3 ms·
We can agree to disagree about the nature of the intervention being suggested. As to testability, you have to remember that I believe we're still in the abduct
by DanielBMarkham 17y ago
We can agree to disagree about the nature of the intervention being suggested.
As to testability, you have to remember that I believe we're still in the abduction stage of climate science -- finding the patterns from the data. We haven't even reached the hypothesis stage. So the 1500-year and solar-input theories are all about pattern-spotting. If a pattern is spotted, then I'm sure we can begin talking about hypotheses.
That's just where the science is, at least for me. That doesn't mean that it's "full" or "mature" science. I guess I'd call it honest science.
Yes, it does seem as if the political language has shifted away from "warming" to "change". Perhaps because warming is actually something you could conceivably measure? Whereas "change" is what, exactly? One of the signs that something is not science is when it gets stretched to meet incoming data that would normally disprove it.
One does not have to deny anything. Indeed, the onus is on the scientist to prove a connection, not the skeptic. You're getting it backwards. Perhaps we just don't understand how the climate works, and won't for another 500 years. Ignorance is the default position. It's up to science to move us from that. "deniers" have nothing to do with anything.
If the problem seems to go away - the Arctic starts freezing again -- why is the arctic thawing a "problem". Because sea levels will rise? And because some people can't move out of the way quickly enough? You see, we go immediately from observation to guesswork to moral outrage to political action. Something wrong with that. From a political standpoint, I find it odd that we have some idea of what a "problem" is. When I ask about this, I've yet to get an answer that makes any sense to me. It all sounds so much like "Man changes environment. Man is bad. Therefore, change is bad" If a thousand sheep run across a mountaintop and ruin the tundra it's natural, but take a thousand people with cameras doing the same thing and it's a travesty.
These are aesthetic considerations, not scientific ones. I agree with most people's view of beauty in these areas -- who wants a ruined mountaintop or dirty air? But the devil is in the details here.
Science is self-correcting. I'm a hug fan of way science works. It's the intellectual light we have in the darkness. In practice, however, it's done in a very political atmosphere. People hang on to old ideas for a long time after they've been disproven. Not all new ideas are subjected to the same skepticism. Scientists are very cliquish. Science propagandizes itself to the masses -- scientists are always pure and noble. Progress always happens in a straight line.
We can also agree to disagree about science and politics. When I see government employees who are scientists lobby for political causes that directly support their research -- and then call dissenters "deniers" "uneducated" "rubes" "shills" -- we've entered a bad feedback loop.
- robg 17y agoThe problem with the Arctic melting isn't one particular result. It's that we have no frickin' idea what the range of effects could be or if they're bad. We may end up wasting a lot of resources trying to understand the myriad changes. But current theory at least suggests one common cause. The goal is to see if we can change the climate by changing carbon output. Don't we have to see how that plays out? As to the abduction stage, the data absolutely has to be collected. Would any climate scientist say otherwise? The problem is if there are multiple competing hypotheses, and one has a clear set of tests, that's the one that will get funding and move forward. As it should. We can only test testable hypotheses. Those that require more data until tests can be developed will inherently lag behind. Not only is that the way science works, it's only way it could work. That's what I don't understand about where you're coming from. You believe in the scientific method but with concerns about how humans practice it. You also believe that some hypotheses don't have enough data to support specific tests. But how does that take you to rejecting current efforts? That is science and it is hypothesis testing. If the hypotheses are wrong, climate scientists will need to come up with new hypotheses. Sure, many will die clinging to the old ones. But the new generation will be forced to do so - to publish, gets grants, be honored faculty, etc. There's a club but there is wide latitude to question prevailing logic even if it sometimes takes decades. It's an entrepreneurship of ideas. As for politics, I'll go so far to say that a representative democracy helps to correct Science and her focus through funding priorities. It makes science somewhat accountable to the will of the people. You could still do science in a fascist regime. But you'd end up with eugenics and human testing without informed consent. That doesn't mean the Western system is perfect. Not at all. I just have a hard time thinking about how it could be better. It may be a bad feedback loop, but it isn't a closed one. Your oaths are a good idea. But I think they're unnecessary. Good science replicates. It's really that simple. If experimental outcomes aren't repeatable that scientific line of thought withers and dies. You can continue to pump in funding, but sooner or later the priorities change and, sure, sometimes for the worse. The same is true of the current approach to climate change. If we control or reduce worldwide carbon output and we see climate changes back closer toward the early 20th c. then the assumptions in the carbon "theory" will be strengthen. If we don't, it won't. Carbon output won't be the theory. That process may take a generation or three, but it will play itself out. Without an alternative testable hypothesis, what else can we do until we discover one? To come back to one possibility. Suppose you're right that cloud cover is a big part of climate change. Now suppose that Sadir Smith invents device in his garage that takes the humidity in clouds and turns it into fresh water and using solar power. The more the device clears the clouds the more it's able to generate its own power. Fresh water. Fewer clouds. No more carbon. Don't you think an enterprising scientist will see this and start to study its effects on the local climate? Won't another scientist try to expand the program internationally? Soon there will be conferences and journals devoted to "cloud hydration". I think a big part of the problem is we're witnessing the creation of a new form of science and one that no seems to understand. But that's exactly it. We won't understand this science until we do science. Testing hypotheses is the only way to do science.