7 ms·
OH, god, this is incredibly stupid. This is not the way to fix the economy. The primary real value of money is that it reduces friction in trade so you don't ha
by Mz 13y ago
OH, god, this is incredibly stupid. This is not the way to fix the economy. The primary real value of money is that it reduces friction in trade so you don't have to jump through multiple complicated hoops to trade, say, your coding skills for a steak dinner. You trade your coding skills for money and then take money to the restaurant instead of going to the steak dinner maker and asking what he wants and then finding someone who will give you that in exchange for coding.
Money symbolizes value. Other than lubricating trade, which has real value, in itself, it doesn't really "do" anything. You can't eat it. You can't build a house out of it. If burning it to keep warm makes some kind of economic sense, then the economy is seriously fubarred.
This kind of financial manipulation does not fix any of the underlying issues that lead to financial problems. Financial problems grow out of real problems. I can testify to that first hand: I am deeply in debt and homeless due to medical problems, in essence. I am fixing my medical problems. As my medical problems resolve, my expenses come down and my productivity goes up. My debts are slowly being paid down.
We need to fix real problems, underlying root cause problems. This kind of superficial manipulation is not a fix.
Oh, god, no. I can't believe I am seeing this stupidity being taken seriously.
- dllthomas 13y agoEconomies are made up of individuals; they aren't themselves individuals. Unless you think that there was a rash of major medical issues in 2009, I'm not sure how your experience is relevant or why you think it generalizes.
- Mz 13y agoMy experience here does not have to "generalize" and isn't really meant to. More like an attempt to give a concrete example on a small scale that perhaps people can relate to more readily. When Europe sent people to "The New World" and tons of silver was shipped back to Europe, the result was ridiculous inflation. Historically, when you inject more money into an economy but not more goods and services, not more intelligence, not more real value, the result is inflation. Prices go up because there is more money but not more stuff to buy with it. I don't know how help you understand how ridiculous this idea is if you think dismissing my personal experience somehow proves my point wrong. It doesn't. The point can be made other ways. I just happen frequently speak from firsthand personal experience in part because it was part of the culture of a very respected list I once belonged to where the standard was 1) speak from firsthand experience or 2) cite your sources.
- lotsofmangos 13y agoThe USA has just had a period of quantitative easing, which injected a load of newly made up money into the economy. The inflation rate is about 1.5% after doing this. If you are going to predict massive inflation from increasing the money supply, where is it? It should surely be here by now.
- obsurveyor 13y agoIt hasn't? Check the price of milk. Check the price of beef. Compare the price per ounce of packaged food in 2008 vs. today. Compare the price of anything that isn't included in the "official" numbers for inflation and you see a much different story about inflation. Put another way, it used to be a mystery: "Why do hotdogs come in packages of 10 and buns in packages of 8?" now you should be asking "Why do hotdogs come in packages of 8 and I still pay the same amount as 10?"
- dllthomas 13y agohttp://www.fao.org/worldfoodsituation/foodpricesindex/en/?_=1393604860591 http://www.fao.org/worldfoodsituation/foodpricesindex/en/?_=... Your claims do not reflect my personal experience, and do not seem to be very well substantiated.
- rayiner 13y agoThats a bad argument, because food products are heavily dependent on the price of fuel, and that has gone up because of: geopolitical instability, limited supply, and explosive demand in developing countries. QE didn't cause increasing demand for oil in China. The price of food and fuel would have gone up relative to other things regardless. Inflation from an increase in money supply will manifest in a way that cuts across industry sectors. Cars, computers, and personal services would be getting more expensive. They're not. Look at the price of BMW's U.S. entry level 3 series. In 2004 it was $28k MSRP. BLS estimate for 2014 using official inflation is $35k MSRP. Actual is $38k MSRP (under 2.5 percent) for what is for various reasons a lot more car (50 more horsepower, bigger, safer, more fuel efficient). If it weren't for tighter emissions requirements since 2004, inflation in the price of cars would probably be below the general inflation rate.
- nawitus 13y agoBasic income is social security that works. Just to be clear, are you against social security?
