4 ms·
In an economy where attention is the currency, someone takes your work and uses it to gather attention to themselves -- attention that would otherwise have bee
by smacktoward 13y ago
In an economy where attention is the currency, someone takes your work and uses it to gather attention to themselves -- attention that would otherwise have been yours.
How is that not stealing?
- bad_user 13y agoThis argument is the same as the one MPAA makes about lost revenue due to piracy, which in general is bullshit, because there is no guarantee that those people pirating stuff would have ever paid for it if pirating wasn't possible. So the answer is easy - you can't talk about stealing "attention", when the "attention" you're talking about never existed in the first place.
- JWLong 13y agoAnd you can't sue someone for lost wages when those wages have yet to be earned.
- nawitus 13y agoBy definition it is not.
- gutnor 13y agoAgreed. We can call copying a DVD copyright infringement, after all a viewer would not necessarily have bought the DVD so calling it theft is incorrect. However, cloning a Youtube video is closer to theft. Removing a viewer is directly decreasing the value of the video for Google. It is also key to various legal actions that have happened recently against Google news: some Belgian Companies wanted a cut of Google revenue for showing part of their articles. As much as it hurt my feeling as a older gen internet user, they have a point in this new world where traffic is revenue.
- randomdata 13y agoIf I legally purchase something that is the last of a finite resource, a resource that otherwise could have been yours, am I stealing? I did, after all, take away the opportunity for you to purchase said resource.
- ManFromUranus 13y agoYour analogy is flawed because in this case nobody purchased or requested anything. If your analogy was accurate it would be better stated: If I go into your garage and take your snowblower, and rent it out while you're not using it, without asking you, or giving you any money, how is that stealing?
- randomdata 13y agoIf we lived in some magical world where you could make an exact copy my snowblower and rent out that copy when I wasn't using mine, I don't see any problem and would not consider it stealing. Otherwise, your analogy appears to be theft by the letter of the law. Perhaps a better analogy is when you rent/loan out your snowblower, are you stealing from the manufacturer who otherwise could have made additional sales to your rental customers? That would cover your demand component.
- millstone 13y agoCopyright infringement (purportedly) hurts the content creators, not the legitimate purchasers. You can't be denied revenue unless you seek profit. So to stretch this analogy: the snowblower is the Snow Master 1.0, your own unique design, the pinnacle of years of research. Someone else comes along, magically copies it without your permission, and, having no costs to recoup, undercuts you in the market. I don't know if that's stealing, but I do know you'll think very hard before starting work on Snow Master 2.0.
- angersock 13y agoThat's weird, because I can't buy gas for my car with attention. Or a sandwich. Or a cup of coffee. So, erm, we don't live in that economy. As a thought experiment, though, let's assume we have a magical attention-based currency. Attention is not quantifiable, it is not fungible, and it is not storable. So, erm, why the fuck would you use it as a currency?