3 ms·
Natural monopolies do exist, it's just that not all businesses claimed to be natural monopolies actually are. If you can, imagine a watershed. The river, alon
by logfromblammo 13y ago
Natural monopolies do exist, it's just that not all businesses claimed to be natural monopolies actually are.
If you can, imagine a watershed. The river, along with its tributaries, covers the most efficient downhill route from every point in the watershed to sea level. The natural monopoly on precipitation drainage is everywhere you see flowing water. Installing a second river does not work. Wherever you try to put it, the natural tendency is for the second river to drop right down into the original watershed. You end up with just one river again.
If you turn that idea into a graph, replace the ocean with the Internet, the power plant, the potable water and sewage treatment facilities, the highway system, or some other common resource, and replace raindrop targets with homes and businesses. There is only one optimal routing for roads, pipes, wires, and fibers. The surface path following that route is the natural monopoly. You can cram an awful lot of stuff on top of it if you wanted.
Once poles are up and tunnels in place, the hard part is over. If a second cable company runs a second cable, that's not a waste. The customer can now buy either of two cable service packages, or both. If there's already a hamster tube up on the poles connecting the house to the municipal rat supply, and someone wants to run another for squirrels, that's not a waste. People might not want their rats and their squirrels from the same tube.
So when people say cable and phone service are natural monopolies, they are wrong. It's the space those wires run through.
- praxeologist 13y agoThe analogy with a river doesn't work at all. Rivers don't act or engage in exchange. I see what you are saying on the most optimal path for water to flow, but that is then equivocating on "monopoly".
- logfromblammo 13y agoMonopoly is a single seller of a good or service. There is an economic definition that must be met for a "natural monopoly" to exist, which depends on the marginal cost of producing additional units and the fixed cost of maintaining the capital. Basically, just as you don't typically see two different rivers draining the same watershed, you don't see multiple firms serving the same natural monopoly market. That doesn't mean that it never happens; it just means that any challenger to the incumbent either displaces them entirely, acquiring their capital in the process, or goes out of business and yields its capital to the incumbent. The lowest energy state of the natural monopoly is a single firm. Excited states can also exist, and are necessary for transitions to occur, but these states are less economically efficient. Customers see higher prices, and firms see lower profits. But given that a monopoly is in itself inefficient, it can still be worthwhile for a challenger to attempt to displace the incumbent, especially if they can operate at lower costs. In a truly free market, the switch could be accomplished by an initial investment of sufficient size. In the context of the analogy, huge machines dredge a new channel for the river. For a time, water flows in both channels, but in the end, one dries up and you are left with one river again.