6 ms·
The Constitution also says that the states cannot coin money, issue paper money, or make anything but gold and silver coin tender in payment of debts. (Article
by logfromblammo 13y ago
The Constitution also says that the states cannot coin money, issue paper money, or make anything but gold and silver coin tender in payment of debts. (Article I, sect. 10, clause 1)
Technically, they shouldn't be accepting Federal Reserve Notes as payment for any state taxes, including sales taxes.
Note that this clause does not authorize the federal government to declare a legal tender or issue paper money; it simply prohibits the states from doing those things. Thanks to the 10th Amendment, those are reserved exclusively to the people. The wording is a bit tortured, but a logical parse is that powers not delegated to the federation are reserved to the states, and that powers prohibited to the states are reserved to the people. Legal tender, and paper money are not delegated to the federation, but prohibited to the states, therefore they remain the province of the people.
There should be no problem with the Federal Reserve printing its own notes, but there's no way in hell that making them legal tender or accepting them for payment on state or federal debts is constitutional. They do it anyway. Hardly anyone cares. Those who do are ignored.
As usual, they will do as they please, damn the consequences, and hang it all up under the interstate commerce clause.
Edit: Article I, section 8, clause 5 does give the federation the power to coin money and standardize its value. It still doesn't give them the power to accept those coins as payment for debts unless they are gold or silver.
- dailyrorschach 13y agoI mean there’s likely no convincing you - but there’s plenty of scholarship to disagree. The Constitution quite clearly gives Congress the power to “coin Money and regulate the value thereof.” It of course makes no additional statement as to how that should be done. It’s a pretty tortuous reading in my opinion and one that would basically be invalid going back to McCulloch v. Maryland to say that coin Money, must only mean metallic alloy coins. Between Expressed Powers and Necessary and Proper there’s certainly enough justification - it relies even less on the Commerce clause.
- logfromblammo 13y agoUnfortunately, it doesn't matter one little bit if you can convince me or not, as I am neither a federal circuit court judge, appellate judge, or supreme court justice. I think it is less important that our money be a particular commodity than it is that the government lack the power to manipulate its value for its own convenience. In my opinion, it is clear that the power to "coin money and regulate the value thereof" is to standardize the exchange rates between coins, probably by weight of the metal, but not necessarily. It is also clear that the coins need not be metal, but also that no one could be forced to accept coins other than gold or silver coins. Thus, they could stamp out wooden nickels, but that wouldn't make them worth anything to anybody, except possibly for payment of federal taxes. As long as we have those, it is only a short hop to rectangular paper "coins". They can do it, but nobody has to accept them. But since nobody is trying to pay taxes with Bitcoin yet, and the federal government isn't mining them, as far as we know, there is no justification for them to be standardized or otherwise regulated whatsoever. It might arguably be authorized under whatever clause, but it certainly isn't justified.
- Crito 13y agoWhat would be done if massive deposits of precious metals were found, rendering those metals little more valuable than perhaps copper or aluminum? You could still make coins with the same value of course, but they would be a bit impractical to carry around. A copper coin worth $20 in todays USD would weight nearly 3 kilograms! Surely at least paper gold and silver certificates would be a reasonable concession.
- logfromblammo 13y agoGold and silver certs are negotiable debt instruments, covered by the government's power to borrow. You lend them a gold or silver coin, and they write you a note promising to repay the bearer of the note one gold or silver coin of equal weight on demand. It's sort of a bogus loan, with a variable term and zero interest rate, but it's still allowed, and certainly makes things more convenient for a lot of people. And the government can still profit from the seignorage from the mint.
- dragonwriter 13y ago> Thus, they could stamp out wooden nickels, but that wouldn't make them worth anything to anybody, except possibly for payment of federal taxes. As long as we have those, it is only a short hop to rectangular paper "coins". They can do it, but nobody has to accept them. Nobody has to accept paper money, either. The only thing "legal tender" laws mean is that if you want to use the power of government to enforce debts, then the government gets to say that its job is done when government-declared legal tender has been presented, whether you accept it or not. If you don't choose to involve the government in your affairs, then legal tender laws don't affect you.
- Guvante 13y agoSection 8 says very explicitly: To coin Money, regulate the Value thereof People are totally allowed to make their own money and you can use it as you like. EDIT: About the commerce clause. Forgot to mention, if you want to bag on the federal government, don't bag on the commerce clause, bag on stipulating federal funding is only available if you do this completely unrelated thing. "If you handle more medicaid people we will cover part of the cost", that makes sense. "If you raise your minimum drinking age to 21 we will help pay for your roads". WTF?
