11 ms·
Can you explain what you mean by "a lack of a MW is welfare?"
by yummyfajitas 13y ago
Can you explain what you mean by "a lack of a MW is welfare?"
- dllthomas 13y ago"welfare for noneconomic businesses" My reading is "subsidy, because they can get labor at below what it's actually worth", which is not necessarily a claim I would make but it doesn't seem incoherent.
- dredmorbius 13y agoNot "below what it's worth" but "below its real cost". "Worth" is a sticky word in that it presumes the market sets value above provision cost. In the short term, this isn't necessarily the case, and given distortions, e.g., provisioning of an encumbered labor class such as undocumented aliens (who would tend to be averse to seeking legal remedies or unionization), or young and naive labor (as is typical in startups), or of a labor class with significant barriers to desirable employment (persons with conviction or drugs records, with poor credit scores, discriminated minorities, etc.), the "short term" can exist for a quite considerable period, possibly decades or centuries.
- dllthomas 13y agoI wasn't committing to any particular definition of "worth". Certainly they're not getting it at below market value, but that's not an interesting statement...
- yummyfajitas 13y agoCan you then define the "real cost" of labor? Surely it's not subsistence, since that's only a few dollars/day.
- dredmorbius 13y agoI've just referenced the Federal poverty rate elsewhere: $11,670 for an individual, $23,850 for a family of four. http://familiesusa.org/product/federal-poverty-guidelines http://familiesusa.org/product/federal-poverty-guidelines (the numbers cited previously are apparently pre-2014 and are slightly lower). There are criticisms of the calculation of this (it's weighted for food, housing and transport costs are a much large component now than when the index was first created), but it would correspond to $5.84 for an individual, $11.93 for a family of four. In the latter case, I'd assume one parent is working less than full time. By either measure, and with the requirement that subsistence cover both the worker's and their childrens' living costs, the present federal minimum wage is below subsistence. How do you figure a few dollars per day for someone within the US?
- yummyfajitas 13y agoWhere I am located, many millions of people subsist on 100 rupees/day. Adjusting that for purchasing power yields about 6-8 USD. Granted, I'm not living a place where 75% of the poor own a car, 45% of the poor own their own home, and 67% have at least 2 rooms per person [1]. I'm not in a place where even the middle or upper class have all those luxuries. Yet somehow, in spite of living below what you would call subsistence, there is no mass die-off over here. In any case, I now understand that by "subsistence", you actually mean "subsistence plus an expanding basket of luxuries." (As I'm sure you know, the federal poverty line measures a fraction of average consumption which has gone up over time, not a fixed basket of goods.) And apparently, some of those luxuries include living in highly desirable areas like NY or SF, which even the federal government doesn't include. When you use common terms in such non-standard ways, it helps the reader to clearly define what you mean. In any case, your factual claim regarding "obtaining an input at less than the cost of production" is clearly wrong, as a simple look at other countries will prove that labor can be produced at far lower cost (adjusting for PPP) than the US minimum wage. [1] http://www.census.gov/prod/2008pubs/h150-07.pdf http://www.census.gov/prod/2008pubs/h150-07.pdf
- dredmorbius 13y agoI'm aware that the standard of living, including what's considered poverty, is much lower outside the OECD / G7 / G20 nations. Simply put: for the most part that wouldn't constitute a sufficient standard of living to interact with the working world in the US without imposing significant handicaps of opportunity. The reality is that it's not only the ceiling that's higher in the US than in India, but the floor. The cost of living -- food, shelter, clothing, services -- is simply higher in the US. You're arguing against US Federal standards for poverty, quite standard definitions, by the way, and which, contrary to your assertion, are not normalized for high-cost coastal cities (as I indicated: the costs would be higher there, and living at the poverty line would be distinctly challenging). Living expenses vary across the US pretty markedly. I'm not finding a direct link to lists, but city-data.com has some good lists of various demographics by city: http://www.city-data.com/toplists.html http://www.city-data.com/toplists.html http://www.city-data.com/ http://www.city-data.com/ As for San Francisco: supposing you do happen to live there, the cheapest available housing will run around $200/week or $800/month per room. Few properties will let you have an unlimited number of tenants, so figure on 2-3 people per room maximum, the higher values only if you've got young children. Cost of living also tends to correspond to earning potential. And while housing might be slightly less expensive further out, you'll need transportation: BART will run $15 /day or so, for much of the US car ownership is all but necessary, carrying with it gasoline, registration, insurance, parking, and other costs. I don't doubt you could establish a lower prevailing subsistence wage in India, but it's not directly comparable to what the same lower bound would be in the US.
- dredmorbius 13y agoI believe you'll find that adequately addressed in my linked blog post, however, given that: • Labor has a natural disadvantage to employers in wage negotiations (see Smith), exacerbated often by additional illegal disadvantages (see current wage price cap collusion by Silicon Valley firms), • That below-subsistence wages are not sustainable, that is, they don't cover the full costs of providing labor, and • That a business which cannot cover the costs of its inputs is, ipso facto, uneconomic, then • Failing to require businesses meet the full costs of their inputs, and offshifting that cost onto labor, corresponds to a net subsidy of an uneconomic business by labor. This presumes that the minimum wage is set to cover the subsistence rate, which is to say, the rate at which a laborer can support both themselves and their immediate family: nonworking spouse if required for maintenance of household and raising of children, and of children, their upkeep, and education.
- yummyfajitas 13y agoI read your post, but the only part of it that I can find which remotely addresses my question is: "A man must always live by his work, and his wages must at least be sufficient to maintain him." So if that's the relevant piece, you are asserting that it's welfare for an employer to pay a man less than a few dollars/day (i.e., subsistence) in wages? That still doesn't explain what you mean by "welfare".
- dredmorbius 13y agoWhat part of "obtaining an input at less than the cost of production due to uncorrected market imbalances" don't you understand?
- dllthomas 13y agoyummyfajitas is (explicitly) interpreting "cost of production of labor" to be "subsistence wages" (and has asked for alternatives if that's not what is meant). Minimum wage is quite a bit more than subsistence wages in most places, and quite a bit less than what's typically referred to as a "living wage" - particularly if we're including raising children.