4 ms·
Luckily not a single student ever left traditional education with a single misconception about anything, or else this would seem like a ridiculously slanted art
by ZeroGravitas 13y ago
Luckily not a single student ever left traditional education with a single misconception about anything, or else this would seem like a ridiculously slanted article.
edit: on re-reading, he's still clearly using Khan and MOOCs as eye-catching buzzwords, symbolic of "bad education", but a) he mention (in passing) offline education having similar issues, and b) he intends to talk about how online education could fulfil his pet theory of learning in another article, so it's not quite the usual reactionary post, although it does lean that way.
- jacobolus 13y agoThe point is, if you have some kind of human discussion, close examination of coursework, etc., it’s possible for a sensitive expert teacher to figure out what kind of misconceptions and misunderstandings students have, and talk through them, making sure that students leave a course with a correct model in their heads. By contrast, this is very difficult to achieve via lecture alone, whether in person or online. [And certainly many traditional classes fail at this.] In particular, all of the Khan Academy lectures I have seen (admittedly, this is only about a dozen random ones) do quite a poor job compared to the good teachers and professors I’ve had. They don’t seem to me to be grounded in much understanding or appreciation of how people learn. (In theory, online courses should give people access to enough interactive tools and communication infrastructure to discuss and question and properly figure out the gaps in each student’s understanding. In practice, I haven’t seen any which do this at all well.)
- ZeroGravitas 13y agoAnd what about the people who will never have professors, and have never had sensitive expert teachers? Do we just explain that they can't afford a good education and that it sucks to be them as the people who could afford that education are now fighting tooth and nail against any move to democratize learning?
- VLM 13y agoTo some extent it just requires more sweat. That's how the elite who figured it out the first time originally learned. Very little of hard science is revealed knowledge like (most) religious ed. The problem with "gonna have to work harder" is a side marketing presentation of "it'll be faster and cheaper" in direct competition. I think most students don't learn from direct interaction with teachers, anyway. My first uni calc course had about one kilostudents in an auditorium. Most recently I got one of 1100 meaningless certificates from a comp sci MOOC where a busy post in the discussion forum had maybe 100 reads and 10 posts. The other 90%+ who got certs ignored the forums. Unsure how many signed up and participated to some level but didn't get a meaningless cert. I got nothing out of the forums and mostly hit wikipedia / mathworld / google in general with my questions. About 90% of my questions were quickly answered by the textbook before I tried slower online research. Slower because the text was written much better than the average blog post on the topic, lots of slogging thru junk on line.
- mathattack 13y agoIt does use Khan Academy as a strawman though. "Let's say that Khan Academy is the be-all end-all of education, then prove that it's not." In reality, sites like the Khan Academy aren't intended to replace classroom education. They're meant to reinforce it. Get the lectures on your own time, so that you can get to the deep learning with teachers in the classroom. Spend classroom time on the socratic method, rather than lectures. He beats up the tool that he should be using to improve the classroom experience.
- msandford 13y agoRight? It seems like he's railing against the Kahn Academy but it's not as though a public school (or most private school) educations are much better. With a student/teacher ratio of 30:1 (or worse) and absolutely no tailoring of teaching method to student's optimal learning methods (verbal, visual, writing, etc) it's not as though traditional schooling is a paragon of getting everything 100% right and MOOCs are terrible by comparison. Kahn should get a lot of credit for giving students the option to go back and re-watch things they didn't get the first time. If they learn by hearing or seeing (instead of reading) then that's an incredibly valuable tool. If we want to complain about anything I think we should be complaining that there's no standardized testing of learning methods and then informing the students of their results (and what those results mean) so that they have the opportunity to try and optimize their learning and thus hopefully get a damn diploma. Why isn't that a national goal? Seems like it would be a small incremental change that would make a huge difference in terms of raising education levels across the board. It helps smart people and dumb people and everyone in between.
- jerf 13y agoThe reason I'm confident that in the long term MOOCs will succeed where traditional education fails is not that MOOCs will come out of the gate a superior product. The reason is that MOOCs can be tuned and developed over time in a way that a classroom experience can not, because every class room experience is too unique, delivered live, unrecorded, etc. It will take time for this to happen, but it is likely inevitable, and eventually the idea of flinging out an "education" into a room, where it shall disappear forever with no feedback or development, will be considered as archaic as the horse buggy. (And also people can't seem to help comparing the perfect conventional education that does not exist to the worst of MOOCs, which may feel good, but is not relevant.)
- VLM 13y agoI watched video tapes in the early 80s and before that, professionally produced film strips. Even film strips with 33RPM vinyl records, before tape. Also I saw a couple really old analog film movies in my youth. Currently, youtube videos and DVDs are supposedly popular. Why didn't they replace traditional classroom education using the same criteria you're applying to MOOCs? You may be correct about outcome, but the reaction mechanism is lacking. I'm a classically self educated well rounded kind of guy, so I feel education is developed from within not a mechanical external process much like weightlifting. The idea it merely requires butts in seats, and the result depends on what technique someone else applies to those seated butts, is more likely to disappear. Or at absolute most, perhaps "necessary but not sufficient".
- jerf 13y ago"Why didn't they replace traditional classroom education using the same criteria you're applying to MOOCs?" For the same basic reason that the computers of the 1980s didn't replace newspapers the way computers of the 2010s are; too hard to use, too expensive, not enough availability. The tech for editing a course may have existed but it wasn't wide-spread and easy, so there was not a feedback loop of improvement going on. Imagine being the teacher in 1980; you've recorded your lectures, you sent them away to be "edited", three months after your course was recorded they come back, you sample a couple of them just to see how they came out (you certainly aren't going to watch them all), and that's it. Even if you find an error, you're going to have to shrug your shoulders and at most issue a paper errata; you certainly aren't capable of going back and fixing it yourself, nor is anybody else going to pay for the skilled labor necessary to do so. For a feedback loop to occur there's a certain base level of ease that has to exist. Only now do we have a world in which an instructor can give some bit of instruction, get a question from a student about something, and simply click "edit" to go back and fix whatever weakness in the original instruction the student's question reveals almost as quickly as they could answer the question in the first place. Run something like Physics 101 through that process over the course of 4 or 5 years and you'd quite likely end up with the best possible Physics 101-type course that could be developed. (The next step after that is fundamental rewrites of how we teach physics at all, but that will take longer.) And indeed I'd suggest that we're still in the very early phases of that, too; it's going to get easier and more widespread. Once we start building educational resources over time instead of firing them like one-shot ammunition, the improvement feedback loop is all but inevitable.