4 ms·
> I don't argue that cryptocurrencies can or should replace government currencies, but they clearly accomplish something valuable. They might, but I wouldn't s
by pron 13y ago
> I don't argue that cryptocurrencies can or should replace government currencies, but they clearly accomplish something valuable.
They might, but I wouldn't say it's "clear" just yet. The only clearly valuable thing Bitcoin accomplishes now is the facilitation of illegal trade online. Valuable – certainly, but a new technology whose crowning achievement so far is facilitating crime has a big PR problem. And that's not Bitcoin's only PR problem. Its association with wingnut (hacker-)libertarianism is another ball and chain, which gives Bitcoin the good old Glen Beck treatment.
I think Bitcoin adopters should market it as a terrific way to spend small amounts of cash online. Unfortunately, Bitcoin's volatility doesn't help to make this case, so that is probably the first thing that should be addressed. Bitcoin supporters should understand one thing: uncontrolled volatility, even when it's pointing up, perhaps especially when it's pointing up, isn't a good sign. Every currency is based on one thing – trust – and if Bitcoin is ever to become a currency, it should loudly declare that it's in the hands of responsible people; not criminals, speculators and wingnuts.
- lukifer 13y ago> The only clearly valuable thing Bitcoin accomplishes now is the facilitation of illegal trade online. How do you figure? Being able to send money across the world for next to nothing (compare to credit card fees, not to mention the higher prices of Western Union or hawala) has immense value. Charitable organizations have already raised large sums using crypto-coins. You are correct about volatility. It makes more sense right now to treat as a highly fungible asset than a currency; it will be interesting to see if it can self-stabilize without any central organization.
- pron 13y agoBitcoin's role as a large-sum money-transfer mechanism for legitimate purposes hinges on availability of immediate exchange at each end of the transaction (immediate because of the volatility). Bitcoin exchanges aren't getting the best PR lately, either. I don't think responsible organizations would allow the use of Bitcoin as a transfer medium in the current chaos just to save some money. So this utility, I claim, is more theoretical at this moment. In any event, the volume of such transactions by established, lawful, and respected organizations is probably too limited to be categorized as clear value just yet.
- betterunix 13y ago"Being able to send money across the world for next to nothing (compare to credit card fees, not to mention the higher prices of Western Union or hawala) has immense value." This is likely to end as Bitcoin exchanges discover the cost of compliance.
- lukifer 13y agoThe cost of compliance is a serious issue, true. I would hope that at least some states recognize the value in letting the experiment play out without interference, as with the early days of the internet, but with real money on the line it's harder to dismiss as a mere toy. However, I wouldn't neglect the "gray market" use cases of Bitcoin: things that happen outside the law, but are not as nefarious or blatantly illegal as Silk Road. Immigrants sending money home to their families, secondary savings accounts for those in countries with unstable currencies, etc.
- notahacker 13y agoThe real cost of money transfer isn't really "next to nothing" when it depends on an asset so volatile it might lose 20% of its value before the party at the other end realizes they've been paid, and counterparties involved in the transaction are people that really shouldn't be running financial institutions. When you look at the proportion of Bitcoins in existence whose owners are known to have lost them to incompetence/malice, suddenly those 2% conventional currency transfer fees with banks' associated guarantees look very cheap indeed. If you want a "disruptive" money transfer system with low fees then there are a whole lot of p2p-based FX firms which offer very competitive rates that are run by relatively competent people and don't rely on a volatile asset in the middle of the transaction. Obviously, if you want a speculative investment vehicle, to stick a middle finger to fiat currency or to facilitate money laundering then Bitcoin has other appeal.
- panarky 13y ago> The only clearly valuable thing Bitcoin accomplishes now is the facilitation of illegal trade online. Shiller argued that Bitcoin doesn't solve a "sensible economic problem". His argument had nothing to do with legality or legitimacy, which are much more slippery concepts. Goverments have tried various ways to make information illegal, require licenses for printing presses[0], ban the dissemination of books and pamphlets, etc. It's hard to argue today that the freedom to publish and consume information is a valuable thing, regardless of its legal status. We see a very similar pattern with money, as governments try various ways to control who can send and receive value, to require licenses[1] for transmitting money, to ban broad classes of transactions, etc. Cryptocurrencies liberate and democratize money in a very similar way that the internet liberated and democratized information. Just as publishing laws have been liberalized to reflect the technological reality, financial regulation should also liberalize as it becomes clear that the cryptocurrency genie cannot be stuffed back in its bottle. Contrary to Shiller's argument, that seems like a valuable thing, a solution to a "sensible economic problem". [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Licensing_of_the_Press_Act_1662 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Licensing_of_the_Press_Act_166... [1] http://fincen.gov/statutes_regs/guidance/html/FIN-2013-G001.html http://fincen.gov/statutes_regs/guidance/html/FIN-2013-G001....
- pron 13y agoWell, what you're describing is sensible to those who ascribe to a very specific political view. I'm sure you strongly believe that your opinions would improve the world, but you are probably aware that many people who value freedom no less than you, and who are just as intelligent and knowledgable, completely disagree with how to achieve it. Giving Bitcoin a political flavor does it a disservice. Personally, I think that financial regulation is a great tool in the service of freedom. For example, before financial regulation in the US gained its teeth, most of the population was under the thumb of a small group of some very unscrupulous individuals (those who came to be called the Robber Barons). It was regulation that freed America from those people. Also, I think that human beings, by virtue of their biological and psychological construction, are prone to be subjugated to some substances as well as some ideas. What is freedom, then: allowing people to fall into slavery if they so wish it or preventing them? I'm not saying my views are right and yours are wrong. But I just want you to understand that many people view the words "regulation", "oversight" and "government" not as obstacles to freedom, but as essential components that facilitate it.