9 ms·
I was all ready to be skeptical and everything... but this could actually be amazing. I currently use Chocolat for code editing, which is beautifully elegant a
by crazygringo 13y ago
I was all ready to be skeptical and everything... but this could actually be amazing.
I currently use Chocolat for code editing, which is beautifully elegant and I love it, but there are 25 little tiny things that I really wish I could fix. I file issues, but the developers rightly have their own priorities. It's closed-source, but even if it were open source, I'm not about to learn how to use XCode and Objective C and figure out how to compile and whatnot.
But if Atom is ultimately just a big collection of straight-up node.js files, and anyone can go in at any time to change a line here or there -- and it's in JavaScript, so it couldn't be easier for programmers in general -- and there's no compilation step or anything -- then it's almost a fundamental paradigm shift for what desktop software could be.
It already makes me dream of a word processor I could hack like that, or a music player. Just by opening up a text editor. It's an inspiring thought.
- adamors 13y ago> and there's no compilation step or anything -- then it's almost a fundamental paradigm shift for what desktop software could be. > It already makes me dream of a word processor I could hack like that, or a music player. Just by opening up a text editor. It's an inspiring thought. Not to rain on your parade or anything, but you can already do this with Emacs, not to mention that Emacs is free, open source software. Atom is not only not open source but their readme says it won't even be free after the beta. Emacs has been around for almost 40 years, and because it's FOSS it will be around for at least another 40. Editors like Atom come and go.
- michaelmior 13y ago> Atom is free during the beta period. Where does it say it won't be free after the beta period?
- adamors 13y agoWell, one can only assume, based on the wording they use here: https://github.com/atom/welcome/blob/master/lib/welcome.md https://github.com/atom/welcome/blob/master/lib/welcome.md > Atom is free during the beta period.
- dustyleary 13y agoHow refreshing, a correct usage of "the exception that proves the rule"!
- doorhammer 13y agoAnd there goes four hours of my night to wikipedia
- atommclain 13y agoThis reminds me of one of Mitch Hedberg's more famous jokes: "I used to do drugs. I still do, but I used to, too."
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- dragonwriter 13y agoOne can assume that, but that's not what it says. The statement that the editor is free during beta could mean "we haven't figured out whether to sell it after the beta, sell services around it, or develop integration with our other services and keep it free to enhance our overall value proposition."
- kuntau 13y agoAtom won't be closed source, but it won't be open source either. It will be somewhere inbetween, making it easy for us to charge for Atom while still making the source available under a restrictive license so you can see how everything works. We haven't finalized exactly how this will work yet. We will have full details ready for the official launch. > http://discuss.atom.io/t/why-is-atom-closed-source/82/9 http://discuss.atom.io/t/why-is-atom-closed-source/82/9
- crazygringo 13y agoTrue, but it's a question of accessibility. Far more people can program in JavaScript than Lisp, and far more people use GUI desktop software that follows traditional GUI user-interface paradigms, than do things inside their terminal. (Edit: or terminal-style buffers/frames.) So that's why my statement was limited to what "desktop software" could be. :) I mean, I use LibreOffice, which is FOSS, but I am never going to touch its code in a million years. The cost-to-benefit ratio is too high. But Atom makes doing that sound almost trivial. That's the paradigm shift.
- rjzzleep 13y agoso write ruby or python for vim then. not saying vim doesn't have it shortcomings, but people always forget that a scripting language for random app xyz still means you have to learn it's grammar. just like people who use ruby motion have to painfully learn that in the end while it looks like ruby it's still cocoa.
- adamors 13y agoEmacs is GUI desktop software. Few people use it in a terminal. Also, people didn't born knowing Javascript. They learnt it. And one could argue that Lisp is just as easy to learn, if not easier.
- pete_aykroyd 13y agoI mostly agree with that although I think it's also kind of irrelevant in a practical sense because many programmers already have to know javascript for their work so you get a lot more people who can contribute right away. Aside from that -- lisp or javascript as the extension language, I'd love to see a brand-new extensible editor like emacs just to have a shot at changing terminology and some of the APIs. Emacs terminology is a little off-putting because it was invented before the GUIs were widely adopted so it doesn't map that well. I also find some of the APIs a bit weird, but that could just be me.
- adamors 13y agoIt's true that a lot of people work with Javascript, but honestly I wouldn't say that they can contribute to anything right away. A lot of these people don't know more than $('#element').hide(); In fact, I would wager that there are more potential contributors to Emacs than there are to Atom.
- ibrahima 13y agoOh what, it's not open source? The little interest I had in this just evaporated. I would definitely be interested in something like Emacs built on modern technologies, but Emacs is already there and quite good. I feel like something like this could be neat, just because far more people know HTML/JS than Elisp, but if it's not open source that kills my enthusiasm for the project.
- dusklight 13y agocheck out lighttable [http://www.chris-granger.com/2014/01/07/light-table-is-open-source/ http://www.chris-granger.com/2014/01/07/light-table-is-open-...]
