Bitcoin's neck, and if anything will choke it, this will be it. Forget about who's right and who's wrong. The reality is that most freedom-loving people aren't libertarian. They like their institutions and want to fix them. They don't want a trustless economy. We may be misguided; we might be wrong; but we're the vast, vast majority.
And if you like history, you probably know that people have been warning about the collapse of modern institutions pretty much since their inception. There were always those who wanted to grab their gold and head for the hills because the system is falling apart. And let me tell you that there were times the system was close to crumbling, but today we're not even close to such a big crisis. Nevertheless, the vast majority of people have put their faith in their institutions, and for about 500 years now, they've been right (well, more or less).
- baby 13y ago> and I actually have a degree in Mathematics this is getting ridiculous, stating your degree just to tell people your argument is backed by studies that really don't help you that much (if at all) in economics (yes I have a degree in mathematics too).
- lazylizard 13y agomy 2 cents..i dont have a degreee in econs...ha! i think the problem is deflation, actually. which leads to 2 practical problems..lack of credit and hoarding. shutting down the ability to spend newly created fiat money i suspect will reduce the amount of credit alot. that probably makes most businesses as we know them now unoperable. hoarding is a social problem i guess. it just increases the wealth gap. not sure if most societies want that.
- leobelle 13y agoIf you wrote more, probably online somewhere, about bitcoin and the like, I would probably read it because you seem smart and stuff. I really mean it. I hadn't considered the fact you can't loan out bitcoins the way you can regular money.
- enko 13y ago> you can't loan out bitcoins the way you can regular money Why not? I mean sure, it would mean losing the anonymity, but the receiver would owe you the interest-adjusted amount just like someone you lent money to. A loan isn't magical boomerang money, it's a legally encumbered transfer, which can be done with dollars, bitcoins, tractors or anything else. In fact here's bitcoin lender right here: https://www.bitbond.net/ https://www.bitbond.net/
- saalweachter 13y agoWe actually have two money systems that are used on a day to day basis, cash and accounts. Bitcoins replace cash, but accounts are where the real magic of the economy happens. Lending -- as an institution, as opposed to as an individual -- is all about fractional reserve banking. The bank pools the money of its depositors and lends it out without restricting the ability of the depositors to access their money. This increases the money supply, and generally works OK because of a combination of (a) most people not needing most of their money most of the time and (b) a lot of transactions happen purely through the bank's internal ledger, without needing cash at all. If Alice writes a check to Bob, who immediately deposits it, the bank just updates their ledger and it doesn't matter whether they have cash on hand to cover it. There's nothing preventing you from operating a traditional fractional reserve bank using Bitcoin instead of cash, and it would work the exact same way as a traditional bank with exactly the same advantages and problems. But if you're writing checks for Bitcoins instead of dollars which end up being processed entirely through a bank's internal ledger instead of through the Bitcoin network's blockchain... why? How is that really Bitcoin?
- pron 13y agoThank you. Maybe I will. I think Bitcoin can be a very good, very useful, universal micropayment platform, and that's about it (well, that's plenty, really). And you can loan Bitcoin just as you do any other form of money; it just requires trust. The problem with the more vociferous proponents of Bitcoin – and not only Bitcoin; you can see the same thing happen in the tech industry in discussions of women or minorities – is one of politics. The problem is this: many in the American tech industry don't know what politics is. According to Wikipedia, it "is the practice and theory of influencing other people on a civic or individual level;" it's a general term for managing powers and spheres of influence in society. Worse, they seem to shun it. But politics can't be avoided. It is essential to human society. When people shy away from politics, a dangerous thing happens: they practice bad politics based on naturalistic fallacies. I think science oriented folk are particularly prone to that because science concerns itself with what is, while politics concerns itself with what ought to be. Science people might, and do, come to believe that what is, is what ought to be (or the only way to be). In fact, Bitcoin is a very interesting example because it allows (actually, it is only imagined to allow) removing people out of the equation altogether, leaving algorithms. When you take power away from people and put it in the hands of mathematics you indeed lose politics (except, of course, for the original act of seizing that power). But then you lose a lot of what makes us human. I think that there is in Bitcoin a confluence of tech people falling into naturalistic fallacies with a general lack of trust in institutions that has possibly been growing of late among Americans. It is interesting to watch, but the arguments, unfortunately, are no different from the old American-libertarian anti-government, pro-gold, arguments. The difference, this time, is not in political awareness (of which there is a dire lack), but in – here's that word again – power. American libertarians traditionally had little power. They have been a small minority of both the general population and even of the rich and influential. But now technology is not only a power (which it always was), but one with exceptionally low barriers to attain. Bitcoin supporters, by virtue of their part in the powerful Silicon Valley sphere of influence, actually do carry a not-insignificant political weight. This will be interesting to watch. Whatever happens, even those who believe in institutions should welcome this challenge, because democratic institutions always benefit, in the long run, from worthwhile challenges. So far they've shown an incredible ability to adapt (though the rate still appears too slow to humans who only live about 80 years), and there's no reason to believe they will not evolve for the better as a result of this interesting challenge. It is interesting to watch.
- seabee 13y ago> I don't know about you, but my institutions aren't failing. They just require regular maintenance. There's the rub: do they get the regular maintenance they require, and who foots the bill when it breaks? What are the incentives to do so, and the consequences if you don't? I don't believe institutions are 'failing' in the sense that they cannot operate, but that they are a net loss to society. The trustless economy is a response to the lack of trust in those who control the economy - whether by enacting policy or being too-big-to-fail - to operate for the greater good of society. It is not about distrusting people, it's that you shouldn't need to trust people. You may evade or buy your way out of the laws of the land, but you can never escape the laws of mathematics. Of course the economy runs a lot better when you can trust everyone. There also exist better forms of government, if you ignore human fallibility or selfishness. But it's not about abolishing institutions, even if the purpose is to obsolete certain types.
- pron 13y ago> You may evade or buy your way out of the laws of the land, but you can never escape the laws of mathematics. Very true, but the laws of mathematics don't have feelings, desires or empathy. That might be good, except for one thing: we're human and we do. As people, we should want to have the freedom to decide our own fate, not put it in the hands of an alien entity. That entity might be right but it won't be right for us.
- shadowmint 13y agoWhat are you even talking about now? Seriously, some of the stuff you were saying in other comments actually made sense, but all you're doing is losing credibility when you go off the deep end and start with the 'fear the machine' nonsense. Take a deep breath, go get some food or something; you don't have to reply to every single comment. (...and a considered comment is worth 10 flash responses that haven't been thought out~)
- Xdes 13y ago>As people, we should want to have the freedom to decide our own fate, not put it in the hands of an alien entity. This is what I don't understand about your argument: the governance of cryptocurrencies is the same democracy you're advocating elsewhere. The difference is replacing the fallible human element with a set of mathematical rules. Noone is saying the rules cannot change (or altcoins would not exist). The entire purpose of the cryptocurrency experiment is to find rules that everyone will like and aren't based promises from politicians, corporatists, or plutocrats.