5 ms·
I think the problem is not too many, it is the same problem app developers have these days: attention. Surfacing good content in any medium is a pain and trust
by protomyth 13y ago
I think the problem is not too many, it is the same problem app developers have these days: attention. Surfacing good content in any medium is a pain and trusted critics have been disappearing (dying newspapers and fake hype).
- waterlesscloud 13y agoYou're right, it's entirely about discovery these days. Marketing is how studios cope with that. Indies are also marketing, but in somewhat different ways. There's curation via critics and festivals, but even that's not enough. My theory is that there's some audience for any half-competent film. The world is a big place, with a lot of variety and a lot of different tastes. If your film isn't truly awful, then there's some subset of people out there who want to see it. Long tail audiences for long tail filmmaking. The trick is they don't even know it exists. It's the same with apps and with music and with self-published novels. Matching audience to creative work for the million niches is the real trick that needs to be figured out. The systems we have now (app store, amazon, netflix, spotify, etc) all fail at it in general. Machine learning (as currently applied any way) doesn't really do it.
- thenomad 13y agoSpeaking as a working filmmaker - yes, you have hit the nail on the head here (and it's a real pity your comment's currently at the bottom of the thread). Self-published novels are doing a bit better than the other media at matching output to demand. That's partially because of a faster feedback loop, partially because Amazon are smart cookies, and partially just because they need to earn back a lot less to be profitable. I'd be interested in talking more about this issue, actually - my email address is in my HN user info.
- protomyth 13y ago"My theory is that there's some audience for any half-competent film." I had high hopes that social media sites would make it easier to find new stuff, but it seems their business model of selling advertising is actually in direct conflict with building tools to discover new media. Apple might have had a chance with Ping, but they bungled it so badly. I would imagine that someone will either make their money from linking media to audience or find a revenue source that doesn't conflict.
- ZenoArrow 13y agoExactly right, attention is the prime issue. We could really do with a few more prominent content hubs that help people connect with promising new content. However, there is a secondary issue, and that is of appetite. Appetite for novelty. We seem to often crave more of the same, rather than taking a chance on something unfamiliar. I do this too, for example I only go on Crunchyroll to watch Naruto-related shows, despite there being a large selection of other shows I could watch. What can be done to help open people up to new experiences? As much as I dislike people banging on about how great things were in the 1960s, the one factor that does seem to be markedly different about that time was an openness to novelty within the masses. Logically there's no reason that can't happen again, but I don't know how it'll emerge.
- thenomad 13y agoInteresting point. In fiction, it's often easy to identify what people want to read / watch / consume - a Joss Whedon fan wants "stuff like Buffy", a 24 fan wants "more 24". You're in the Naruto niche. This is niche identification, just like in non-fiction - where as I mention in a comment above, you can target down to tiny niches. The difference in fiction is that it's illegal to target those niches because of copyright-created monopolies. I can't say "OK, ZenoArrow wants more Naruto" and make some without getting extremely sued. I'm not sure what to do about that, but it's an interesting identification of the problem. This also explains why new fiction is so hard to launch - you're creating a new niche, something that's traditionally randomly successful and very difficult. (The traditional solution, of course, is either to license popular IP - not really doable for indies - or to base your fiction on a niche that's not copyright-protected. Hence the number of Sherlock Holmes-based films, TV shows, and books, for example - the Sherlock Holmes niche is actually available.)
- ZenoArrow 13y agoGlad you found the appetite angle interesting thenomad. Whilst licensing popular IPs is one way to reliably bring in an audience, I wouldn't say it's a long term solution for healthy, diverse culture. Reusing older source material is certainly popular right now though, Sherlock Holmes is a strong example of that. Furthermore, older material can be reused in creative ways (e.g. Sample-based music, reimaginings of universes such as Luhrmann's Romeo and Juliet, etc...). I also think you make a good point about 'a Joss Whedon fan wants "stuff like Buffy"'. I think this can go beyond what someone is used to when people begin to build their identity around what they consume. There is an unwritten but obvious way that a group latches onto certain media, even in scenes that supposedly promote individualism such as geek culture. Even if culture should be identity agnostic, it frequently is not. I should point out that although I don't always find time for the new, I know that I'd be better off if I did. Perhaps 'find time' is the key phrase, I feel so busy with/addicted to my current cultural consumption that I don't make room for finding something new. The one exception for me is YouTube, I'll happily take time browsing YouTube seeing where it takes me. Perhaps that's the one exception due to the habits ingrained in me throughout the 90s through copious TV consumption, I'm at ease that I'll not always hit the jackpot of an interesting video. What I really would like to see is greater cultural diversity, despite my actions to the contrary. As a film maker I apologise that you'll have to deal with these issues! Perhaps short, ambitious content could help? When I was a kid I had a Transformers video I used to watch a lot, one of the episodes was 'Call Of The Primitives'. I really enjoyed that episode, the story seemed to flow really well. When I was older I read a complaint about that episode that they had tried to fit in too much, that it was a film-like storyline in a single 20 minute episode, it struck me that maybe that's part of what I liked about the story flow, it had the ambition to throw in quite a few memorable moments in a short time frame. I don't know if there's a lesson in that, but perhaps there is. What else do you think might help?