6 ms·
Oh, dear Lord. It's comments like this that make people skeptical about Bitcoin in the first place, because it demonstrates that BTC supporters don't understand
by pron 13y ago
Oh, dear Lord. It's comments like this that make people skeptical about Bitcoin in the first place, because it demonstrates that BTC supporters don't understand what the economy, or even money, is.
Ok, when I studied history many years ago, I took a class in early modern Europe (think 15-16th centuries). That was when modern capitalism first gradually appeared. The most important thing to understand about the origins of modern capitalism is the change in society it required. That change was the transition from a face-to-face society (where you personally knew all the people you transacted with) to a society of strangers, where you had to put faith not only in complete strangers, but in people whom you'd never met and never would meet. Most importantly, you had to put faith in institutions. That was when the first institutions started, modeled after the oldest institution of all, the Roman Catholic Church. There was a time when there were no institutions (well, other than the church). People couldn't even understand the concept of an institution: they knew there was a guy named John and a guy named Paul, but what the hell is a group of people that has an identity of its own, and lasts more than its members?
Anyway, modern capitalism required institutions, most important among which were banks and insurers. Insurers reduced risks and encouraged investment while bankers lent money to support such investments. Now, when you put your money in the bank, it has to be loaned to others, otherwise the economy will come to a standstill. You have to put faith in the bank to get the money back to you. Same with insurance. You have to have faith in the insurer to pay your claim, or, at the very least, faith in the court to compel the insurer to pay up.
The way you look at BTC, disconnects money, a central instrument in the economy, from the economy at large. That doesn't make sense, and even if no one ever steals your money, your money won't "work", because there will be no economy to use it in. A modern economy is built on trust. Trust that in the long run, most people will be honest because that's what's best for them, and they know it. If we don't have trust in institutions, there will be no economy to speak of, or, rather, there will be a very primitive one (only, this time, with computers). In that case, I suggest you take good care of your machine, because in your utopia there will be no new models coming out. Sheesh, how some people, in time of crisis, cling to their laptops and algorithms.
- jnbiche 13y agoArgh! It's comments like this that make me wonder if you history buffs out there will ever understand that we're entering a new phase of economic history: a trustless one. All of these spectacular exchange failures out there have nothing to do with Bitcoin itself. Go read up on trustless cryptographic systems, and understand that we're entering a different era. The failures that occur around the periphery of Bitcoin are nothing more than a fault line between the old system (trust in failing institutions) to a new one (trustless). Signed, A humanities major back in college (yeah, I studied economic history, too)
- eterm 13y ago"The trustless economy" must be like "the paperless office" because everywhere I look around Bitcoin I see people losing money because they trusted someone.
- arethuza 13y ago"have nothing to do with Bitcoin itself" While that is technically correct, don't you think to most people Bitcoin is rather more than the protocol - it is the entire eco-system of applications and services that have been built over the last few years. If the "fault line" between this "trustless economy" and the vastly larger "normal" economy isn't pretty painless then I can't see much of a future for Bitcoin and exchanges seem to be a pretty important part of that interface.
- pron 13y agoBut algorithms don't create an economy – people do (and I actually have a degree in Mathematics). I don't have a problem with Bitcoin being hacked: that can and will be fixed. I do have a problem with the very notion of a "trustless" economy for two reasons: first, there ain't no such thing (it's like a worshipper-free religion). Economy equals trust. An economy needs credit and it needs insurance, and you can't have those without trust (heck, the word "credit" literally means "to believe"). Second, even if you could imagine such a thing, where a robot would compel you to pay up, or an algorithm would make decisions for you, why in god's name would you even want to? Why take away the freedom of people to come together and make collective decisions about the economy (say, like devaluating a currency) for their society's benefit? Why, because some people are crooks? The kind of society you picture is, literally, an autistic one. While you don't want people to think that Bitcoin is failing after ceaseless thefts, you call our institutions "failing" based on what? I don't know about you, but my institutions aren't failing. They just require regular maintenance. Also, if you think Bitcoin is about creating a new kind of trustless economy (in other words, the very same economy that existed prior to the modern one or in lawless frontiers like the Wild West), you are mistaken in believing that most people will follow you. That is precisely the libertarian politics that hangs around Bitcoin's neck, and if anything will choke it, this will be it. Forget about who's right and who's wrong. The reality is that most freedom-loving people aren't libertarian. They like their institutions and want to fix them. They don't want a trustless economy. We may be misguided; we might be wrong; but we're the vast, vast majority. And if you like history, you probably know that people have been warning about the collapse of modern institutions pretty much since their inception. There were always those who wanted to grab their gold and head for the hills because the system is falling apart. And let me tell you that there were times the system was close to crumbling, but today we're not even close to such a big crisis. Nevertheless, the vast majority of people have put their faith in their institutions, and for about 500 years now, they've been right (well, more or less).