4 ms·

Ask HN: Ubuntu PC or a MAC

6 points by dawie 17y ago

Should I buy an PC and throw Ubuntu on it, or just get a Mac?

there 17y ago
uh, what are you going to use it for? do you have experience using either operating system?
icey 17y ago
If you are comfortable with Linux I would recommend Ubuntu. They're both fine choices, but you'll get more bang for your buck with Linux than with OS X. (I do most of my development at home on a Mac. I don't like dicking around with my operating system though.)
jacquesm 17y ago
I have both and in practice I find that I use the ubuntu pc for almost everything except mac compatibility testing. The main reason I guess is that most of my servers run linux and I don't need to mentally make the switch from one flavour of unix to another ten times per day. Stuff on my dev box lives in exactly the same places as it does on my production machines. The mac is very slick though, but that's not a good enough reason to buy one if you have to choose between them.
alexitosrv 17y ago
I also have both, and I rarely use the mac (a MBP) except for demos. The mac is really pretty, but almost all the hard work is done in a hp laptop connected to a 25.5" monitor, external mouse and keyboard and running windows xp and a couple of virtualbox machines. Use whatever tool make you more productive. Don't waste money in a mac just because fashion.
TallGuyShort 17y ago
I think Macs are targeted towards art/design professions, and casual home users. I think they're great for those audiences, but unless you fall into one of those categories, I think Ubuntu is the right choice. It's very stable, lightning fast, has a ton of great software, and it's free (comes on cheaper, more versatile hardware, too).
spooneybarger 17y ago
Ok, I'll bite. What do you do? I have a Mac right now. Why? I do tons of web dev and I need to test multiple environments- mac, windows etc. I can do all that with one machine via virtual machines. Not so easy to do mac os testing with a PC. I do most of my dev in a debian vm that is setup to exactly match our production machines.
dlevine 17y ago
I use my mac for everything. Our application is hosted off of ubuntu servers, and it's pretty seamless to switch between the two. My business partner runs ubuntu on his laptop - he has to boot windows to do photoshop, but that's pretty much it. The Mac OS is prettier. I would suspect that it gives you a better experience on a laptop than Ubuntu does. For some reason, I like my macbook better than I liked my thinkpad before that. If you don't care about such things, you might be better off with Ubuntu.
dawie 17y ago
I am using it for Rails Dev and Web development, but I want dual monitors. I see that the Mac Mini does not offer this. The problem that I am running into is that Rails behave differently on my Vista laptop than it does on my VPS and I and it's causing me quite a bit of grief. I just want to be up and running as soon as possible.
garnet7 17y ago
If you want a "just works" experience, but still want to stick with free software, maybe check out http://laclinux.com/gnu/GNU_Linux_Computers http://laclinux.com/gnu/GNU_Linux_Computers

6 points by dawie 17y ago

Should I buy an PC and throw Ubuntu on it, or just get a Mac?

there 17y ago

uh, what are you going to use it for? do you have experience using either operating system?

icey 17y ago

If you are comfortable with Linux I would recommend Ubuntu. They're both fine choices, but you'll get more bang for your buck with Linux than with OS X. (I do most of my development at home on a Mac. I don't like dicking around with my operating system though.)

jacquesm 17y ago

I have both and in practice I find that I use the ubuntu pc for almost everything except mac compatibility testing. The main reason I guess is that most of my servers run linux and I don't need to mentally make the switch from one flavour of unix to another ten times per day. Stuff on my dev box lives in exactly the same places as it does on my production machines. The mac is very slick though, but that's not a good enough reason to buy one if you have to choose between them.

alexitosrv 17y ago

I also have both, and I rarely use the mac (a MBP) except for demos. The mac is really pretty, but almost all the hard work is done in a hp laptop connected to a 25.5" monitor, external mouse and keyboard and running windows xp and a couple of virtualbox machines. Use whatever tool make you more productive. Don't waste money in a mac just because fashion.

TallGuyShort 17y ago

I think Macs are targeted towards art/design professions, and casual home users. I think they're great for those audiences, but unless you fall into one of those categories, I think Ubuntu is the right choice. It's very stable, lightning fast, has a ton of great software, and it's free (comes on cheaper, more versatile hardware, too).

spooneybarger 17y ago

Ok, I'll bite. What do you do? I have a Mac right now. Why? I do tons of web dev and I need to test multiple environments- mac, windows etc. I can do all that with one machine via virtual machines. Not so easy to do mac os testing with a PC. I do most of my dev in a debian vm that is setup to exactly match our production machines.

dlevine 17y ago

I use my mac for everything. Our application is hosted off of ubuntu servers, and it's pretty seamless to switch between the two. My business partner runs ubuntu on his laptop - he has to boot windows to do photoshop, but that's pretty much it. The Mac OS is prettier. I would suspect that it gives you a better experience on a laptop than Ubuntu does. For some reason, I like my macbook better than I liked my thinkpad before that. If you don't care about such things, you might be better off with Ubuntu.

dawie 17y ago

I am using it for Rails Dev and Web development, but I want dual monitors. I see that the Mac Mini does not offer this. The problem that I am running into is that Rails behave differently on my Vista laptop than it does on my VPS and I and it's causing me quite a bit of grief. I just want to be up and running as soon as possible.

garnet7 17y ago

If you want a "just works" experience, but still want to stick with free software, maybe check out http://laclinux.com/gnu/GNU_Linux_Computers http://laclinux.com/gnu/GNU_Linux_Computers