3 ms·
From one of the comments there: "if someone (...) could explain why the line has always been "the metadata" when it is obvious that mass interception of conten
by acqq 13y ago
From one of the comments there:
"if someone (...) could explain why the line has always been "the metadata" when it is obvious that mass interception of content has always been part of the equation i would be grateful.
i would also be grateful if from now on every article relating to the NSA scandal will mention that fact that there is bulk collection of content.
i would also be grateful if from now on every time a public official is questioned or quoted the fact that content is collected in bulk is at the forefront.
every article should contain the fact that these agencies collect nude webcam images in bulk from people who are not suspected of any crime."
- tripzilch 13y agoit was paced like this to make the nay-sayers claiming "there's no such thing, no bulk collection, just metadata, no proof otherwise" over the past few months lose their face. which includes quite a few HN commenters, btw.
- computer 13y agoLet me take a stab at creative government-speak: No, this is also metadata. They are only taking a screenshot every few minutes, with as aim to get a clear picture of the face of the person operating the computer. Just like an email header contains a From-address in the content that's metadata, a webcam session contains the same metadata in the form of these screenshots of people's faces. They're not collecting the data, i.e. the moving webcam video + voice. They have no idea what's being said. Just metadata.
- user24 13y agoMy attempt: NSA: We categorically do not store any content. subtext: we don't, but GCHQ does and they let us search it. That's the real insideousness of the whole five eyes thing. If it's illegal in your country, just get another of the eyes to do it. You can truthfully deny that you do it, while still reaping the benefits as if you had done it. Disgusting subversion of controls that are there for good reasons.