2 ms·
"Why didn't they replace traditional classroom education using the same criteria you're applying to MOOCs?" For the same basic reason that the computers of the
by jerf 13y ago
"Why didn't they replace traditional classroom education using the same criteria you're applying to MOOCs?"
For the same basic reason that the computers of the 1980s didn't replace newspapers the way computers of the 2010s are; too hard to use, too expensive, not enough availability. The tech for editing a course may have existed but it wasn't wide-spread and easy, so there was not a feedback loop of improvement going on. Imagine being the teacher in 1980; you've recorded your lectures, you sent them away to be "edited", three months after your course was recorded they come back, you sample a couple of them just to see how they came out (you certainly aren't going to watch them all), and that's it. Even if you find an error, you're going to have to shrug your shoulders and at most issue a paper errata; you certainly aren't capable of going back and fixing it yourself, nor is anybody else going to pay for the skilled labor necessary to do so. For a feedback loop to occur there's a certain base level of ease that has to exist.
Only now do we have a world in which an instructor can give some bit of instruction, get a question from a student about something, and simply click "edit" to go back and fix whatever weakness in the original instruction the student's question reveals almost as quickly as they could answer the question in the first place. Run something like Physics 101 through that process over the course of 4 or 5 years and you'd quite likely end up with the best possible Physics 101-type course that could be developed. (The next step after that is fundamental rewrites of how we teach physics at all, but that will take longer.)
And indeed I'd suggest that we're still in the very early phases of that, too; it's going to get easier and more widespread. Once we start building educational resources over time instead of firing them like one-shot ammunition, the improvement feedback loop is all but inevitable.
- wbillingsley 13y agoCuriously, with MOOCs replacing OpenCourseware, we've shifted to an environment that's a little bit harder to iterate on. Editing text is easy. Editing something someone said in the middle of some video can be harder (continuity issues, availability of the original speaker, audio environment, etc). Quite a few MOOCs have shifted up a notch in their production values recently. When you've flown to another country to interview a famous scientist for your MOOC, it's probably a bit trickier to make a minor edit to what was said next year.
- jerf 13y ago"Editing something someone said in the middle of some video can be harder (continuity issues, availability of the original speaker, audio environment, etc)." That's part of what I was thinking when I said this was early days. While the problems can't be completely glossed over, there's some stuff we can do to mitigate those problems. An interview would be a primary source; of course you can't edit that, but good odds you've got some sort of summary that is part of the core course, where the interview is immediately available as a primary source. The summary would be as fungible as anything else, and the interview ought to be treated as a primary source and archived. (Possibly with one pass of audio cleanup, but not something to be modified wiki-style.) On the topic of Wiki, some sort of editor-driven Wiki could help too. Many Montessori schools already adapt the idea of having the older students teach the younger, I believe; as MOOCs evolve it's very easy to imagine harnessing the students themselves to start fixing the courses they've already taken. They'd move from an isolated course to an integrated part of the whole education. Again, like I said, I fully believe these are the early days of a revolution, and writing MOOCs (and more generally, online education in general) off now is like writing off the automobile because it's a great deal less convenient in every way than a horse, and smells worse and is more expensive to boot. Yes, that was true... at the beginning....
- ZeroGravitas 13y agoThat's because MOOCs (at least the new breed, not the original ones that had that name) are an attempt to fight back against open education by the establishment. It's like Britannica putting their encyclopedia online, mostly a distraction. Luckily neither Britannica nor the educational establishment actually have/had a coherent plan, but they can distract those who aren't paying attention.
- VLM 13y ago"Only now do we have a world in which an instructor can give some bit of instruction, get a question from a student about something, and simply click "edit" to go back and fix whatever weakness in the original instruction the student's question reveals almost as quickly as they could answer the question in the first place." To the best of my knowledge as a participant there are no MOOCs running internal processes anything like this. More likely in my experience is you get a wiki of errors for when its rerun again in a year with the same videos. Much like my film-strip example. "Advance to the next powerpoint slide at the beep" and then the record starts skipping.
- jerf 13y agoAs I think I said on my blog once, educators fancy themselves hip and cutting edge, but they are one of the stodgiest, resistant industries I know. They will get there. Silicon Valley will drag them, kicking and screaming, if necessary. And I'd bet money there will be a lot of kicking and screaming, but the economics are inevitable. They'd be a lot more evitable if education had not rested on its laurels for so long and simply spent, spent, spent its social capital to suck in ever-more money, but that is what they chose, and that is where we are now.