6 ms·
As a Microsoft customer, this alienates me from them. Paid software means that our interests are aligned: I want good software and Microsoft wants to make good
by skrebbel 13y ago
As a Microsoft customer, this alienates me from them. Paid software means that our interests are aligned: I want good software and Microsoft wants to make good software so that I buy it.
Free commercial software means that I'll have to pay through other means, typically means that I'll have less control over.
- beagle3 13y agoYour interest and Microsoft's interests haven't been aligned in years. Your interest is to keep an OS supported. Microsoft's interest is to release Browser and DirectX updates only for the latest-and-greatest, so that you'd updgrade. Your interest is an open ecosystem. Microsoft's interest is to have a closed garden. (They haven't been successful with that one, but they're trying). Your interest might be a usable Desktop OS like Win7. Microsoft's interest is to ram their touch interface down your throat so that you'd get used to it, and your next phone may possibly run Windows - regardless of what's good for you. Your interest is a usable system that just works. Microsoft's interest is providing a "Protected Media Path" that would degrade your experience if your equipment is not xIAA certified. You already have NO control. You're already paying through other means. You might have had an illusion of control taken away from you - but that's a good thing.
- superuser2 13y ago>Your interest is to keep an OS supported. That's not true. It's in your interest to benefit from improvements in software quality. (Certain "upgrades" from Microsoft have been anything but that, but we've certainly come a long way since Windows ME.) A product encumbered by technical debt is going to be weaker. There are certain well-defined, self-contained systems where never changing makes sense - things that will run for decades, like lab instruments and life-critical industrial automation. General purpose computing isn't one of them.
- beagle3 13y agoYou copied half of my paragraph. I was specifically referring to Microsoft refusing to support DirectX and new Browsers on older operating systems. The limitation was definitely not technical - Chrome and Firefox supported 2000 and XP years after Microsoft stopped. > > Your interest is to keep an OS supported. > That's not true. That's basically always true (even if you quoted me out of context) - it is always your interest to upgrade at your leisure. Unless you are of the general belief that you should be forced to do things that are considered good for you (e.g. forced physical exercise, forced removal of sugar or salt from dishes, etc)
- yuhong 13y agoMS has not done the old DirectX redists since 9.0c.
- superuser2 13y agoBut it is technical. IE, Chrome, and Firefox are different codebases and what's true of one isn't necessarily true of the others. Chrome and Firefox are largely self-contained. Being multi-platform, they have to be. It makes sense that they can be modified without touching their underlying operating systems. You keep calling IE "Browser" but it's more than that - it is (or at least used to be) a core component of Windows, and very tightly coupled with parts of the operating system that have nothing to do with web browsing. (Navigating local files, for one thing.) Consequently, overhauling IE without overhauling Windows is (or at least was) a hairy proposition and Microsoft decided it wasn't worth it. I don't know about DirectX, but I suspect it's also tightly coupled with the operating system such that it's not technically feasible to make current versions run on differently engineered operating systems.
- jejones3141 13y agoAnd that tight coupling was done for political reasons back in the antitrust suit days, to make it impossible to have Windows without IE.
- eropple 13y ago
- nivla 13y ago>Your interest is an open ecosystem. Microsoft's interest is to have a closed garden. (They haven't been successful with that one, but they're trying). I might get some heat for this but I must say Windows is still the OS with the least closed garden or heck even a garden. To get even the legitimate and popular x86 applications you still have to manually browse to websites and download it. You can install whatever you want whether it has a digital signature or not and yes it also includes the plentitude of crapwares and spywares. >Your interest might be a usable Desktop OS like Win7. Microsoft's interest is to ram their touch interface down your throat so that you'd get used to it. Or maybe some people like a touch OS with their touchscreen laptop and its just MS thinking forward? I don't know what other OS can you recommend that is touch friendly for my Surface pro? >You already have NO control. You're already paying through other means. You might have had an illusion of control taken away from you - but that's a good thing. No sure what you mean by this. I don't see MS cloud apps and ads preinstalled on my OS. I don't see it being sponsored by Amazon shopping experience either. The only crap that comes pre installed is done by the manufactures but MS can't even do anything about it, thanks to the anti-trust decisions.
