2 ms·
The shipping industry has been disrupted many times. Two of the more recent ones are the transformation to containerized shipping, and the switch to slow steami
by dalke 13y ago
The shipping industry has been disrupted many times. Two of the more recent ones are the transformation to containerized shipping, and the switch to slow steaming.
The Maersk's Triple E class ships, for example, are less powerful than the previous generation of ships.
The next disruption is likely the New Panamax will allow ships with up to 13,000 TEU through the Panama Canal, rather than the old limit of about 5,000.
This disruption, and the creation of the Panama and Suez canals, are counter-examples to your idea that people "don't want to discuss, even as speculation" disruptive ideas. Some don't - the British didn't want the competition to their India trade - but certainly many, including Napolean, wanted a Suez canal.
> The heuristic is not that they object, it is that they don't want to discuss, even as speculation.
What if I proposed a nuclear powered aircraft. There are obvious advantages, like unlimited range. Airports wouldn't need the fueling infrastructure, so flights to, say, Easter Island wouldn't have to also pay to get the jet fuel there for the return flight. Ground crew could smoke. It would be highly disruptive, yes?
Of course, there will be people who dismiss it right away. "The reactor and shielding will be too heavy", "there's too much risk in case of accident", "the R&D costs are too high", and so on. Most don't even want to discuss what nuclear powered air travel could do, even as speculation. Each one could shut down the conversation.
By your heuristic, airplane power production is an undisrupted industry.
While the reality is that those objections are absolutely true, and are some of the reasons why we don't have atomic aircraft.
This means your heuristic is wrong, or at least incomplete.
Some ideas are disruptive .. but either physically impossible or economically nonviable.
How do you judge if this ides isn't in one of those two categories? You presume that drone designs will be up and running at some point. What if that point is 100 years in the future? Why should people now be concerned with it?