4 ms·
Hello, downsides of unregulated currency. Some of the rules are there for a reason.
by untog 13y ago
Hello, downsides of unregulated currency. Some of the rules are there for a reason.
- agorabinary 13y agoExcept when the rules result in say, Weimar.
- untog 13y agoWell, sure. It would be pretty idiotic to suggest that every rule ever thought up was a good idea.
- dnautics 13y agono but there's a pretty bad track record of currency collapse. Diocletian. Confederate States of America. Weimar. Yugoslavia. Argentina. Zimbabwe. Venezuela. Edit: Looking at my list, I should have listed one for every alphabet Letter, instead of going chronologically.
- anigbrowl 13y agoconsidering the time spans and number of countries, that's not actually that bad. Sure, there have been many other less famous examples, but the thing is that hyperinflation and currency collapse is actually quite rare. A lot of bitcoin boosters seemed to be under the impression that it was both inevitable and frequent. Also, this list is strongly correlated with catastrophic economic/political problems, as opposed to countries that were rolling along just fine until a sudden monetary-policy mistake.
- dnautics 13y agowell, small catastophes aggregate themselves in centralized economies. I'll strongly suggest you read this (which I linked to above): [0]http://www.overstock.com/Books-Movies-Music-Games/The-Mis-Behavior-of-Markets-A-Fractal-View-of-Financial-Turbulence-Paperback/1742370/product.html?refccid=GSUOBJC4S2E3ZDKGRT73NX6FC4&searchidx=0 http://www.overstock.com/Books-Movies-Music-Games/The-Mis-Be... Financial losses and windfalls / catastrophes happen far more frequently than you'd expect. Also, my list is subject to dnautic's memory bias. Those are the names that I remember. There are certainly more. There is no currency in the history of the world that has lasted forever.
- dnautics 13y agoPlumbing my memory, I can add another: Brazil The cruzeiro was replaced by the "cruzeiro real" literally "real cruzeiro", as a hack to recover from poor fiscal policy resulting in hyperinflation. The cruzeiro real was then replaced by the 'real'. Imagine things getting so bad that the government decides to rebrand its old currency as 'fake'.
- untog 13y agoBut that's another example of a currency collapsing as a result of external (political) pressures. This was something that Bitcoin did all by itself.
- bmelton 13y agoThe failure of one exchange is not a currency collapse.
- dnautics 13y agoI don't think there is any meaningful dichotomy between "external" and "internal" anything with regard to a currency. If an "external" asteroid hits a country and destroys all the users of a given currency, it goes to zero, but that is a meaningful measure of the value of the "internal" exchanges that are going on as valued in that currency.
- grey-area 13y agoYou could start with Assignats...
- baddox 13y agoIt sounds like you're saying that having rules (as opposed to having no rules) is a good idea, but only if there is some mechanism that makes good rules more likely than bad rules.
- thesimpsons1022 13y agoBecause bad rules can exist doesn't mean all rules are bad. Just because bad can laws exist doesn't mean all laws are bad. libertarians can't seem to understand this.
- FLUX-YOU 13y agoBrings back memories of banking scams in EVE Online
- dmm 13y agoBusinesses fail all the time. Most startups fail. Should we have more startup regulation? Failure is a normal part of the market. What's really scary are the businesses that are never allowed to fail.
- untog 13y agoStartups tend not to hold vast sums of money on behalf of their customers.
- smellelderberry 13y agoYeeaaahh regulated companies that handle vast amounts of money for their customers never get into any trouble.
- landryraccoon 13y agoIf you're talking about banks, they're insured and if the bank fails you still get your money back though.
- smellelderberry 13y agoYou mean with that $25B that FDIC has to insure $10T of deposits? That insurance? http://www.occ.gov/topics/capital-markets/financial-markets/trading/derivatives/dq312.pdf http://www.occ.gov/topics/capital-markets/financial-markets/...
- leot 13y agoDepending on the nature of the risk, yes, that might be enough insurance. Bank deposit insurance is fascinating: it largely exists to prevent bank runs, which are caused by people believing they won't get their money out. Having any insurance means that people have less reason to believe there's a chance they won't get paid back, which decreases the probability of a run on the bank, which decreases the risk associated with the insurance, which decreases the amount of insurance needed.
- crassus 13y agoWhere we're going, the rules will be written in software
- the_ancient 13y agoYes because government currency is such a Utopia......
- colept 13y agoThis is the very reason why Bitcoin needs to policed from a decentralized standpoint. I don't know much about the logistics of crypto-currencies but from my understanding there are public/private keys involved. It should be possible that one can blacklist their own bitcoin address by using the private key. This way at least crooks cannot make off or use the stolen coins. Do any more technical Bitcoin fanatics have any thoughts about this?
- plaguuuuuu 13y agoFirst, it would be pretty disastrous being able to blacklist money after spending it (by giving it to someone else) Second, AFAIK crooks need the private key to steal it, so wouldn't work anyway.
- wmf 13y agoPeople usually don't refer to securing their own money as "blacklisting". Look into cold wallets, hardware wallets, and multisignature transactions.
- baddox 13y agoHow would any existing regulated system handle a similar situation to this? Or are you suggesting that bad things like this never happen in regulated systems?
- smellelderberry 13y agoBailouts.
- djur 13y agoBailouts, plus a regulatory apparatus making fraud and deception harder to get away with, plus criminal and civil liability for illegal financial activity. But what's the state good for anyway?
- smellelderberry 13y agoBy "civil liability," do you mean fining a company $10M for stealing $100B? And let's not pretend that bankers go to jail often.
- FedRegister 13y agoI'd support if you mean "death by hanging in the public square" by criminal liability for illegal financial activity. Make the corporation pay back every penny they got illegally, then hang the bastards high to set an example.
- logicchains 13y agoSo instead of the the people who knowingly took a risk in investing in a risky prospect suffering, taxpayers who took no such risks have to foot the bill instead? Great.
- smellelderberry 13y agoNo no no, I meant a bailout by Saint Satoshi. He will return on the 13th day after the fall of Gox to reimburse all its users.