3 ms·
>> Even a custom-written third party client still doesn't eliminate the requirement to trust Apple. They're delivering your closed source operating system, whic
by nitrogen 13y ago
>> Even a custom-written third party client still doesn't eliminate the requirement to trust Apple. They're delivering your closed source operating system, which could very easily include hostile behaviors like key logging and screen recording.
> It does eliminate the requirement to trust Apple actually.
As the parent comment indicated (emphasis added), in an extreme hypothetical scenario, Apple could (be compelled to) write a backdoor specifically for your device that captures all text and touch input events, or periodically takes screenshots and sends them somewhere.
- lawnchair_larry 13y agoYou're missing the part where "custom client" means you aren't using an Apple device at all, if you don't want to be. This is like sending a PGP message over gmail using mutt on linux via IMAP. Google owns gmail, but they can't backdoor you or read your message in this scenario. Any non-broken secure messaging protocol should have this property, regardless of if people use it that way. This is what end-to-end encryption means.
- sjwright 13y ago> Any non-broken secure messaging protocol should have this property Okay then, tell me how you could build a system that * Guarantees secure transmission of public keys * Can be installed safely on a closed-source operating system * Is impervious to the whims of the hardware vendor or the operating system vendor * Is sufficiently straightforward that mums everywhere will happily use it * Doesn't require users to become security experts Given the practical realities Apple has to contend with, I think they've done a pretty good job -- certainly a lot better than what anyone could have expected, arguably a lot better than anything comparable that has come before it.
- lawnchair_larry 13y agoNo, Apple has definitely done worse than what we have expected. Worse, they haven't provided what they claimed. That being a secure end-to-end messaging protocol. This discussion about backdooring applications isn't even interesting or relevant here. The protocol itself is not secure.