- bytefactory 13y ago> I might get some heat for this but I must say Windows is still the OS with the least closed garden or heck even a garden. Surely you meant "OS with a significant market share" or something, because there's no way Windows is more "open" in any way than Linux!
- roel_v 13y agoAt least it's more reliable as a platform. Try to compile, let alone run, a program written for Linux 5 years ago on a distribution today. I compile and run 20 year old software, unmodified, on Windows 8, without any problems.
- pjc50 13y agoWhat? This usually works just fine. The only area where it doesn't is Gnome, who like making breaking changes. Quite a lot of the core tools (shellutils) are 20+ years old with only minor updates.
- csense 13y ago> Microsoft's interest is to ram their touch interface down your throat so that you'd get used to it, and your next phone may possibly run Windows s/Microsoft/Canonical/ s/Windows/Ubuntu/
- mercurial 13y agoOn the other hand, a different ui is one apt-get away in Ubuntu. It's much less trivial on Windows.
- beagle3 13y agoTrue. Except ... I'm not paying Ubuntu for my desktop OS; and I would for my server, except they're taking it where I don't want it to go, so I don't. And ... if you don't like Ubuntu's Unity (many people don't), Gnome, KDE, Enlightenment and ten other desktop environments are basically an apt-get away. Remind me, what was the command to get rid of The-UI-formerly-known-as-Metro and use the desktop instead?
- kamaal 13y ago>>ten other desktop environments are basically an apt-get away. This one thing you should never do. I once tried to apt-get shift to KDE from GNOME and then could never get Network to work ever again. After searching the internet the only feasible option seemed to be to back up all data and reinstall the OS.
- beagle3 13y agoI used to do it regularly before I settled on my current setup. Never had a problem. I'm not sure what you did, but all it SHOULD do (and in fact, did, for me) was add another session to the login manager. I didn't remove anything, and I can still choose my desktop environment from the list on every log-in.
- honestcoyote 13y agoSet Windows 8 to boot to desktop and then install Classic Shell. Metro / Modern is now gone except for the occasional control panel which uses it.
- RyanZAG 13y agoMicrosoft is a business. Their interests and your interests have never and will never be aligned. They may occasionally release products which can solve your needs - but their interest in this case is to extract the maximum amount of money from you in exchange for solving your need. Solving the need has never been an explicit interest in itself. Moving to an advertising based pricing model doesn't change any alignment. They still need to fulfill your need or you won't use their software which means they won't get paid by advertisers. They still don't have your interests at heart, but will not do anything to directly lose you as a 'customer' if they believe there are methods of extracting revenue from you. Microsoft's main customer base has never been the end user anyway, you were merely collateral to getting them inroads into the lucrative enterprise markets which requires that employees coming into enterprise positions are already familiar with Microsoft's technology.
- sliverstorm 13y agoTheir interests and our interest may not have been aligned, but at least the user was the customer. In an ad supported model, the advertiser is the customer, the users are the product, and the software is the bait. We've already seen where that gets us.
- jejones3141 13y agoYou're not the customer for Windows, at least not an important one. The OEMs are the customers for Windows.
- ekianjo 13y ago> Microsoft is a business. Their interests and your interests have never and will never be aligned. They may occasionally release products which can solve your needs - but their interest in this case is to extract the maximum amount of money from you in exchange for solving your need. Solving the need has never been an explicit interest in itself. You can say the same thing for every business then. I don't think you see it in the proper light. A business is a for profit organization. It does not mean it does not strive to provide valuable services. Actually, you'll see that when companies actually evolve in a relatively free market (i.e. which is not the case of Windows since it's installed by default on most PCs), companies actually compete to provide better service to their customers in order to maximize their profits. There are many cases where consumers interests and companies interests CAN be aligned.
