The catch here is that content providers don't want to give in to DMCA complaints. That's why chilling effects exists. Providers will often go a long way to be

The catch here is that content providers don't want to give in to DMCA complaints. That's why chilling effects exists. Providers will often go a long way to be as permissive as possible and to cause as much pain for frivolous complaints as possible. Also give some credits to judges. They won't just give in because a company is rich and litigious, well at least not in most districts :)