- logfromblammo 13y agoI'll bag on the commerce clause from here to next week and back, thank you very much. The original meaning of regulate was "standardize", so most of what They claim to be doing with it is overreach. As far as intent goes, it was supposed to eliminate border friction on interstate trade, so Delaware couldn't charge a $1 tariff on a widget imported from New Jersey and two bits on the same thing from Pennsylvania, or other assorted trade-barrier nonsense. I think it would be completely warranted to have a constitutional amendment that controls how the federal government manages the treasury. It should not be giving money to the states except by apportioning the funds by census populations. If the Wisconsin drinking age is 18, too bad. As long as you are paying for highways at all, you have to pay them 1.817% of that money, because they have 1.817% of the US population. That would prevent an awful lot of political lever-pulling in the form that you mentioned. You couldn't tie federal highway funding to anything other than the actual upkeep of the highways. And you couldn't make school lunch subsidies contingent on serving corn at least 3 times per week, or declare ketchup a vegetable.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- rayiner 13y ago> I'll bag on the commerce clause from here to next week and back, thank you very much. The original meaning of regulate was "standardize" Revisionism. The word "regulate" was interpreted in more or less its modern sense in Gibbons v Ogden, in 1824, merely 35 years after ratification. "[T]he power to regulate; that is, to prescribe the rule by which commerce is to be governed. This power, like all others vested in Congress, is complete in itself, may be exercised to its utmost extent, and acknowledges no limitations, other than are prescribed in the Constitution." This is not a case where the meaning of the word has drifted from what it meant at the time of the founding. I'm quite conservative in my Constitutional interpretation, but I think conservatives get the Commerce Clause wrong. Its broad and was intended to be. The anti-federalist framers thought the "interstate" part would be a limit, but didn't concieve of a world where every transaction would cross state borders. Indeed, they lived in a world where market transactions were the exception. But saying that we should interpret the plain text more narrowly because the world has changed since then is a very "living Constitution" thing to do.
- rayiner 13y agoThis is not a "no way in hell" issue. The issue of whether Congress should have the power to issue paper money or make them legal tender was debated at the Constitutional convention and left unresolved: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Legal_Tender_Cases#Original_intent_and_original_meaning http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Legal_Tender_Cases#Original_int.... An explicit part of the concern at the Constitutional convention was about not wanting to bind the hands of a future Congress with regards to paper money. Supreme Court cases in the 19th century determined that the power to make notes legal tender was incident to Congress's power to borrow money on the credit of the United States and to "coin Money" and to "regulate the Value thereof." To be fair, this is actually one of the more plausible ones of the various "everything is unconstitutional" myths. At least some of the framers clearly did want to tie the hands of the federal government when it came to making paper money legal tender.
- logfromblammo 13y agoI find the arguments of Alexander Hamilton and his central bank supporters to be self-serving and destructive to the ends of the people. And in my biased and prejudiced opinion, central banking in the US has been an unmitigated disaster every time it has been tried. I don't believe JM Keynes can be used as a foundation for a sound economy, and I don't think monetary inflation is good for anybody except the person doing the inflating. There is good reason for the Constitution to override the status quo of the Articles of Confederation on the subject of minting coinage, but I'm not certain a debate left unresolved regarding paper money is indicative of anything when they did actually agree that a person could be owned, and that was worth 3/5 of a vote. It was either less important than slavery, or more difficult to resolve. I'm inclined to believe the latter. Before descending into full-on libertarded ranting, let's just say that leaving the matter as ambiguous effectively grants the government license to do whatever it pleases and interpret the ambiguity in favor of that. Failing to bind the hands of a future Congress is what allowed them to pick up that grenade and pull the pin.
- rayiner 13y agoI'm not really interested in getting pulled into a 200 year old debate. For better or worse, most of the latent ambiguities in the Constitution were resolved in favor of the interpretation espoused by Hamilton and the Federalists. All I'm saying is that it's not the case that there was this clear Constitutional dictate in one direction that we callously ignored in modern times.
- hashmap 13y agoThe statement does not refer to how states may pay their debts - it refers to their power to issue currencies. "...make any Thing but gold and silver Coin a Tender in Payment of Debts... " means states cannot issue their own currencies as legal tender. They can only make gold or silver legal tenders for debts. The federal government can make paper dollars a legal tender, and the states can pay their debts in that. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Contract_Clause#Legal_Tender http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Contract_Clause#Legal_Tender
- logfromblammo 13y agoDenying a power to the states is not the same as granting it to the federation. The federal government was never authorized to declare anything a legal tender. It was authorized to manufacture coins and say what they are worth. It would be nice to think that the supremes would strike down legal tender laws for that reason, but as they are paid in paper, I don't think it likely in this millennium.
- dragonwriter 13y ago> Legal tender, and paper money are not delegated to the federation, but prohibited to the states, therefore they remain the province of the people. The power to emit debt instruments, including in the form of paper money, is, to the extent it is not included in the power to coin money and regulate its value (Art. I, Sec. 8, cl. 5) a necessary part of the power to borrow (Art. I, Sec. 8, cl. 3). See, inter alia, Juilliard v. Greenman, 110 U.S. 421.
- logfromblammo 13y agoThat's rather disingenuous. When you borrow, the counterparty must have something to lend to you. The creation of new fiat paper money has no counterparty. The power to borrow is to write a promissory note in exchange for a real something, that is later redeemable by giving real somethings to the holder of the note. I can write a note promising to pay a hamburger and a half on Tuesday for a hamburger today. In order for that note to have any sort of economic effect, someone has to give me a hamburger for it. Once it's out there, that's worth 1.5 burgers, and can be traded around at will, but come Tuesday, I need to have 1.5 hamburgers on hand to redeem the note. The paper money notes now circulating in the economy have nothing to do with borrowing. Where is the promise to pay? What is the term of the loan? Why is the US paying the Fed interest to take and use their note? If it were borrowing, the Treasury would print the notes and give them to the Fed in exchange for something. Those are T-bills. The something they get in return is Fed scrip. That is what circulates. That is what they made into legal tender. Do you buy groceries with T-bills? US notes? Gold or silver certificates? No? The federal power to borrow does not apply here. You are not exchanging federal instruments, but notes issued by a private (but legislatively controlled) banking system. If you contract to be paid only in federal coins or instruments, and someone pays you in private bank notes created from thin air instead, the courts will not decide in your favor.