4 ms·
How does 'Tag soup' follow from 'let's not force pedantic XML parsing rules on people'? HTML5 parsing is clearly defined and in most cases quite sensible. I th
by andybak 13y ago
How does 'Tag soup' follow from 'let's not force pedantic XML parsing rules on people'?
HTML5 parsing is clearly defined and in most cases quite sensible. I think it was an excellent compromise.
- mattmanser 13y agoYou say pedantic, while others might say simple, easy to remember, easy to error check and impossible to get wrong.
- alkonaut 13y agoIt's the html5 standard that is complex and pedantic, it breaks silently when you violate one of hundreds of rules (e.g lists of void elements that can't be closed). XML is simple. Sure it's pedantic in the sense that it breaks, but html5 breaks too only subtly. It's like the difference between java and JavaScript. Java isn't more "pedantic" than JS in ANY way, it just breaks in a more understandable way (break loudly, early and understandably is in my view "better").