4 ms·
I find the arguments of Alexander Hamilton and his central bank supporters to be self-serving and destructive to the ends of the people. And in my biased and p
by logfromblammo 13y ago
I find the arguments of Alexander Hamilton and his central bank supporters to be self-serving and destructive to the ends of the people. And in my biased and prejudiced opinion, central banking in the US has been an unmitigated disaster every time it has been tried. I don't believe JM Keynes can be used as a foundation for a sound economy, and I don't think monetary inflation is good for anybody except the person doing the inflating.
There is good reason for the Constitution to override the status quo of the Articles of Confederation on the subject of minting coinage, but I'm not certain a debate left unresolved regarding paper money is indicative of anything when they did actually agree that a person could be owned, and that was worth 3/5 of a vote. It was either less important than slavery, or more difficult to resolve. I'm inclined to believe the latter.
Before descending into full-on libertarded ranting, let's just say that leaving the matter as ambiguous effectively grants the government license to do whatever it pleases and interpret the ambiguity in favor of that.
Failing to bind the hands of a future Congress is what allowed them to pick up that grenade and pull the pin.
- rayiner 13y agoI'm not really interested in getting pulled into a 200 year old debate. For better or worse, most of the latent ambiguities in the Constitution were resolved in favor of the interpretation espoused by Hamilton and the Federalists. All I'm saying is that it's not the case that there was this clear Constitutional dictate in one direction that we callously ignored in modern times.
- argumentum 13y ago> I'm not really interested in getting pulled into a 200 year old debate. Why not, if the debate is still valid? These issues weren't so much "resolved" as put aside in favor of more government power or postponed (in the case of slavery, equal protection). The mere fact that the debate is 200 years old is simply more credit to its importance. The constitution is imperfect (like our government), as it itself acknowledges, and is "correct" only as Lincoln said that it serves a nation "conceived in liberty and dedicated to the proposition that all (men) are created equal". As someone else once said, don't take refuge in the false security of consensus.
- gnaritas 13y ago> The mere fact that the debate is 200 years old is simply more credit to its importance. No, it usually means one side lost and can't get over it. Half the country still disagrees with Darwin, it doesn't make the debate important despite it being well over 100 years old. The same applies here.
- argumentum 13y ago> Half the country still disagrees with Darwin If you don't think that debate is still important, you are essentially conceding it to the half the country you disagree with (because they sure as hell think its important). I'm sure you don't want your kids being taught creationism just because you consider yourself "above" the argument. And regardless, the same does not apply here, because unlike the overwhelming evidence we have for evolution by natural selection, there simply is not enough data on the usefulness of central banking to the prosperity of the nation.
- gnaritas 13y ago> If you don't think that debate is still important, you are essentially conceding it to the half the country you disagree with No I'm not. The debate was over 100 years ago, the ignorant just haven't figured it out yet. They simply get laughed at now for trying to argue the case. Mockery is not concession. > there simply is not enough data on the usefulness of central banking to the prosperity of the nation. Not what I was referring to. I was referring to this, " For better or worse, most of the latent ambiguities in the Constitution were resolved in favor of the interpretation espoused by Hamilton and the Federalists." You can't ignore 200 years of judicial interpretation and case law simply because you prefer to interpret the text differently, that was his point and he's correct. That debate is over.
- dllthomas 13y ago"No I'm not. The debate was over 100 years ago, the ignorant just haven't figured it out yet. They simply get laughed at now for trying to argue the case. Mockery is not concession." If it's actually half the country, and they actually think it's substantially more important than the other half the country, there's an argument that it's effective concession. But, at the risk of putting words in your mouth, I more understood you to be saying that having the argument wasn't important - conveying the understanding behind your "your side" of that argument you might consider quite a bit more important.
- logfromblammo 13y agoI'm saying that even if it was clear, it probably would have been ignored (maybe even amended) anyway. Control over the nation's currency is so powerful that it is inevitable that someone will try to usurp it. If you're trying to create a limited government, there are ample reasons to dig a deep moat around money, fill it with poisonous snakes and spiders, and line the walls with Dementors.
- dllthomas 13y ago"I don't think monetary inflation is good for anybody except the person doing the inflating." Isn't it good for persons with dollar-denominated debt exceeding their dollar-denominated assets?
- icebraining 13y agoOnly if their dollar-denominated debt wasn't adjusted to account for inflation, which assuming stable rates of inflation, isn't likely.
- dllthomas 13y agoAgreed, though I have a hard time seeing it as particularly bad for anyone in that case either.
- logfromblammo 13y agoIt complicates all economic calculations by unnecessarily introducing time and rate variables into the equation, and puts the entire economy on a treadmill, so people have to work just to stay in one place. Since those variables are often only rough guesses, they can be wrong, and cause misallocation of funds. When you print an additional 2% of the money supply, you are essentially taking about 2% of the entire economy and assigning it to yourself. Back when money was gold, and gold was money, in order to increase the money supply by 2%, you had to mine 2% of all gold already in the marketplace, which required a lot of labor and capital. If the price of gold was high, you worked more expensive mines. If it was low, you idled them as temporarily unprofitable. The effect of the increase on the money supply was diffused throughout the economy by virtue of the sheer amount of work required to accomplish it. With paper money, all that is required is a press and anti-counterfeiting measures. The transfer of value into the new money is far more concentrated, both in terms of actors and time. The buying power of the new money is higher, because people don't necessarily know how much you printed until you start spending it. It is a great virtue for Bitcoin to make public the exact amount of new money added to the economy. Monetary inflation can therefore be predicted exactly. It's still inflationary, and does not account for changes in demand to achieve a stable money price. What it needs is a feedback loop that connects mining rewards with demand for the currency. I imagine that could key from the hash rate of the whole network, but I'm not certain how.