2 ms·
> Have you read the commentary here? A lot of it is really bad. I agree a lot of it is pretty far from the mark, but I object more strongly to the idea that on
by asveikau 13y ago
> Have you read the commentary here? A lot of it is really bad.
I agree a lot of it is pretty far from the mark, but I object more strongly to the idea that one must dogmatically follow the rules.
Also, I do think folks here sometimes get carried away with the "no politics" rule in particular, as if to define politics too broadly or kind of miss the point. (OK, so this has political implications, but imagining some sort of time warp, would you deny a story on World War II because it's "too political"?)
- davidw 13y agoI think politics is fascinating. But 99% of internet discussions about politics are crap. I'm beginning to develop some theories about that revolving around the idea that good discussion is costly, and cheap shots/conspiracy theories/empty words are very cheap, meaning the former get crowded out by the latter. In any event though, the discussions are pretty much horrible and worsen the site, which is one of the few good places to discuss hacking and startups out there.
- enraged_camel 13y ago>>But 99% of internet discussions about politics are crap. So are 99% of HN discussions about guidelines. You do notice the irony, right?