- chaostheory 13y agoI wouldn't fret. Looking at history, MS will probably release several versions of Windows including paid versions. Microsoft's biggest strength and weakness is that they want to cater to everyone at the same time.
- aegiso 13y agoEnd-user Windows licenses haven't been a significant source of income for Microsoft for a very long time. They make their money from their enterprise ecosystem, and end-user Windows serves only to support that ecosystem. So unfortunately, I hate to break it to you that as an end user the money you're giving Microsoft for their products never gave you control. But on the bright side, pissing off the end users that provide sustenance and influx for their volume-licenses cash cows doesn't serve Microsoft's bottom line either. So even if you pay nothing, your usage of Microsoft's products is very much something Microsoft would prefer to continue.
- Aaronontheweb 13y ago> End-user Windows licenses haven't been a significant source of income for Microsoft for a very long time. If ~$20b in revenue last year isn't a big business... http://www.microsoft.com/investor/EarningsAndFinancials/Earnings/PressReleaseAndWebcast/FY13/Q4/default.aspx http://www.microsoft.com/investor/EarningsAndFinancials/Earn... 65% of that $20b comes from OEMs, which is 100% consumer. edit: the exact quote from the earnings statement I linked: "Excluding the impact of the Windows Upgrade Offer, OEM revenue decreased 15%, and was approximately 65% of total Windows Division revenue." Windows Enterprise licenses are managed separately - even if Wells Fargo orders 12,000 new laptops from Dell, Windows licensing is not factored into the price; WF manages that separately through its enterprise relationship directly with Microsoft.
- tanzam75 13y ago> 65% of that $20b comes from OEMs, which is 100% consumer. No, OEM is not 100% consumer. It's not even half. A large number of OEM machines are sold with Pro preloaded. These go to businesses. (Some consumers buy Pro, but some small businesses buy Home. Assume it more or less averages out.) Last quarter, Windows OEM revenues overall decreased by just 3%, despite the fact that non-Pro OEM revenues decreased by 20%. Why? Because Pro revenues increased by 12%! In fact, the slides even said: "Windows OEM Pro revenue up 12%, driven by higher Windows Pro mix in large enterprises and developed markets." So they explicitly acknowledge that enterprise customers are included in OEM revenue. If you do the algebra, Pro now accounts for 61% of OEM revenues. That means that Home accounts for 39%. $20 billion * 0.97 * 0.65 * 0.39 = $4.92 billion. $4.92 billion in a company that took in $73.7 billion of revenues in fiscal year 2013. For comparison, Bing had revenues of $3.2 billion in fiscal year 2013.
- sdegutis 13y agoNot necessarily. They may be giving away their platform to encourage the ecosystem that surrounds it (to both consumers and developers), which is probably much more valuable than the OS itself.
- brudgers 13y agoMy take is that Microsoft is shifting its consumer strategy away from expressing core B2B values and toward the you are the product model loved by Wall Street and used by Apple and Google and Facebook and just about everyone else. It's part of the generational shift and the radical change to ownership and thereby control that is underway. Gates and Ballmer are divesting their shares and that means that the new Microsoft has to make Wall Street analysts happy in a way that a company whose CEO and Chairman are the two largest shareholders doesn't. The writing was on the wall with Windows 8. It wanted persistent login to Microsoft servers and to produce tailored content via persistent tracking. Whatever doubt I had was gone when Windows 8.1 rolled back my choice of local login without asking and buried the means of changing deeper than before. Topping it off was that 8.1 ignored the fact that the login name I entered as default was the valid local login I had used to start installation. I've been using MS operating systems since DOS 3.3. The first version of Windows I worked with was 2.0 [only for a customized workflow on an Amiga 2000 with bridgeboard, though]. It's been Windows full time since 3.0 because I've never felt that Microsoft's approach was caveat emptor. Now I can't say that. I fear they are becoming like everyone else.