- lord_quas 13y agoCheckout lighttable.el https://github.com/Fuco1/litable https://github.com/Fuco1/litable
- reeses 13y agoNice. I was able to read and understand the whole implementation on my phone. Of course, thanks to Apple, I can't load and eval it, but I will take it for a spin when I get to a machine. :)
- ytpete 13y agoBrackets (http://brackets.io/ http://brackets.io/) is another option - it's MIT-licensed, and also written in JavaScript.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- cmelbye 13y agoAtom is not only not open source but ... Do you have a source for this? I'd be very disappointed to hear that if it were true. EDIT: It appears that this isn't true. From a GitHub employee in freenode/##atom: <jonrohan> EvanDotPro: it will be open source, and other platforms, when it's out of beta <chance> jonrohan: where are you getting that information? <jonrohan> chance: i work at github
- girvo 13y ago> not only open source That means the opposite of what you thought it did :)
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- tricolon 13y agoIt was > not only not
- chimeracoder 13y agoFrom Tom Preston-Warner: http://discuss.atom.io/t/why-is-atom-closed-source/82/8 http://discuss.atom.io/t/why-is-atom-closed-source/82/8 > Atom won't be closed source, but it won't be open source either. It will be somewhere inbetween, making it easy for us to charge for Atom while still making the source available under a restrictive license so you can see how everything works. We haven't finalized exactly how this will work yet. We will have full details ready for the official launch. Either jonrohan is misinformed, or he's using a rather tortured definition of "open source" - even the Open Source Initiative would disagree with that usage[0]. I must say, I'm a bit disappointed by the fact that Github doesn't seem to be on the same page internally about this; it's a rather important piece of information. [0]http://opensource.org/definition http://opensource.org/definition
- baddox 13y agoI'm with you. I'm an Emacs user, which ostensibly has a similar design philosophy (open source, with powerful extensibility from a full-blown programming language), but Emacs Lisp has a lot of baggage and is nowhere near as widely used as JavaScript. I also find the Emacs community disjointed and hard to navigate and participate in. Ultimately, assuming that the underlying design decisions of Atom are reasonable, its success will depend on the community that develops (double meaning intended) around it. It could be great.
- davidw 13y ago> Emacs Lisp has a lot of baggage and is nowhere near as widely used as JavaScript Back in the 90ies, when I started using Emacs, Elisp had a lot of baggage and was nowhere near as widely used as Perl. I'm still using Emacs.
- nilsbunger 13y agoHave you looked at Adobe Brackets? It's basically that, open-sourced today. Or look at node-webkit if you only want the app framework without the editor. The biggest downside I see right now is HUGE binaries (100+MB) because you're bundling a browser in your exe.
- encoderer 13y agoBrowsers are 100+MB?
- coercer 13y ago> but even if it were open source, I'm not about to learn how to use XCode and Objective C and figure out how to compile and whatnot. It's such a shame that modern web "development" has instilled this lack of curiosity in so many people. It really is disheartening to see that a generation of programmers has been lost to this "if I can't accomplish it in 2 clicks with a JS framework then I won't bother learning" mentality...
- freshyill 13y agoYou are so on-the-money about Chocolat. I love it except for the things that drive me crazy. I've been trying to love Sublime Text lately. Even though I see the benefits, I see the un-Mac-like-ness of it even more.
- adito 13y ago> But if Atom is ultimately just a big collection of straight-up node.js files, and anyone can go in at any time to change a line here or there -- and it's in JavaScript, so it couldn't be easier for programmers in general -- and there's no compilation step or anything -- then it's almost a fundamental paradigm shift for what desktop software could be. http://discuss.atom.io/t/atom-is-so-powerful-that-it-blows-my-mind/294 http://discuss.atom.io/t/atom-is-so-powerful-that-it-blows-m... > How I felt after that? I felt awesome. I had only installed Atom minutes ago. I didn't even had to think to fix my problem. All the knowledge I needed was already in my head! It was simple as editing a webpage. TL;DR: Atom allowed me to fix one simple problem – that I still encounter in most text editors nowadays – in seconds. What about yours?
- alextgordon 13y agoIt's funny you say that, because as the only full time-ish developer of Chocolat, I could really use a lot of help! There's ~600 open issues, my personal todo list alone is several years' worth of work. Too much for one man. --- People make too much of open vs closed source. The real distinction is individual-lead vs committee-written. TextMate, Sublime and Vim are good editors. But they are also Allan, Jon and Bram. Writing an editor requires good taste, accumulated experience, and a certain disregard for users' feelings. You need someone who cares about the editor. Without that, you get a program where everything is wrong, but nobody ever bothers to fix it. This is however a blessing and a curse. If the author can't financially support themselves, the editor will die. If the author becomes a millionaire, the editor will die. Thankfully, I'm still poor. --- What are the 25 little things, by the way?
- crazygringo 13y agoHaha, too much work indeed. :) I'm not going to list all 25 here, but I'd say the biggest three are definitely issues #1157 (this is HUGE, add a pref option please!!), #1369 (please!), and #1451/1417 (constantly crashing). But overall, it's still just the most beautiful and elegant editor. :) Thanks for it!
- cormullion 13y agoNever heard of Chocolat before - but it is a very attractive OS X app!
- bruceboughton 13y ago>> and it's in JavaScript, so it couldn't be easier for programmers in general Because JavaScript is magically easier than any other programming language ever invented. Even if this were true, it still wouldn't help an expert Objective C programmer with no JS experience hack on Atom. Your bias is showing.
- pdpi 13y agoAdobe has been working on Brackets for a while, and it's essentially the exact same concept.
- ricardobeat 13y agoThat is also one of the ideas behind Light Table.