4 ms·
>it's hard to imagine a situation where such an action would be worthwhile, given the resources at the disposal of any such actor. This needs more defense. I f
by pessimizer 13y ago
>it's hard to imagine a situation where such an action would be worthwhile, given the resources at the disposal of any such actor.
This needs more defense. I find it hard to imagine a situation where such a minimal and deniable action with such a massive effect wouldn't be worthwhile.
- matthewmacleod 13y agoThis needs more defense. I find it hard to imagine a situation where such a minimal and deniable action with such a massive effect wouldn't be worthwhile. Because the goal of any such agency is not "let's render a minority of computing devices insecure for a short period under certain circumstances." That entire argument hinges on the idea that taking this action would have achieved some kind of desirable goal, when it simply would not have. In fact, the whole thing is a massive distraction. There are myriad easier ways to conduct individual surveillance if that was the goal, and I would be much more concerned about the fact that these same agents already apparently have legal carte blanche to intercept traffic in other ways.
- pessimizer 13y agoThanks. I think that your defense hinges on this being the only thing that they are doing. As one of many things, with no risk and little expended effort, why not? >There are myriad easier ways to conduct individual surveillance if that was the goal What's easier than getting a call from somebody placed at a tech company indicating that one of the most security critical pieces of code didn't have test coverage and wasn't statically analyzed before going into the build has a spot where an errant line could be inserted, in a way that could be argued later was accidental. The total marginal cost to that hypothetical situation would have been to say 'ok.' >these same agents already apparently have legal carte blanche to intercept traffic in other ways. intercepting traffic != decoding traffic
- tptacek 13y agoNo, it doesn't need a defense. There is no evidence to back up the idea that the bug was malicious. People that have worked on large C codebases have seen crazier things than this. Routinely. I understand that Rails developers believe that all the TLS stacks must have dense rspec test coverage and zero-warnings static analysis passes in their builds, but that isn't the reality for any TLS stack. These aren't Rails apps (and, hate to break it to some of you, but your Rails test coverage isn't doing as much for your security as you'd like to think it is). This is a nutball conspiracy theory, another example of the tech "community" eating its own rather than focusing on anything that would help mitigate state-sponsored surveillance. And it's happening solely in the service of an "exciting" narrative. The people promoting this bullshit conspiracy theory are, by and large, doing it because they want it to be true.
- miopa 13y ago1. It is certain that NSA has some very smart people playing with the sources of the Apple crypto-modules. 2. If you're a NSA boss, and some of your experts told you that you can break SSL in Apple products with adding one line that could be almost certainly attributed to inconspicuous human error, would you try to make a deal with Apple? 3. If you're an Apple boss, and NSA offers you cache (or other benefits, like competitor intelligence) for adding plausibly deniable bug in your code, would you turn it down? There is no direct evidence for this case, sure. There is however ample evidence in the Snowden docs that this scenario happens too often for this to be called bullshit conspiracy theory.
- tptacek 13y agoNone of this is evidence. This is all innuendo. I could apply the exact same set of arguments to the Rails YAML bug, or to whatever the last Chrome bug Pinkie Pie got working was. Nobody doubts your ability to spin some coherent-sounding story about the TLS bug. It's not a hard game to play. People have been playing it for centuries. How about you try a more fun topic, like alien landings?
- miopa 13y agoYou should make a difference between plausible conspiracy theory and bullshit conspiracy theory. Conspiracies happen quite often, having no evidence just makes them higher quality.
- patio11 13y agoRemember how Diaspora was supposed to be the private peer-to-peer encrypted Facebook but peers private keys could be read or overwritten by anyone on the Internet? Doesn't your argument suggest "Well we can't rule out the NSA having a man on the inside trying to undermine their encryption"? Heck, why not go all the way: the NSA funded Diaspora to bring Facebook to the negotiating table? Down this path lies madness. Software has bugs.
- miopa 13y ago