3 ms·
That's a good argument for publicly funded research, the products of which become available to be leveraged by business across the economy. That doesn't mean th
by simonh 13y ago
That's a good argument for publicly funded research, the products of which become available to be leveraged by business across the economy. That doesn't mean that vertically directed, product focused research within companies is a bad thing. Without it smartphone tech would be years behind where we are today, and the Mac would never have happened which means Windows may never have happened, at least when and in the form that it did.
This is also an argument against a strictly enforced and restrictive patent system. If inventors are incapable of turning their inventions into viable products, then the broader economy and public interest may actually be best served by allowing others to make use of those inventions without punitive licensing terms. I'm not anti-patent, but it seems to me the current patent system is far from optimal.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- dnautics 13y agoNo, that's a good argument for nonprofit research. It's not necessarily the case that funding it publically is a good idea. Public funds, because they are allocated through a political process, are therefore potentially subject to political control and manipulation for political ends. Moreover because the public doesn't have the granular ability to say 'no' to this use of their taxes, public funds ought to (rightfully so) be held to a level of accountability and scrutiny that is antithetical to basic research. How do you make sure public funds going into 'basic' research doesn't wind up subsidizing the intellectual masturbation of a professor from the 'haves' academic caste? (BTW this happens so much via NIH funding it's disgusting) Private nonprofits have a higher level of freedom to innovate and discover in an unrestricted fashion. That is why crazy hypotheses such as the chemiosmotic theory (which wound up being more or less correct) were discovered by private nonprofit research institutes. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peter_D._Mitchell https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peter_D._Mitchell It's not in the wiki article but at the time the general scientific consensus was that he was crazy and there was no way an electrochemical gradient could power a cell.