3 ms·
They have regulated religion as well. Only certain religions can use, say, peyote in ceremonies. If tonight I get a vision that mandates I must use this chemica
by MichaelGG 13y ago
They have regulated religion as well. Only certain religions can use, say, peyote in ceremonies. If tonight I get a vision that mandates I must use this chemical with my followers, I don't qualify.
There are other exemptions too for religion, where they decide what a real religion is. I think, for instance, conscientious objectors needed to have an approved religion.
(There should be no freedom of religion explicitly; it just opens things up for abuse and silly interpretations. Freedom of speech, thought, assembly and so on should be more than enough to include religion.)
- argumentum 13y agoI totally agree it has been misinterpreted, I'm pretty sure the intention of Jefferson and Madison was that the government is not supposed to be able to determine what constitutes a religion in addition the right to believe & practice it* . The inclusion of the word "religion" seems a practical response to the tendency of governments to ban practices that threatened their power. * Where the preamble declares, that coercion is a departure from the plan of the holy author of our religion, an amendment was proposed by inserting "Jesus Christ," so that it would read "A departure from the plan of Jesus Christ, the holy author of our religion;" the insertion was rejected by the great majority, in proof that they meant to comprehend, within the mantle of its protection, the Jew and the Gentile, the Christian and Mohammedan, the Hindoo and Infidel of every denomination. -Thomas Jefferson, Autobiography, in reference to the Virginia Act for Religious Freedom (from which the 1st amendment is derived)
- dllthomas 13y agoDoesn't "we can't interfere with a religious practice" plus "we can't determine what is a legitimate religious practice" mean anyone can claim anything to be a religious practice? "Oh, I'm sorry, I'm engaged in the blessed sacrament of the mugging."
- jerf 13y agoThis is where it's worth remembering that humans are in the justice system by design. While the line is intrinsically fuzzy, one can at least agree that at one extreme a marijuana user coming up for charges who suddenly claims he has a marijuana-based religion in an attempt to get out of it isn't going to get very far. Judges are not required to be as stupid as computers interpreting the law.
- dllthomas 13y agoOn the one hand, judges are still part of the government. On the other, the first amendment says "Congress shall make no law regarding the establishment of religion", not that "judges shall make no rulings".
- jljljl 13y ago>> Only certain religions can use, say, peyote in ceremonies. The relationship between Native American Tribes and the US government is a bit more complicated than you are indicating here. Native American Tribes are afforded an extra degree of sovereignty and authority, and are actually recognized as "domestic dependent nations". This is where the exemptions for their religious ceremonies come from.
- MichaelGG 13y agoIf the exemption came from the sovereignty of the Native states/tribes, why would it be narrowed down to just peyote? Versus letting those nations simply decide for themselves their own "scheduling" of medications? I'm going off a few quick searches, but the peyote bit seems to exclude it for any "bona fide ceremonies" for the Native American Church, regardless of race. I didn't see any mention that they must be on reservations either. Wikipedia also notes that some states have a "bona fide religious" exemption that's not related to the NAC (which is at least somewhat more consistent, but "bona fide" is still silly to apply in this scope).
- jljljl 13y agoNations are not necessarily tied to land, nor is the sovereignty of the Native nations full sovereignty. I don't understand the full ramifications of the treaty and legal status myself. My point was just to indicate that the flippant remark about "some religions can use peyote" leaves out a lot of historical, political, and legal context.
- MichaelGG 13y agoOK, what about Sikhs and the dagger they are "required" wear at all times? I can't up and decide I must wear a knife (even if I put glue on it), then expect schools and the TSA to allow me to do so. The fact is that my "flippant" remark, while mentioning peyote specifically, applies to other such cases. Another example: conscientious objector status (which now has the religious part removed, but required a supreme court case to do so, AFAIK).