- Mz 13y agoSocial security (as in the American retirement thing called "social security") is a form of retirement income. It is based on the idea of paying in over time and getting something back in old age. Such systems run into problems in countries with low birth rates because you hit a point where the working age youth are overly burdened with taxes to support the elderly. I don't currently have a solution. But I am clear that just paying everyone money that you manufacture essentially out of thin air is a disincentive to actually work. It may inject short term liquidity into the system but it won't solve the real problem. I think some kind of basic income might be useful to level out the haves and have nots and redress some things but $2000/mo is more than a full time minimum wage job pays currently. I think it would cause a lot of people to see no reason to work. If people quit jobs to live on the government dole, this could actively harm the current system rather than improving things.
- 21echoes 13y ago> it won't solve the real problem. you keep saying this. what, in your mind, is the real problem? the article lays out a very clear real problem in its view: lack of aggregate demand. they then offer a solution to fix said problem. if you disagree with the article, please at least point out what you think the problem is. proposing a solution would also be nice...
- Mz 13y agoI suggested two underlying real problems in the U.S. here very recently: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7315440 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7315440 I don't know what all the solutions are but I am confident that one of the problems is Peak Oil. Some of the solutions for that include passive solar design, living closer to work, shopping closer to home, improving pedestrian-friendliness of built environments and improving public transit. The health issue: I don't like Obama Care. Making people pay for insurance just shifts who pays. It doesn't make people healthier. Some of the solutions for making people healthier include: Pedestrian friendly built environments which promote more walking, better education, less pollution. I don't have all the answers. I am applying the answers that I know work to my own life. I gave up my car several years ago. Most of the time, I walk everywhere. I moved a location with good public transit and I use public transit when I don't walk. I am getting myself healthier. I know these are things that work because I am applying them to my own life, though I was just told that my personal example is irrelevant and doesn't generalize. That sort of dismissiveness is something I am commonly met with. If people don't want to believe me, they don't have to. I will continue to do what works for myself because I know it works, regardless of how many nay-sayers I run into. It is getting results.
- paperwork 13y agoI don't see your point. I'm no economist but from what I read in the article, are you disagreeing with the premise, that aggregate demand is low, or the solution, that giving money directly to citizens will increase increase spending? I understand your point about the purpose of money, but don't see how the idea of bypassing tax credits or tax breaks and directly giving money to people is stupid.
- Mz 13y agoPeople are living creatures with minds and wills of their own. They are not merely cogs in the economic engine. You can't control what they do when you decide to just give out money and money only represents value. You don't create value by printing money. In countries with low birth rates, you see that government retirement programs are killing the economy. Government retirement programs are based on the idea of older people having earned this. But someone has to do the work to provide the goods and services being purchased. If no one is required to work, a lot of people won't work. People who win the lottery are typically bankrupt within 5 years (about 2/3s of them, IIRC, go bankrupt). A lot of people, if given money, 1) promptly quit their jobs and 2) promptly fill their empty hours with consumptive activities, not productive ones. I do not see this fixing anything. In the long term, it is likely to bankrupt the system because of disencentivizing productive activity and turning people into consumers with an entitled attitude.
- dllthomas 13y agoWe aren't giving people lottery jackpots. If you look at examples where they've actually done this in the small, people spend the money "well". In particular, a lump some of ~$1000 given to 13 long-term homeless individuals in London (http://www.economist.com/node/17420321 http://www.economist.com/node/17420321) saw 11 of them off the streets a year later, and the Mincome experiment in Manitoba only saw modest decrease in hours worked (most dramatically among new parents, which strikes me as a positive outcome).
- vladd 13y agoIncome inequality (savers are from within the big earners group) coupled with automation of low-skilled work will lead to a society where capital is concentrated in the hands of few (the high class), intelligence defines the middle class workers but a significant part of the population won't have neither the capital nor the work aptitudes to contribute in meaningful ways to the society. If most of our needs are covered by capital and robots, we will evolve to ensure a minimum level of services provided by the society to every human person alive (or else people will starve to death). Even their potential transition into niche areas with low skills and poor robot automation (e.g. arts and entertainment businesses) would require assets to sustain their education and living facilities. While I can see how the idea of minimal income might be controversial, I doubt you could fairly label it "incredibly stupid".
- gnaritas 13y ago> Financial problems grow out of real problems. Yes, one of those problems is that the labor based distribution of resources is going to fail long term because we simply won't need all that human labor. Jobs are not simply being replaced with different jobs; they're being eliminated entirely. Nothing you've said addresses that problem and that problem is what a basic income is trying to address.
