3 ms·
To be fair, a lot of the rhetoric from both sides tends to be extreme. The other side of the argument is that this is clear proof we must never use nuclear ene
by jrockway 13y ago
To be fair, a lot of the rhetoric from both sides tends to be extreme. The other side of the argument is that this is clear proof we must never use nuclear energy for anything ever again, and instead continue burning our limitless supply of fossil fuels.
I think the reality is: we need to make nuclear energy didn't work. TEPCO could't do it. Hopefully someone else can.
- dredmorbius 13y agoThe other side of the argument is that this is clear proof we must never use nuclear energy for anything ever again, and instead continue burning our limitless supply of fossil fuels. Well, that's a false dichotomy and representation right there. It's possible to believe both that nuclear power isn't desirable and that fossil fuels are limited. Which from my experience a fair number of those opposed to nuclear do in fact believe. Which rather undercuts your own credibility.
- einhverfr 13y agoI do think that what Fukushima shows is that when you have a nuclear power plant, you have the possibility of really big problems caused by natural disasters well above what you planned for. The questions are what you can plan for and what you do plan for? Ideally we'd put nuclear reactors way away from all natural disasters, and design them to withstand magnitude 10 earthquakes, F-5 tornadoes, Category 5 hurricanes, and, say, bombing by massive conventional munitions during wartime. And we'd have perfect, guaranteed safe forever storage of waste. Practically, it isn't clear that this is possible. I think the reality is: we need to make nuclear energy didn't work. TEPCO could't do it. Hopefully someone else can. The question is, do we want these things to work until they don't? Or do we want them to be guaranteed to work no matter what happens? I am not sure the latter is possible.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]