12 ms·
Not a great day to be a Libertarian. When their domain goes up for sale, I'm going to buy it and start an online exchange for Magic cards.
by jrockway 13y ago
Not a great day to be a Libertarian.
When their domain goes up for sale, I'm going to buy it and start an online exchange for Magic cards.
- cheez 13y agoSo in the current EU/US political climate, MtGox would be bailed out, meaning people who didn't invest their money with MtGox would be forced to make the people who did whole. Whereas in the current BitCoin climate, the investors suffer and will be forced to sue MtGox to reclaim their money. Which is morally better? No libertarian will tell you that either of these is a preferred outcome, but out of the two, the morally superior one should be relatively obvious. Edit: The reason I say it would be bailed out is not because they are investment accounts but precisely because it was so huge in the BitCoin economy.
- stevewilhelm 13y agoChecking accounts, savings accounts, and CD are protected by FDIC. Brokerage accounts for doing FX speculation are not insured. [1] http://www.fdic.gov/consumers/consumer/information/fdiciorn.html http://www.fdic.gov/consumers/consumer/information/fdiciorn....
- stingraycharles 13y agoMtGox is an exchange, not a bank. I'm mentioning this because there is an important third person with a bank: the customer, not the investor. With mtgox, every customer is an investor. When bailing out a bank, however, the rationale is often to help out the people who cannot be blamed: the customers. I'm still not claiming that bailing out I banks is a good thing, but the comparison you make is a small apples/oranges thing.
- cheez 13y agoThis sounds a lot like the too big to fail argument and so it is not an apples/oranges thing. It's a sliding scale and the only reason it seems like it is apples and oranges to you is precisely because MtGox isn't big enough. I'm not saying that customers of a bank should suffer for the investment side but let the investors suffer for their bad investments, if the political will is there.
- bunderbunder 13y ago> the morally superior one should be relatively obvious. Except that it isn't. Hence why many smart people disagree on the issue. The difference is meta-ethical. The TBTF argument is fundamentally a utilitarian one - it's saying, "This is distasteful, but we're going to do it anyway because we believe it will result in a better final outcome." The Libertarian take on the issue frames it in a fundamentally deontological light, as you have. It's concerned with the actions themselves, and doesn't even attempt to speculate on long-term practical consequences of any particular choice of action because they aren't relevant to the argument under that particular framing. Which is fine, both are legitimate approaches to ethics. What bothers me is when the two camps start just talking past each other. Which is what seems to be happening when one makes a statement such as "the morally superior one should be relatively obvious" in this context. In terms of persuasiveness, it's reminiscent of the Verizon "Which one is bigger?" ad campaign - there's an attempt to get at something legitimate there, but it's overshadowed by a rhetorical approach that could make even the best argument in the world feel unpersuasive.
- adrianwaj 13y agoI suspect a high capacity USD/doge exchange with a Gox compliant API would be the most lucrative opportunity out there right now. But I'd need to recheck the viewpoint before acting on it.
- MartinCron 13y agoNot a great day to be a Libertarian Cherry-picking one high-profile catastrophic failure isn't exactly an intellectually honest indictment of Libertarianism. It's not like there's a shortage of better indictments to use. It is a good day for schadenfreude, though.
- bunderbunder 13y agoAgreed. That said, this whole episode might serve as an interesting case in relation to many Libertarian talking points, such as the relative merits of many regulations covering savings & loan organizations in most countries.
- hnisnotreddit 13y agoEpicaricacy. because you speak english.
- jgeorge 13y agoBut how will you address transaction malleability in Magic cards?