3 ms·
And what "appropriate approval" was that, exactly? In general, exporting personal data outside of the EEA requires the explicit notification of the data subjec
by Silhouette 13y ago
And what "appropriate approval" was that, exactly?
In general, exporting personal data outside of the EEA requires the explicit notification of the data subject under UK data protection law (among other consequences of the first Principle[1]). Moreover, the rules for even processing sensitive personal information, which includes health-related information, are significantly stronger than the general case.
They should never had been given that data in the first place, of course, and giving it to them should clearly be illegal on the part of whoever disclosed it. If it turns out not to have been, that will be a compelling case for dramatically strengthening the legal data protection and privacy framework in the UK. But I don't see how either the original source or PA Consulting can get around the basic conditions for processing sensitive personal data[2]. In particular, the most likely condition they might appeal to here in the absence of explicit consent reads:
"The processing is necessary for medical purposes, and is undertaken by a health professional or by someone who is subject to an equivalent duty of confidentiality." [Emphasis added]
Even once they had it, that still doesn't give them a free pass on exporting the data outside the EEA without notification (see [3]), or actually processing the data themselves for that matter.
[1] http://ico.org.uk/for_organisations/data_protection/the_guide/principle_1 http://ico.org.uk/for_organisations/data_protection/the_guid...
[2] http://ico.org.uk/for_organisations/data_protection/the_guide/conditions_for_processing#conditions-sensitive-data http://ico.org.uk/for_organisations/data_protection/the_guid...
[3] http://ico.org.uk/for_organisations/data_protection/the_guide/principle_8 http://ico.org.uk/for_organisations/data_protection/the_guid...
- nolok 13y agoDoesn't the "safe harbor" clause apply to US companies ? You know, that joke of a clause which says that US companies fit the needs of our data protection law as long as they claim to fit it (and they only have to claim it) ? Part of the new data protection law that was supposed to be voted in the EU following/during the PRISM scandal was revoking that stupid clause but I'm not sure what happened to that reform.
- Silhouette 13y agoSafe Harbor avoids some of the issues with exporting data from the EEA at all. It doesn't cover exporting the data without notifying the subjects appropriately. It isn't even close to covering exporting sensitive personal data (which is a technical term explicitly including health-related information), for which much stronger rules apply under UK data protection legislation.
- shubb 13y agoI thought that was why google hosted a lot of stuff in Ireland? So that companies could host EU data there without running afoul of the privacy laws? I don't think the duty on a company is all that strong - the data has to stay in Europe, on a properly protected computer. Providing you needed a password or equivalent secret to get to the data they are probably okay legally. Given the NHS is planning to sell poorly anonymized patient records at 10'000 for $10 imminently, I think we are complaining about the wrong problem.
- Silhouette 13y agoI don't think the duty on a company is all that strong You are mistaken. For sensitive personal data, there are much stricter rules on what you can do. Please see the second link I cited before. Given the NHS is planning to sell poorly anonymized patient records at 10'000 for $10 imminently Are you referring to care.data? That programme is essentially dead, in the face of massive opposition, and it was even before the current round of disclosures about hospital records already being leaked.
- DanBC 13y agoYou are wrong about the HES records and about the proposed GP records - there are criminal offences if the data is misused. > Given the NHS is planning to sell poorly anonymized patient records at 10'000 for $10 imminently, That's wrong too. It's okay to be against something, but only if you know what that thing actually is. The data would be pseudo anonymous with HSCIC and anonymous outside HSCIC. While there's a possibility of de-anonymisation anyone doing so would be committing a criminal offence.
- baldfat 13y agoThe statement from the offending party is that there was no individual identifying data. So what law?
- lotsofmangos 13y agoPeople were able to identify individuals on the earthware map produced from this data that was publicly online. It doesn't really matter what the offending party says, if it is demonstrably untrue.