3 ms·
We are "hackers" who build things for others. They are "hackers" who take from others. We are to be encouraged and admired. They are to be caught and punishe
by edw519 17y ago
We are "hackers" who build things for others.
They are "hackers" who take from others.
We are to be encouraged and admired.
They are to be caught and punished.
We do the right thing no matter how hard it is.
They do the easy thing no matter how wrong it is.
We love turning nothing into something.
They love turning something into nothing.
We get a rush when we see something appear for the first time ever.
They get a rush when they see the same thing disappear again.
We will persevere no matter what it takes.
They will quit when no one notices anymore.
We will leave our mark.
They will take someone else's mark away.
Don't confuse us with them.
- Locke1689 17y agoActually, this is definitely Hacker News. Finding a way inside a system and beating it is interesting and clever. Actually doing so improperly is illegal and immoral, but that doesn't make the act of security penetration any less "hacker worthy."
- pbhj 17y agoMy Aunty shoulder surfed me the other day .. "you're not one of those there hackers are you [...]". So I got chance to explain hackers vs. crackers for the 100th time.
- dbz 17y agoI have explained the difference so many times that I've lost count. It's too bad hackers get such a bad rep.
- anigbrowl 17y agoFine. Fork:bricoleur-news|script_kiddie-news|ignoble_cracker-news
- cema 17y agoToo much pomposity. Modded down.
- theoneill 17y agoOh dear.
- tptacek 17y agoA strange response from a very smart person to a rather impressive technological achievement.
- edw519 17y agoMy response was not to the technological achievement, but to the ethics of it. I am always unimpressed with doing wrong things, not matter how impressed others are. Many people here at hn are capable of impressive cracking, but choose not to even go that way. I'm sure there are systems out there I could crack if I tried, probably quite a few for financial gain. But I dare not go there. That's one cherry that will never be popped. Say what you will about the technical merits of individual feats, but I'm much more impressed with someone who tackles the problems of other people and goes to work every day building something of use rather than shooting fish in a barrel, which much cracking is. I stand by every single word I wrote. In fact, it's one of my favorite posts. Since crackers often do what they do to impress their peers, perhaps we should all just be unimpressed so that they can channel their energy into something more useful. I didn't know what to expect when I made that post, but I have to say I'm disappointed. Why am I so often the only responder who has a sense of right and wrong? Thanks Thomas, for providing me an opportunity to explain with the only reply that was suitable.
- plinkplonk 17y ago"Why am I so often the only responder who has a sense of right and wrong?" Pomposity, thy name is ... PS: I didn't downvote you. I just think that sentence is off key in your (otherwise excellent) post.
- edw519 17y ago"Pomposity" is the last word people who know me would use to describe me. I guess my writing continues to convey unintended meaning. One of these days, people will interpret exactly what I meant. Until then, I'll keep trying...
- 17y ago
- jcl 17y agoWhich would be appropriate, except the guys in the story didn't "take from others". They analyzed the system, found a flaw, and told the city about it. Moreover, they are not telling other people how to hack SF's specific system, nor does the story imply that they are continuing to make or use the "free" cards. If it turns out that other people are already secretly using this technique, the researchers may have saved SF and other cities a lot of money.