3 ms·
I don't understand why the data being on "Google servers" is generating such outrage. Because Google's systems demonstrably aren't secure (see numerous recent
by Silhouette 13y ago
I don't understand why the data being on "Google servers" is generating such outrage.
Because Google's systems demonstrably aren't secure (see numerous recent discussions about NSA etc.) and therefore aren't an appropriate choice to transmit or store sensitive personal data under UK data protection rules.
- raldi 13y agoIs your concern that the NSA itself is targeting British health records? If so, what makes you think anyone else is better prepared for this adversary? Or, if you're talking about someone other than the NSA (which you allude to with your use of "etc"), then who is it? What are they going to do, and why do you feel it's demonstrably more likely to happen with the data on Google's servers? Where would you put the data instead, and how would this help reduce the likelihood of the scenario? "On a powered-down hard drive in a vault" doesn't count; presumably, PA was given the contract because the potential benefits of the research were believed to outweigh the privacy risks.
- Silhouette 13y agoThe NSA specifically isn't the point, though I do believe their blanket surveillance of the Internet (and the similar surveillance by other government spy agencies such as our own GCHQ) should be considered a hostile act and incur a proportionate response. I simply don't accept that there is any ethical legitimacy to such dragnet programmes or that they bring more benefit than the risk they obviously pose to free, peaceful, democratically governed civilisation. In any case, Google aren't a part of any government. They are a private, profit-making corporation, and they are in the business of collecting as much data on people as possible for their own benefit, and they evidently cannot comply with the restrictions on handing personal data required by UK law even if they want to. Providing this kind of treasure trove to them should be unthinkable.
- raldi 13y agoYou didn't answer any of my questions.
- Silhouette 13y agoI would leave the data in the hands of medical professionals who are subject to medical ethics and confidentiality, kept away from anyone who might have any other ambitions for it. And I would keep it within the range of European data protection law, which is in general considerably stronger (rightly so, IMHO) than the rules in places like the US, though in this particular case if HIPAA is relevant that may not actually be the case. Edit: Incidentally: presumably, PA was given the contract because the potential benefits of the research were believed to outweigh the privacy risks. That "belief" would be a huge assumption, for which I see little evidence in this specific case, nor any historical pattern to suggest it is reasonable. In any case, it was clearly a bad assumption with hindsight, because the privacy risks are evidently not merely risks at this point.
- raldi 13y ago> I would leave the data in the hands of medical professionals Presumably, the medical professionals aren't also IT professionals. If they want their data to be on a hard drive, and accessible via a network, using some apps, then some group of non-medical professionals is going to need to maintain those services. Who do you think that should be, and why do you think their systems would be more secure than Google's? > kept away from anyone who might have any other ambitions for it What ambitions are you implicitly accusing Google of having? Do you think Google's going to tap into their customers' private files and sell them to a third party? If not, then what's the actual, non-vague scenario you're worried about?
- wetafur 13y agoIf a malicious incident like the below happened then Google wouldn't even be liable, unlike data that is kept under UK control. From http://gawker.com/5637234/gcreep-google-engineer-stalked-teens-spied-on-chats http://gawker.com/5637234/gcreep-google-engineer-stalked-tee... In at least four cases, Barksdale spied on minors' Google accounts without their consent, according to a source close to the incidents. In an incident this spring involving a 15-year-old boy who he'd befriended, Barksdale tapped into call logs from Google Voice, Google's Internet phone service, after the boy refused to tell him the name of his new girlfriend, according to our source. After accessing the kid's account to retrieve her name and phone number, Barksdale then taunted the boy and threatened to call her. In other cases involving teens of both sexes, Barksdale exhibited a similar pattern of aggressively violating others' privacy, according to our source. He accessed contact lists and chat transcripts, and in one case quoted from an IM that he'd looked up behind the person's back. (He later apologized to one for retrieving the information without her knowledge.) In another incident, Barksdale unblocked himself from a Gtalk buddy list even though the teen in question had taken steps to cut communications with the Google engineer.