4 ms·
Just like you'll wait until physical cash has mugger protections before using it?
by SilasX 13y ago
Just like you'll wait until physical cash has mugger protections before using it?
- danhak 13y agoGreat strawman. Parent post didn't mention physical cash. He mentioned credit cards, which have chargeback/purchase protection, and bank accounts, which have deposit insurance.
- SilasX 13y agoThat's not what strawman means, and the point is that different measures protect you from different things and you shouldn't fault one for not protecting against others (outside its "threat model"). Paper dollars are designed to protect against counterfeit. That's all. To protect against muggers requires either a) sacrificing the desirable properties of paper dollars, or b) use of a separate security layer (vaults, safes, holding little at a time on you, etc). In no case are those limitations a failing of the paper dollar itself. They likewise don't themselves protect against someone convincing you to give them your paper dollars under false pretenses. Same points apply: to handle that threat, you rely on laws, trust networks, escrows (like credit card arbitration) etc. Still not a problem with the dollar, just outside its threat model. I made the previous comment in the hopes of compressing that point into one sentence. Perhaps I failed, but at no point did I misattribute a position to the GGP. "Your position implies X" != "you are advocating X" ... even and especially if you're not advocating X!
- danhak 13y agoThe original post's point was that conventional banks and credit cards offer consumer protection. Your response was that physical cash offers no consumer protection. So you either misunderstood or misrepresented the original point.
- SilasX 13y agoThe original point was that 3rd party services can offer consumer protection. My point was that they can do this to bitcoin too. What did I misunderstand?
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- CJefferson 13y agoI would never carry around, or own, more than a couple of hundred pounds worth of physical cash or bitcoin at a time.
- balls187 13y agoI have a blue belt in Krav Maga. I am my own mugger protection.
- pavel_lishin 13y agoI hope that belt is bullet- and knife-proof, and wraps your entire body. My mugger protection is throwing my wallet south, and running north.
- balls187 13y agoI hope you can run faster than a bullet. Otherwise you'll die tired. What if your kid was with you? Your girlfriend/boyfriend/significant other? You just gonna take off running and hope for the best?
- aroch 13y agoBitcoin are also vulnerable to physical theft and the OP isn't talking about physical theft of currency -- I'm pretty sure you know that and are electing to be snarky in spite of that. A credit/debit card when stolen, regardless of physical or electronic purloining, is backed by a set of consumer protection laws, regulations and policies -- some obviously required by government but some provided without legal obligation. Further a bank account, a brokerage account or any number of real money stores are insured against theft and loss (bankruptcy). BTC are not.
- patmcc 13y ago"Physical cash" stored at a third-party like a bank or credit union does have mugger protections - they have safes and vaults and security guards and insurance. If a bitcoin "wallet" service opened that offered those things, consumers would be more likely to take it seriously. Putting a fortune into Mt. Gox or someone similar is like burying your cash in someone else's backyard. You don't need mugger protection, you need common sense.
- balls187 13y agoSo the question remains: Is there a bitcoin wallet that offers such a guarantee? The Federal Government has up to $100,000 for deposits. Banks themselves will provide funds bank in case of fraud, to increase consumer confidence. Credit Cards have a number of consumer guarantees (for example, did you know if you purchase an item with a credit card, the credit card company will extend the warranty of the item in many cases--read the fine print). As another commenter said, yes I'm "paying" for that insurance by giving up some amount of control, but I think before BitCoin or another decentralized currency can reach critical mass, it will need service providers to offer similar protections. My opinion, anyway.
- SilasX 13y ago>"Physical cash" stored at a third-party like a bank or credit union does have mugger protections - they have safes and vaults and security guards and insurance. If a bitcoin "wallet" service opened that offered those things, consumers would be more likely to take it seriously. Indeed. But you wouldn't fault the paper dollar itself for failing to have the protections of the vault, just as you shouldn't fault the Bitcoin itself for failing to have he protections of escrow, nor compare a paper apple to a vaulted orange. Yes, 3rd party services will help with the trust issue in the Bitcoin ecosystem. They are still not a failing of Bitcoin per se, just as lack of built in mugger protections is not a failure of the paper dollar per se.
- pseut 13y agoI think you're looking for the phrase "debit card."