2 ms·
Emacs is overkill and has very poor default key bindings. Windows has notepad++, which is an excellent free editor. On the Mac I use Aquamacs Emacs, which is
by amichail 17y ago
Emacs is overkill and has very poor default key bindings.
Windows has notepad++, which is an excellent free editor.
On the Mac I use Aquamacs Emacs, which is ok, but I would still prefer something like notepad++. (For coding I use the xcode editor.)
- jrockway 17y agoHow does this relate to the article?
- amichail 17y agoIt's time for people to move on from Emacs. Development effort would be better spent on lightweight editors that complement modern IDE editors (e.g., the Java editor in Eclipse).
- GeneralMaximus 17y agoMost Emacs users love Emacs because of the amount of customization it offers, not because of the keybindings. In fact, I've never seen an Emacs user who hasn't customized his keybindings. I don't get what you mean by "moving on". Just because people started writing Emacs 30 years ago does not mean the code is crufty and old. Both Emacs and Vim work well with all modern desktop environments on all major operating systems. I don't see why anyone should be "moving on". You might love your IDE, but many people hate them. Some of us don't like bloated software with features we don't need or use. (I'm a Vim user, BTW :) )
- amichail 17y agoBut emacs is bloated software. Eclipse at least gives you amazing functionality. Have you actually tried the Java editor in Eclipse?
- adharmad 17y agoHow is emacs bloated? Size of emacs 22.1 (windows): 36MB Size of eclipse galileo (windows) 189MB
- gaius 17y agoEmacs runs in 4M resident on this box... Eclipse is closer to 500M. That is bloat.
- jrockway 17y agoDo you know anything about emacs? There is actually not that much bloat. There is code to support each platform and windowing system emacs runs on. There is support for managing buffers, and other very primitive editor functionality like that. Then there is the Lisp VM and associated data structures ("Lisp_Object") to glue everything together. On top of that are some primitive functions ("and", "cdr", etc.), along with some primitive editing functions ("next-line") implemented in C. That's about it; the rest is all Emacs Lisp code that you can simply choose not to run. (Yes, some gets compiled right into the Emacs binary to speed startup, but you can skip that.) Sure, you can argue that many emacs extensions (hello, Gnus) are bloat. But you can just pretend it doesn't exist; nobody is forcing you to use anything. Plain emacs is a very simple toolkit for building your own editor. Emacs with simple.el (and friends) is still a very simple, but rich, text editor. As you add packages, you add functionality and complexity... but you can choose what to add, Emacs is infinitely malleable and does not care what you do to it. I am not too familiar with Eclipse, but I doubt that it is simpler than Emacs.
- amichail 17y agoI'm interested in an editor that works the way I like with minimal customization required. Notepad++ is like that. Emacs isn't.
- yason 17y agoThere's a difference between editing text files and editing text. In the former, all you need is some mechanism to type, delete, and move text. In the latter, you want to work with the contents itself in a huge number of ways. There's no such things as an editor that works the way you like unless you only have very basic text editing needs. This is where people generally resort to Notepad or Word. In the other case you really want a good editor that fits both your fingers and thinking, and that's where you had better write the editor yourself. It is at this stage when many people have figured out that starting with Emacs is the easiest path.
- garnet7 17y ago> In fact, I've never seen an Emacs user who hasn't customized his keybindings. Here's one. I only make 2 minor additions (no customizations) to the default key bindings. By now, the defaults are pretty much hardwired into my hands.
- lacker 17y agoIt's a sign of how true the original statement is that you consider "only adding 2 extra keybindings" to be essentially the same as "haven't customized your keybindings."
- adharmad 17y agoAnd what about people who program in C, C++, perl, python, erlang? How is that useful to them?
- twopoint718 17y agoOr a new programming language that we haven't even heard of. Emacs (and Vi(m)) will typically have a programming editing mode long before v 1.0 of the lang comes out (c.f. clojure-mode)
- GeneralMaximus 17y agoThe Haskell folks actually recommend you use Emacs for all your editing needs. The Emacs Haskell mode is supposed to be awesome (I've never used it, since I use Vim). Extending Emacs or Vim to work seamlessly with your programming language is, IMO, a much smarter move than building an IDE from scratch.
- gaius 17y agoLeksah is the Haskell IDE http://leksah.org/ http://leksah.org/
- GeneralMaximus 17y ago> ... runs on any platform where GTK+, gtk2hs and GHC can be installed ... That's the problem. GTK doesn't work very well on the Mac, and (AFAIK) there's no GTK+ on Haiku. OTOH, Emacs works perfectly on both platforms :)
- lallysingh 17y agoIt doesn't -- it's someone forgetting the no flamebait rule. Notepad++, really? If that isn't bait I don't know what is.
- andreyf 17y agoTextMate on OSX is a lot like notepad++ (but better). Re: emacs, I think complaining about default key bindings is like complaining about the color of a tennis racket's handle - it's a sign of n00b :-P
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]