3 ms·
Focusing on the age is probably the wrong approach. Math true then is still true now. The problem is that the curriculum is now held sacred (and I mean that ful
by jerf 13y ago
Focusing on the age is probably the wrong approach. Math true then is still true now. The problem is that the curriculum is now held sacred (and I mean that fully as nastily as possible), and it is being held there by people who are now the blind-leading-the-blind unto the sixth or seventh generation. I've gotten around in the math world a lot since primary school, and what I was taught vs. any actual modern mathematical practice, across the entire spectrum from utterly practical to the utterly theoretical, bears surprisingly little resemblance to what I wasted my time with in school. The current curriculum is bizarrely overfocused on real analysis to the near exclusion of all else (a few other disciplines will be introduced, generally poorly motivated either practically or theoretically, fiddled with for a couple of weeks, then dismissed; matrix math, for instance... in primary school nobody ever gave me a clue why we cared about this, and once you're done solving polynomial sets of equations (itself an unmotivated activity), you're pretty much done), and even if we grant that real analysis really is worth crowding out everything else, it still comes with a very 19th century flavor to the whole thing, too, wasting time on some dead-ends and missing some things that would be both mathematically and practically useful, too. (For instance, numerical approximations methods are usually covered as "Newton' Method For Finding Roots", and that's it. There's several things I'd trade away in favor of more of this, and it's easy to motivate why this is useful stuff.)
I'm pretty pessimistic in the short term about any efforts to reformulate math curricula, though, due to the aforementioned blind-leading-the-blind unto the seventh generation problem; math educators aren't even aware how bad the problems are, let alone in any position to fix them themselves, or aware enough to ask for help.
- gus_massa 13y agoThe curriculum changed. For example, logarithm tables were a standard topic. I don't know haw many hours in a year were use to explain it. Now that subject luckily has disappeared because it's not necessary. Note: There are some tables that are very similar, for example the voltage of a thermocouple.
- j2kun 13y agoAnd yet, we somehow think that being able to draw an accurate picture of an ellipse given its equation is useful, along with knowing the derivative of every inverse trig function, and countless other things.
- gus_massa 13y agoI agree that the exact form of an ellipse is not useful, but some general idea is. Other example is the method for long multiplication. I think that it's not 1000 years old, but I can't find a source. One of the formed methods was to use square tables and the identity xy = ( (x+y)^2 - (x-y)^2) )/4. It guesses it was explained in schools, but now it's almost a curiosity. To use it, you must have a book with the tables of the squares, and the last edition of those books is from 1888: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Multiplication_algorithm#Quarter_square_multiplication http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Multiplication_algorithm#Quarte...
- Consultant32452 13y agoI went all the way through differential equations in engineering school and don't know how to do anything with matrices. shrug
- gus_massa 13y agoDon't worry, Heisenberg discovered the matrix formulation of quantum mechanics without knowing matrices http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Werner_Heisenberg#Matrix_mechanics_and_the_Nobel_Prize http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Werner_Heisenberg#Matrix_mechan... :). More seriously, if you ever want to study quantum mechanics, you should learn matrix algebra before.
- dalke 13y agoWhen I was in school there was still the giant slide rule on the wall, from when the teacher used to teach how to use it.
- belovedeagle 13y agoAs a student in my first /real/ real analysis course (called "Advanced Calculus I" by the registrar, predictably), I have a slight quibble with your characterization of high school "calculus" as real analysis. What we did in high school, which I now think of as nothing but "calculus" in scare quotes, is to real analysis as arithmetic is to mathematics proper---because that's all it was, glorified arithmetic. Even though I had a great teacher and an understanding principal who allowed me to just go and study math on my own for two years, even then I was misled into the glorified-arithmetic world of studying "calculus" for advanced standardized tests. That's all high school math ever was, and when I scored in the 99th percentile on all the standardized tests, it was because they quite literally just asked arithmetic questions (sometimes disguised as "plug this into the quadratic formula", sometimes as "take the derivative then plug in this value"). TL;DR: high school math, and even much of what's taught in an undergraduate degree now (in math!), is just glorified arithmetic.
- jerf 13y ago"I have a slight quibble with your characterization of high school "calculus" as real analysis" Yeah, I know, but if that's not what high school math is, what is it? As hostile as I am I'm not quite ready to write it off as "entirely not math"... there's some math content in there, after all. I do want to point out that I am in contact with reality and do not expect students to start with number theory, nor do I realistically expect high school to ever cover what you covered in "real" real analysis. (Real numbers are terribly complicated things and I don't think high school should cover all the endless, endless corner cases of those either; time is short and the fields are vast.) What I'm really looking for is dropping a lot of stuff that is both practically and theoretically pretty useless, and replacing it with a lot of stuff that is, well, both more practical and more theoretically useful. Some of the core will survive (integration and differentiation aren't going anywhere, those really are fundamental to any reasonable math education, though we might spend several fewer weeks walking through all the special cases of each), but there's a lot of room for improvement.
- rayiner 13y ago> TL;DR: high school math, and even much of what's taught in an undergraduate degree now (in math!), is just glorified arithmetic. Is this a bad thing? You can design and build airplanes with what doesn't amount to anything more than glorified arithmetic. I don't see the value in teaching kids more than that.
- j2kun 13y agoI think one problem is that mathematicians would have high school students focus on solving puzzles and slowly introducing technical content and proof-technique, while the rest of the world cries out that they need real-world applications and preparation for calculus. The truth is that the puzzles and proof techniques are what develop mathematical thinking skills. Every mathematician knows this, but no administrators are publicly willing to believe it.