4 ms·
Oh, so we've come full circle. Don't download random Windows apps from the internet, they're bad for your PC! Hey, here's my nice shiny app store where the ap
by oblio 13y ago
Oh, so we've come full circle.
Don't download random Windows apps from the internet, they're bad for your PC!
Hey, here's my nice shiny app store where the applications are curated. Only quality content, categorized, free of spyware and other distractions.
Oh no - market pressure has pushed the bar lower and lower and I once again have to rely on the Internet for reviews and comparisons of apps in order to install only the decent and trustworthy apps.
Kind of sounds like the Windows model all over again. But this time I have to go through your BS systems to publish an app on my own device. Yay progress!
- dredmorbius 13y agoAnd the answer which the Linux world came up with: we're going to offer you a repository with your distro from which you can obtain most or all of the applications you need. In the case of one particular distro, Debian, this was backed by a Social Contract[1] and Constitution[2], expressed in Policy[3] which was ultimately enacted by A Package Tool (APT)[4] with user feedback and interaction supported through the Debian Bug Tracking System (BTS)[5]. Among the principles of the Social Contract: "Our priorities are our users and free software". The result: a distro with a tremendous number of packages available (49,614 on my jessie/sid install), in which the significant concerns are user experience (including privacy and security), and freedom of software. The last possibly best exemplified in LWN's coverage of a story ... wow, already a decade ago, on LWN: "Debian and the hot babe problem". It concerned an "ITP" (intent to package) a new piece of software. I'll let Jon Corbet take it from here: The program involved is hot-babe, a graphical CPU utilization monitor. It works by displaying a typical Bruno Bellamy drawing of a minimally-clad, maximally-endowed woman. As the CPU gets busier ("hotter"), the woman undresses to compensate. Your editor, whose journalistic ethics required that he investigate this utility, found it to be an amusing addition to the desktop - for about five minutes, or until the children walk in, whichever comes first. The Debian developers raised the obvious, predictable objection to the inclusion of this utility: the associated images were covered by a non-free license. Hot babes notwithstanding, one thing I noticed Debian didn't have problems with a decade ago were drive-by installs of spyware and adware which were plaguing Windows at the time. That, um, "ecosystem" has now moved into the mobile space, and the negative equity and goodwill associated will, I suspect, play out in time there as well.
- diminish 13y agoAnd Debian got first release on August 16th, 1993; 20 years ago. It saved many from shareware/crapware app-colypse of 90s. Am I the only on dreaming of Debian (an exactly Debian) developing an app repository (at least for Android), where free apps are carefully supported, building on top of each other where no tricks or crap exist.
- pekk 13y agoSure, if instead of Android you mean a Linux distribution for phones
- girvo 13y agoF-Droid? Yeah, it's not really "debian" per-se, and it has it's own issues, but it's close.
- dredmorbius 13y agoI'm looking forward to native Linux on a mobile platform. Preferably a tablet.
- mseebach 13y agoGoogle could help kickstart that ecosystem by offering a promotion category for "Best Free/Open Source apps" in Play. Only apps with a GPL compatible license and fully buildable from a public repo are eligible.
- shawn-furyan 13y agoI'm not sure Google has the incentives in place to be interested in this, but it seems like a perfect fit for CyanogenMod as they try to grow as a platform.
- mseebach 13y agoThe incentive is that Google will benefit form having an ecosystem of high quality apps. A good ecosystem lowers the bar to creating high quality apps - the non-app open source software ecosystem is pretty conclusive proof of that. But you're right - CyanogenMod is probably a better forum for such an ecosystem to bootstrap.
- _pmf_ 13y ago> Oh no - market pressure has pushed the bar lower and lower Considering the Apple store, market pressure has nothing to do with it. It has been 95% ultra low-quality, ultra-low quality crap from the beginning (stuff that a Shareware site from 1998 would have been ashamed to host).