3 ms·
It's a testament to how much more software we could stand to develop, software that probably hasn't even been touched, yet. For a newspaper, obviously they nee
by moron4hire 13y ago
It's a testament to how much more software we could stand to develop, software that probably hasn't even been touched, yet.
For a newspaper, obviously they need to have a parallel process to layout the paper and develop the content. Why don't they have software now that "compiles" the paper from design files and content files and won't release the copy until all of the content is marked as reviewed?
Or essentially, as the person is performing the layout for stuff like callouts, instead of generating their own placeholder content, they generate rules for the place holder content (just as they seem to be typing rules into the callout as the placeholder itself), and the system would both generate the placeholder for the designer, while also queuing the snippet of content for the writer.
Then, you just have to train your users "never type in your own placeholder text." Use the queue as a project management tool. Editors could then review the text, mark it as reviewed, or re-enqueue it for rewriting. The article is done when the queue is done.
I mean, really, I'm not even describing anything revolutionary here. It's BugZilla, Redmine, etc., just with a layout program tied to the fields in the database.
Would newspapers and magazines actually use something like that? Or is pigheaded entrenchment into old ways the disease of their industry that is leading them to die out?
- goblin89 13y agoSounds like something along the lines of http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Adobe_InCopy http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Adobe_InCopy: > Once integrated, writers, editors and designers can simultaneously work on the same page; the designer creates the page layout with InDesign, while editors simultaneously edit different stories with InCopy, via the Adobe LiveEdit rights management system. I recall there's at least one other product for similar kind of workflow (not tied to Adobe ecosystem), but being no longer in the industry I forgot the name.
- moron4hire 13y agoSo is the software any good? Why wouldn't something of such obvious utility take over? I have seen plenty of cases where users will circumvent a system they are given if it is difficult to use or they don't understand it.
- goblin89 13y agoI know of one example where this kind of integration is actually in place and properly utilized. It's a pretty big newspaper. The integration is provided by a publishing system called K4. Admittedly, very few publications would employ similar systems here. Because they're complex to set up, expensive, and not easy to pirate (I don't think many small publications paid for their copies of InDesign/PageMaker), because there's inertia and fear of losing their jobs among the staff (not many young forward-thinking professionals in print nowadays), etc. Not sure how things are US, though.
- moron4hire 13y agoOkay, not surprising.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- chris_wot 13y agoIt would have helped stop the headline "Can Dec anally match Ant?" in the Daily Express. This was credited as "Accidental headline of the year" by the Guardian. http://www.theguardian.com/media/mediamonkeyblog/2009/sep/01/express-ant-dec-headline-error http://www.theguardian.com/media/mediamonkeyblog/2009/sep/01...
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]