3 ms·
How about because "failure is good" is an absurd proposition? Failure in this case typically means people lost money and jobs. It also means customers probably
by Silhouette 13y ago
How about because "failure is good" is an absurd proposition? Failure in this case typically means people lost money and jobs. It also means customers probably got stung buying into something new and that could make them more hesitant to buy into something new next time, which is harmful to successful innovation.
Learning from failures is good, and might help entrepreneurs to develop a more viable proposition if they try again. But that still doesn't make failures good. It just means there is a silver lining for some of the participants, if they have enough left to try again later.
Hit-it-out-of-the-park success is good, and from an investing perspective funding a number of failures may be a reasonable cost of doing business if it means you get the occasional smash hit as well. But that still doesn't make failures good. It just makes them tolerable.
Moreover, the hit-it-out-of-the-park outliers in SV are mostly part of one big pyramid scheme these days. It may be a while before the bubble bursts, because at the top of the chain you've got the outlying outliers like Google and Facebook that really have managed to bring in actual revenues and build up huge war chests, but even then the theoretical valuations for some of these giants are dubious. There literally aren't enough people in the world to continue growing their core offering at historical rates in some cases, and attempts at diversification have mostly been failures propped up by those core offerings. Even if these weren't the case, the biggest giants in technology rarely manage to remain dominant for more than a decade or two before newer ideas from more nimble competitors start to intrude.
Meanwhile, smaller companies being bought for staggering sums of money when they have yet to demonstrate a viable business model for monetizing what they do is just silly in most cases. In the ones where it isn't, the acquisition is often for strategic reasons rather than a genuine investment in expected actual value.
So the bottom line is that European investors have less time for boom and bust than US ones. SV couldn't happen here, and we don't want it to. Culturally, while there are start-up incubators and the like around, we tend to be more interested in investing to grow something after its foundations and basic viability are already established. That could be demonstrated either through having a working business model that only needs cash immediately to accelerate growth that could have happened anyway, or through at least having a plan with clear potential to generate real money, for example. While I don't have any hard data to back this up, I suspect we also tend to put more emphasis on bootstrapping your own business or going to the bank for a loan rather than taking angel investment, and use more informal support networks such as old university connections here in Cambridge for the non-monetary benefits that angels might provide in somewhere like SV.
- michaelfeathers 13y agoMaybe the way to put it is - "failure is not something to be that scared of." I didn't like the article. It felt shallow. The real issue is that in the US we have a tendency to not second-guess people's decisions about how to invest their money. Yes, this means that some people will be ripped off, but it also means that they, and the society as a whole can be in rapid learning cycles about what makes a good investment. It's clear that the US has a very different take on acceptable risk and as a result they more big wins and big losses. Can't have one without the other.
- Silhouette 13y agoIt's clear that the US has a very different take on acceptable risk and as a result they more big wins and big losses. Can't have one without the other. Is that really true? If you ever make a big loss, in the sense that backing something like Google or Facebook would have been a big win, you're probably doing investment wrong. The dominant US tech investment strategy today appears to be accepting many relatively small losses on the basis that one smash hit will outweigh them all. I've noticed that in US-centric discussions, the distinction often seems to be stated in terms of "risk-aversion", with a focus on how much downside is acceptable and how US investors tend to accept more risk. In discussions on this side of the pond, we might rather distinguish based on "expected returns", with a focus on how much upside is likely across all outcomes and an emphasis on the mean rather than modal return.
- michaelfeathers 13y agoWhat if we shift the discussion from investor risk and reward to founder risk and reward? In the US it's possible for founders to win big and I suspect that is the reason why startups gravitate to the US. On the risk side, yes you can lose your shirt and so can your investors, but the system considers it normal to get up and try again. I don't like the fact that we don't have much of a social safety net in the US but that can be considered one of the larger risks founders face as well.