4 ms·
Is this going to be another one of those products that are cheap in small quantities, but are simply not available in large quantities? The reason we keep goin
by ars 13y ago
Is this going to be another one of those products that are cheap in small quantities, but are simply not available in large quantities?
The reason we keep going back to silicon is the planet (the crust) is basically made out of it. It's available in any quantity.
- Turing_Machine 13y ago"methylammonium trihalogen plumbates" Methylammonium ions can be had from methylamine, which is dirt-cheap (made from methanol and ammonia, usually). Halogens are fluorine, chlorine, bromine, iodine. All common and cheap. Plumbates are lead and oxygen. Again, common and cheap. So, no, there shouldn't be any supply problem. Disposal might need some watching due to the lead, but I doubt this would involve anywhere near the volume that's used in (e.g.) lead-acid car batteries.
- SideburnsOfDoom 13y ago> methylamine, which is dirt-cheap The public has already been educated a bit about methylamine as an industrial chemical http://www.cbsnews.com/news/video-behind-the-breaking-bad-train-heist/ http://www.cbsnews.com/news/video-behind-the-breaking-bad-tr...
- ars 13y agoChlorine is available in quantity, but fluorine, bromine, and iodine are not. Bromine and iodine are actually quite rare - there's more uranium than either of those. Lead is also somewhat rare. > All common and cheap. Exactly what I'm talking about. In the small quantities we use currently - common and cheap. In the quantities needed to make energy? Not common at all. > So, no, there shouldn't be any supply problem. Actually, if that's what it's made of there will be huge supply problems. Based on all this I suspect this is the last we will hear of this technology. It works in the lab, but is not practical at scale. Although maybe those elements are just used at ppm levels, and the bulk of this is silicon, then this could work. > but I doubt this would involve anywhere near the volume that's used in (e.g.) lead-acid car batteries. To provide energy at country level scales? It would use WAY more. I once calculated that there is not enough lead on the planet to make enough batteries to store enough energy for overnight use. (In the context of batteries to buffer the diurnal nature of solar energy.)
- maxerickson 13y agoIt sort depends on how much material is needed for each unit area of panels. Bromine is apparently abundant in the oceans and annual production is ~half a million tonnes (wikipedia!). On the other hand, 5% of England is billions of square meters. http://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=5%25+of+the+area+of+England http://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=5%25+of+the+area+of+Eng...
- gilgoomesh 13y agoIodine is very much the same. While there's not a huge amount in the Earth's crust, relative to some elements, it's relatively abundant in seawater and relatively easy to extract – for anyone who really needs it.
- DennisP 13y agoFrom the article linked by danmaz74, the most commonly studied chemical is CH3NH3PbI3, so lead and iodine are a significant portion. But it's a thin layer on a substrate like titanium dioxide or zinc oxide. They don't say exactly how thin, except to say it's less than several micrometers including the substrate. I'd really like to see numbers on how much of each element would be needed per gigawatt, and compare to what's available. Anyone who doubts that your battery calculation was correct should read "A Nation-Sized Battery" by Tom Murphy, a physics professor at University of California. His other blog entries do a fine job with similar calculations for other energy technologies. https://physics.ucsd.edu/do-the-math/2011/08/nation-sized-battery/ https://physics.ucsd.edu/do-the-math/2011/08/nation-sized-ba...
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- Turing_Machine 13y ago> Chlorine is available in quantity, but fluorine, bromine, and iodine are not. All of these are available in quantity. Bromine is available in tank-car lots. Iodine is available in tonne lots. "Lead is also somewhat rare." "Somewhat rare", perhaps, but it only sells for about $1/pound, and 8 million tonnes are produced annually. "Actually, if that's what it's made of there will be huge supply problems." Actually, you're totally wrong. Sorry. "I once calculated that there is not enough lead on the planet to make enough batteries to store enough energy for overnight use." Batteries use multiple heavy plates of solid lead. This is a micrometer scale thin film on a substrate. There's a difference.
- theoh 13y agoPerovskite is also common in "the planet": 93% of the mantle is silicate perovskite, according to Wikipedia. I'm not sure the geological abundance (accessible or not) is the determining factor in the cost of solar cells made with these materials. Edit: actually, it seems from the more detailed descriptions that the perovskites useful in solar cells have a totally different chemical formula from the common geological ones, so your point about abundance of silicon needs to be measured against whatever elements these (presumably synthetic) perovskites contain.
- pmahoney 13y ago"Perovskite" refers to the common mineral as well as any number of materials exhibiting the particular crystal structure.
- pjc50 13y agoThis is like saying we'll never run out of coal because carbon is so prevalent: it's not the right form. Silicon purification is energy-intensive, a major factor in the cost of silicon cells. Perovskite and other thin-film technologies potentially have the advantage of it being easier to handle liquids than thin solid silicon wafers; just deposit the final result of the process on glass. A downside of these cells is buried at the bottom of another article: http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/nova/next/tech/photovoltaic-materials/ http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/nova/next/tech/photovoltaic-material... especially vulnerable to water damage if the seal fails.