3 ms·
How exactly would/could MtGox prove they originally owned the 700k coins and then lost access to them? I like the idea, but how would anyone be able to do this
by meowface 13y ago
How exactly would/could MtGox prove they originally owned the 700k coins and then lost access to them?
I like the idea, but how would anyone be able to do this without the risk of coin "duping" (in MMO terminology)?
- haakon 13y agoThis is exactly why such a scheme, while well-intentioned, would utterly destroy confidence in Bitcoin.
- teraflop 13y agoIf they can produce logs of every single transaction they've ever done, including moving coins to the cold wallet, then anyone who wants to could examine the blockchain and match up transaction times and addresses with MtGox's claims. If they tried to claim ownership of someone else's wallet, that person could easily disprove their claim by signing an address with the corresponding private key. No matter how thorough the audit, it wouldn't be enough to convince every last user of the system. But it only has to convince enough people that the few remaining holdouts are forced to either follow suit or create a fork.
- marme 13y agoThe idea is not to recreate the coins. The idea is to allow MtGox to make a transaction from a wallet that supposedly they have lost the private key to, this is a wallet that has hundreds of thousands of BTC in it so not many people could be claiming ownership. The way security work with BTC is that to make a transaction you must have your private key sign the transaction to prove you are the owner of the wallet. If the transaction is not correctly signed it is rejected as a fraudulent transaction. The idea is to let MtGox make a fraudulent transaction from a wallet they have lost access to. They would convince 51% of the miners to accept the unsigned or incorrectly signed transaction as being legit and the transfer would go through. There is no duping of coins as the original wallet that is inaccessible would be drained of coins.
- meowface 13y agoI understand that, but it's a chicken and egg problem. How can MtGox prove they own the wallet they're trying to make a fraudulent transaction from if they don't hold the associated private key?