3 ms·
The point is, if you have some kind of human discussion, close examination of coursework, etc., it’s possible for a sensitive expert teacher to figure out what
by jacobolus 13y ago
The point is, if you have some kind of human discussion, close examination of coursework, etc., it’s possible for a sensitive expert teacher to figure out what kind of misconceptions and misunderstandings students have, and talk through them, making sure that students leave a course with a correct model in their heads. By contrast, this is very difficult to achieve via lecture alone, whether in person or online. [And certainly many traditional classes fail at this.]
In particular, all of the Khan Academy lectures I have seen (admittedly, this is only about a dozen random ones) do quite a poor job compared to the good teachers and professors I’ve had. They don’t seem to me to be grounded in much understanding or appreciation of how people learn.
(In theory, online courses should give people access to enough interactive tools and communication infrastructure to discuss and question and properly figure out the gaps in each student’s understanding. In practice, I haven’t seen any which do this at all well.)
- ZeroGravitas 13y agoAnd what about the people who will never have professors, and have never had sensitive expert teachers? Do we just explain that they can't afford a good education and that it sucks to be them as the people who could afford that education are now fighting tooth and nail against any move to democratize learning?
- VLM 13y agoTo some extent it just requires more sweat. That's how the elite who figured it out the first time originally learned. Very little of hard science is revealed knowledge like (most) religious ed. The problem with "gonna have to work harder" is a side marketing presentation of "it'll be faster and cheaper" in direct competition. I think most students don't learn from direct interaction with teachers, anyway. My first uni calc course had about one kilostudents in an auditorium. Most recently I got one of 1100 meaningless certificates from a comp sci MOOC where a busy post in the discussion forum had maybe 100 reads and 10 posts. The other 90%+ who got certs ignored the forums. Unsure how many signed up and participated to some level but didn't get a meaningless cert. I got nothing out of the forums and mostly hit wikipedia / mathworld / google in general with my questions. About 90% of my questions were quickly answered by the textbook before I tried slower online research. Slower because the text was written much better than the average blog post on the topic, lots of slogging thru junk on line.