4 ms·
Doesn't matter. When you download Node.js itself, you are doing so over HTTP. https://nodejs.org/download/ https://nodejs.org/download/ (note the httpS) does no
by IgorPartola 13y ago
Doesn't matter. When you download Node.js itself, you are doing so over HTTP. https://nodejs.org/download/ https://nodejs.org/download/ (note the httpS) does not work. Hope you enjoy being a part of that botnet :)
Edit: I used to email project owners about issues like this, but never seem to get any response, so I stopped. The worst one, in terms of losing $$ was Pandora. I keep trying to sign up for the paid service, but the form to put in your credit card details is served over HTTP. I emailed them several times with no response.
- ColdHawaiian 13y agoRegarding Pandora, their login form is also served over HTTP instead of HTTPS (http://www.pandora.com/account/sign-in http://www.pandora.com/account/sign-in), which I find to be very disappointing, since it's less secure that way.
- leobelle 13y agoRegarding pandora, the form post is over HTTPS: https://www.pandora.com/radio/jsonp/v35 https://www.pandora.com/radio/jsonp/v35 And you can load the form, which is just an HTML input form with some sensitive data (last 4!), over HTTPS. It sucks that HTTPS is not default though.
- travem 13y ago> Regarding pandora, the form post is over HTTPS: Sure, but for the purpose of being explicit to other readers that is still not secure. If the form collecting the sensitive data is served using HTTP only then a malicious actor could alter the page (by injecting some javascript for example) to steal the data even if the actual form post is secured. Serving the form page as https at least ensures that the page collecting the data for submission was unmodified in transit.
- nevi-me 13y agoHasn't moxie discussed this a few years ago, that it's unsecure to send sensitive data from an HTTP page to an HTTPS one?
- IgorPartola 13y agoThe problem is simple: if you send me an HTML file over HTTP, an attacker can inject some JavaScript code that will catch the onsubmit event and also send the data elsewhere.
- leobelle 13y agoYou'd be able to see that though, and you can actually load the form over HTTPS, just use https://pandora.com https://pandora.com instead of http. It's stupid that it's not default though, and there is actually insecure content also loaded, so yeah. :(
- IgorPartola 13y agoGood. Perhaps I will sign up now. Last time I checked was almost a year ago. But yeah, that should be the default.
- nilved 13y agoThat's a non-problem because people who care about online security don't have JavaScript enabled by default.
- IgorPartola 13y agoOK what if the attacker replaces the action of the form to submit to their servers instead? Also Pandora does not work without JavaScript just like most modern websites. Would be pointless to sign up then, wouldn't it. Lastly, what you are saying is simply not true.
- barrkel 13y agoSecurity isn't binary.
- nilved 13y agoSuffice to say: anybody who has JavaScript enabled by default demonstratably does not care about their security. Interest and competence in security is indeed a spectrum, but somebody in first grade math still knows what 2 + 2 is.
- chill1 13y agoIf you are so concerned about downloading anything via HTTP, why not always use a VPN? At least that way you aren't susceptible to local MITM. Just make sure you trust your VPN :) Edit: Oh, plus you can always use a checksum to verify your download packages [1] :) [1] http://nodejs.org/dist/v0.10.26/SHASUMS.txt http://nodejs.org/dist/v0.10.26/SHASUMS.txt
- handsomeransoms 13y ago> why not always use a VPN? Because then you're susceptible to remote MITM? VPNs are useful but do not replace end-to-end encryption.
- CSDude 13y agoYou know this links is also not served on HTTPS. So local MITM can change the checksum on this page too.
- IgorPartola 13y agoWhat others said. Checksums downloaded via HTTP are just as easy to spoof as the tarball. The VPN protects you part of the way but not the entire way. Now, if you said that I could verify the download because it was signed using the publisher's GPG key and that key was widely trusted, then I might have entertained the idea. Then again, that is very non-standard compared to getting a $10 TLS cert.