- Mz 13y agoHistorically, we addressed this by being supportive of families in a way that no longer exists. If you just give everyone money without tying it to anything other than citizenship here, you are failing to encentivize positive behaviors. Creating more pro-family laws and culture would help. A stay-at-home-parent provides value to both the family and the economy without earning money but is not just a "welfare case" either. We have done a lot in the U.S. to undermine families. Reversing that position would do the economy a lot of good and help address the issue of a world where not everyone "needs" to work but everyone needs resources to sustain themselves.
- gnaritas 13y agoWhat does that have anything to do with anything I said? I'm talking about how to make an economy work in a post scarcity world where labor isn't necessary; that has literally nothing to do with families. Creating more pro-family laws does nothing to help with post scarcity. We have not had this problem in the past, so looking to the past for solutions does nothing, there are no past solutions to a world that doesn't need labor. This is not an issue that in any way relates to families or the undermining of families. Honestly, it's like you just make random responses that don't address anything said to you.
- Mz 13y agoNo, I am not making up random responses. I am all for real national health coverage (not Obamacare). That would accomplish some of the things this is intended to accomplish. Historically, it was more feasible for a nuclear family to have one breadwinner supporting multiple members in part because family medical coverage was more common. One of the things that keeps young women with children in the work force is that family medical coverage has become relatively scarce. Most women who have small children feel conflicted about working and wish the could either work only part time or be home with their child. They work in part to retain medical coverage. Homemakers and dependent children (who can be young adults -- like college students) are technically "unemployed" but are not simply cut off from societal resources. I am sorry you do not see that but it is at least a partial answer to the issue of distributing resources to non-working members of society in a way that does not destroy the social fabric or economy.
- panarky 13y agoCounter-intuitive concepts might seem stupid at first, but if you think through the mechanics you might see that it could actually work. For me, I have to remind myself that money is just a social construct. The real economy consists of people working and deploying physical plant and equipment to create things other people want. Today we find that the real economy has a lot of idle resources. People who want to work don't have jobs. Factories and equipment are idle or under-utilized. If spreading some green pieces of paper around will get the real economy moving again, the standard of living for most people will rise. It seems wrong at first glance, but it's even more wrong to allow all these resources to waste away, unused, when so much could be done.
- Mz 13y agoThe problem is that it is like pouring water evenly over the surface of the globe, removing both oceans and continents. Yes, we need to find a way to more fairly and humanely distribute the available resources. I just don't think this is really it. If you tie it to nothing, it isn't likely to work or be sustainable. What will it be tied to in order to ensure that it doesn't just wreck the economy? That piece seems to go unaddressed. My understanding is that in Alaska, everyone gets a check instead of paying taxes but it is because of the Alaska oil pipeline. When that pipeline runs dry. so will the "free money." It comes from somewhere. It doesn't just get printed out of thin air. Oil gets sold, the state redistributes the money to its citizens. It isn't just some magical manipulation on paper because money is relatively abstract, so people seem to think manipulating it really works. No, it really doesn't.
- nzp 13y agoSelling something (in this case oil) doesn't really make a difference. You haven't explained how is it different, you just said that it is different. All else being equal, what would change if Alaska just printed the money it now gets from selling oil? Because in current situation there is still some excess money that gets distributed "for free", so let's abstract the source of this money, and see if there is something wrong going on with Alaskan economy because of this "free money" being distributed.
- 13y ago
- zacinbusiness 13y agoYou also clearly have access to an internet capable machine and, apparently, a job as you are paying your debts. So you're already better off than millions of unemployed and truly homeless people who have neither of those advantages. You also seem to have a sound command of the written word, meaning you are educated and mentally sound. Two more advantages lacked by many. So in your case I feel certain that a little extra cash would go a long way, even though you seem to resist it. In the case of others, it's amazing how far a warm meal and a place to call your own can go. I did charity work setting up computer systems for a free clinic and they also worked to find homeless people housing and honest, safe work. And these people who were mentally and physically able to work (true homelessness is devastating to the mind and the body) could turn their lives around and enter society much more easily if they could also afford some counseling and some basic luxurious that most of us really take for granted.