3 ms·
Chlorine is available in quantity, but fluorine, bromine, and iodine are not. Bromine and iodine are actually quite rare - there's more uranium than either of t
by ars 13y ago
Chlorine is available in quantity, but fluorine, bromine, and iodine are not. Bromine and iodine are actually quite rare - there's more uranium than either of those.
Lead is also somewhat rare.
> All common and cheap.
Exactly what I'm talking about. In the small quantities we use currently - common and cheap. In the quantities needed to make energy? Not common at all.
> So, no, there shouldn't be any supply problem.
Actually, if that's what it's made of there will be huge supply problems.
Based on all this I suspect this is the last we will hear of this technology. It works in the lab, but is not practical at scale.
Although maybe those elements are just used at ppm levels, and the bulk of this is silicon, then this could work.
> but I doubt this would involve anywhere near the volume that's used in (e.g.) lead-acid car batteries.
To provide energy at country level scales? It would use WAY more. I once calculated that there is not enough lead on the planet to make enough batteries to store enough energy for overnight use. (In the context of batteries to buffer the diurnal nature of solar energy.)
- maxerickson 13y agoIt sort depends on how much material is needed for each unit area of panels. Bromine is apparently abundant in the oceans and annual production is ~half a million tonnes (wikipedia!). On the other hand, 5% of England is billions of square meters. http://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=5%25+of+the+area+of+England http://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=5%25+of+the+area+of+Eng...
- gilgoomesh 13y agoIodine is very much the same. While there's not a huge amount in the Earth's crust, relative to some elements, it's relatively abundant in seawater and relatively easy to extract – for anyone who really needs it.
- DennisP 13y agoFrom the article linked by danmaz74, the most commonly studied chemical is CH3NH3PbI3, so lead and iodine are a significant portion. But it's a thin layer on a substrate like titanium dioxide or zinc oxide. They don't say exactly how thin, except to say it's less than several micrometers including the substrate. I'd really like to see numbers on how much of each element would be needed per gigawatt, and compare to what's available. Anyone who doubts that your battery calculation was correct should read "A Nation-Sized Battery" by Tom Murphy, a physics professor at University of California. His other blog entries do a fine job with similar calculations for other energy technologies. https://physics.ucsd.edu/do-the-math/2011/08/nation-sized-battery/ https://physics.ucsd.edu/do-the-math/2011/08/nation-sized-ba...
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- Turing_Machine 13y ago> Chlorine is available in quantity, but fluorine, bromine, and iodine are not. All of these are available in quantity. Bromine is available in tank-car lots. Iodine is available in tonne lots. "Lead is also somewhat rare." "Somewhat rare", perhaps, but it only sells for about $1/pound, and 8 million tonnes are produced annually. "Actually, if that's what it's made of there will be huge supply problems." Actually, you're totally wrong. Sorry. "I once calculated that there is not enough lead on the planet to make enough batteries to store enough energy for overnight use." Batteries use multiple heavy plates of solid lead. This is a micrometer scale thin film on a substrate. There's a difference.
- Turing_Machine 13y agoAssume the film is entirely lead (likely the limiting component -- as others have noted there is no shortage of bromine, chlorine, and iodine in the ocean) and 10 micrometers thick. Lead has a density of 11,340 kg/m^3. A ten micrometer thickness means that each m^2 of material will use about 0.11 kg of lead. While the earth receives something like 1,000 watts/m^2 in full sun, other factors (e.g., night, clouds, different sun angles) mean that the mean is closer to 250 watts/m^2. This stuff is expected to reach 20% efficiency, so each m^2 of collector will produce a mean output of 50 or so watts. Human civilization as a whole produces about 15 terawatts of power, so replacing it would require about 300 billion square meters of collector. At 0.11 kg/m^2, that would require about 33 billion kg of lead. World production of lead is about 8 billion kg per year. So, unless I messed up the arithmetic (please correct if so) total replacement of all existing power sources would require only about 4 years of lead output. Given that that will never happen (and even if it did, the time scale would be much longer than 4 years), it is safe to say that the availability of lead is not a limiting factor for this technology.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- ars 13y agoYour arithmetic is correct except for lead production figures and optimism on iodine. You are including recycling, so real production is about half of what you wrote. The trouble is that at current rates of consumption the world will run out in 42 years (according to wikipedia). So this project would use 20% of all the remaining lead in the world. (Well not really, the film is not 100% lead, but it's still quite a lot.) I call that "not enough". Although it might be worth it anyway. But what do you do when energy use goes up? And despite people saying there is bromine and iodine in the ocean, there is no practical way to get it out of the ocean in quantity. There is everything in the ocean - in huge quantities! For example 1/10 as much gold as has ever been mined by humans exists in the ocean - but no one can get it out in quantity. World production of iodine is about 1/200 of lead production and we already see that we barely have enough lead. And world existence of iodine is 1/100 of lead. And considering we need a significant percentage of the lead in the world, there is no way there is enough iodine. But we are ignoring the substrate. It won't be so thin, so we'll need a lot of it. I wonder how much of it is for mechanical strength (i.e. replaceable) and how much is essential. Maybe this could work - using a thin film is very promising, but I'm skeptical this could be scaled.