4 ms·
We've been dealing with DDOS attacks affecting mainstream citizens and businesses of 1st world countries for about a decade now. Why isn't there law enforcement
by stcredzero 13y ago
We've been dealing with DDOS attacks affecting mainstream citizens and businesses of 1st world countries for about a decade now. Why isn't there law enforcement dedicated to catching people who do this? We're at a point where CEOs of companies can engage in such behavior and the companies can stay in business.
If there is someone reading this who works with a US congressman or senator, this may be a chance to introduce legislation that can make a positive impact, make it easier to establish Internet-facing companies, and instead of eliciting dismay from the community of technical people, gain their gratitude instead.
- higherpurpose 13y agoYes, and then NSA will say "Sure, we'll protect you. You just have to give us access and control to your whole network and servers, because that's the only way to 'properly protect you'. Deal?" This is exactly what these agencies want. To give up on your responsibility for the security of your users, so they can take over. If your company does that, please tell me now so I know to avoid it forever. The solution is to better design anti-DDoS systems, not to let the government "handle it".
- redbad 13y agoThe NSA has nothing to do with the parent's proposal. Your entire reply is a non-sequitur.
- thisiswrong 13y agoActualy, the NSA - just like the CIA, is known to carry out false flag acttacks to achieve a certain outcome. This point should not be overlooked. In this case Meetup is a perfect NSA 'false-flag' target because it's not a financial institution (NSA ally), and yet is used by millions of people. Thus millions of people starting to ask if GCHQ/NSA will keep them 'safe' online.
- kbar13 13y agousername oddly relevant The FBI is responsible for "cyber" crimes.
- supersystem 13y agohttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Einstein_(US-CERT_program)#Einstein_3 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Einstein_(US-CERT_program)#Eins...
- eli 13y agoIt's already illegal -- what law would you have them pass? Also, my assumption is that most DDoS ransom demands are coming from overseas.
- dllthomas 13y agoMaking it a civil infraction to be running a computer used in such a thing might help.
- eli 13y agoThe idea being you would sue individual owners of botnet-infected computers? Not so sure about that.
- dllthomas 13y agoThe idea being they could be ticketed for using their hardware unsafely on public infrastructure, much like a speeding ticket - but I'd suggest lower amounts corresponding to the lower risk to lives.
- eli 13y agoUnlike speeders, I assume they are mostly unwitting and unwilling participants in the attack. Seems a bit unfair. Why not also sue Adobe for allowing the zero-day that led to the PC getting infected and added to a botnet?
- dllthomas 13y ago"Unlike speeders, I assume they are mostly unwitting and unwilling participants in the attack." If you don't check your vehicle and something falls off of it, you're responsible. For that matter, if you do check your vehicle and something falls off of it, you're responsible. You don't have to have "wittingly" or "willingly" done something for a ticket - negligence (even minor) is plenty. You're responsible for hardware you deploy. Edited to add: Also, plenty of speeding tickets are given to people who never said to themselves "I'm going to speed," but simply neglected to pay enough attention to either posted limits or their speedometer. I know that's been the case with the couple of speeding tickets I've received. So I'm not really sure it's "unlike speeders" at all. "Why not also sue Adobe for allowing the zero-day that led to the PC getting infected and added to a botnet?" In general, I don't think it makes sense for liability to start with the vendors because the risks and downside is determined primarily by the particular deployment. I've no problem with allowing the companies to offer indemnification for tickets caused by their failures, and if we went that route that's something users should demand (... while still allowing people to publish GPL software for those willing to accept the responsibility, without taking a huge financial risk).