4 ms·
"Journalism Isn’t Dead. Just The Old Business Part Of It." This is a huge assumption. I disagree with it. I say that journalism is dead. Let me explain...
by edw519 17y ago
"Journalism Isn’t Dead. Just The Old Business Part Of It."
This is a huge assumption. I disagree with it. I say that journalism is dead. Let me explain...
Turn on any television. Do it 3 or 4 times per day. Surf around the dial 2 or 3 times. I defy anyone to find anything resembling journalism.
Sit down for brunch on Sunday with 3 or 4 Sunday newspapers. Go through all of them for 3 to 4 hours. Learn anything new? I didn't think so.
I bring up these 2 examples because they are my experience over the last 5 years. Television and print journalism are conflicts in terms. They are dead. There's little difference between most newspapers and supermarket tabloids. Heraldo from 10 years ago looks more professional than anything on TV.
Where does that leave us? With the internet. Yes, there's plenty of great writing on-line, but it's buried among all the rest of the crap. Anyone can say anything and they usually do. Readers here know how to separate the wheat from the chaff, but mom and dad and Aunt Millie don't, so they're not getting the news anymore. Most people aren't.
I admire OP's experiment of rescuing the business of journalism. I just wish someone would think of an experiment to rescue the profession of journalism first.
- jacquesm 17y agoSunday papers and TV are not exactly the right examples to search for real journalism. Try the Times, the Scotsman and the Washington post. that is journalism. And it's not quite dead but I fail to see how they're going to support their reporters, the current businessmodel is failing fast and they don't seem to have any really good plans on replacing it.
- CalmQuiet 17y agoBut what if we use "dead" to mean, "No longer in demand"? Or, "No longer marketable/saleable"? Hasn't the most really journalist "news" long been subsidized by gossip and "human interest"? For the small portion of population that values in-depth, analytical coverage, perhaps some mimicking of The Economist's business model may be necessary?
- uhuyvvty 17y agoBut their business model isn't news - it is to be the PR and government relations arm of whichever billionaire owns them. The Times is a cheap way for Murdoch to make sure that the government gets the public opinion that is best for his other businesses.
- jacquesm 17y agoYes, that's a part of it, but there is definitely something called journalism going on there. It's just that it is coloured and not as objective as it should be. Which is a pity and which is one of the reasons why centralizing all this media power is a very bad thing.
- Tangurena 17y agoNo. I'd say from personal experience that journalism is dead. I ran for elected office last November. I had a number of opponents. None of us got more than a passing nod in either (now only 1) local paper. Time and time again, the reporters covering the "beat" that this elected office fell under would call or send pages of questions about us, about our campaigns, about our goals if elected. Chatting with the other candidates, they, like myself, sent page after page of answers only to have everything truncated to $CANDIDATE is $AGE and works as a $JOB. Why should anyone have voted for any of us? The local papers chose not to let the voters find out. That's a major fault of the papers. If they're not going to bother telling the voters what's going on, then who is? If the local papers aren't going to bother covering a state-level race, then why are they still in business (one isn't) and why should we care when they go out of business?
- mixmax 17y agoTelevision journalism may be dead in the US, but it certainly isn't elsewhere on the planet. I often learn something new from the news.