4 ms·
I don't know if WhatsApp is a good buy for Facebook or not. But I do remember when people cried "bubble" at Google for purchasing YouTube (after all: it was too
by nl 13y ago
I don't know if WhatsApp is a good buy for Facebook or not. But I do remember when people cried "bubble" at Google for purchasing YouTube (after all: it was too much, it was only valuable because of illegally copied content, there are hundreds of video sites, TV companies can do the same thing), and now they look pretty silly.
$16B ($1B) for a hardly profitable mobile app (video sharing site) seems stupid. $16B ($1B) for the future of telecoms (TV) world wide seems a bargain.
- diminoten 13y agoI can't remember where I read this, but as far as I understand, Google is still losing money on YouTube.
- fragmede 13y ago"The video site should generate more than $3.6 billion in gross revenue" [in 2012] http://allthingsd.com/20120621/youtubes-gigantic-year-is-already-here-citi-says/ http://allthingsd.com/20120621/youtubes-gigantic-year-is-alr... They might still be 'losing money', but 3.6 billion/yr is plenty of money coming in.
- username223 13y agoI'm not sure how this matters. I could make infinite gross revenue handing out money to people who agreed to give me half of it back right away. Call it "Bitcoin", and I could even manufacture it myself, turning the gross into net!
- nl 13y agoIt matters because there is a clear path to profit (unlike the "give away money" model). The market sees it like this: Their costs are high because they (Google/Youtube) are investing to support high growth. At some point the growth will taper off, and so will the investment (because you invest to support larger numbers in the future), but the money keeps rolling in. Google has deep enough pockets to invest in that for a long, long time.
- danmatan 13y agoI'll bet they'll never attribute the value to Youtube that comes from being able to better target ads off-Youtube based on your Youtube views. Youtube might lose on paper, but generate more value in total for Google than direct costs. Google also gets a whole pile of AV to do speech-to-text and other analysis on (before any additional compression) that no other firm gets a chance to do.
- rmason 13y agoFacebook paid roughly $42 a user for WhatsApp. Which is about what Microsoft paid for HotMail. Yahoo paid Mark Cuban and his partner $11,000 a user for broadcast.com - that is a bubble price.
- hapless 13y agoWhatsapp's ARPU is a little under $1. By your numbers, they have 42 years of revenue in that figure.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- girvo 13y agoPeople will cry bubble when any software company is purchased by another for large sums of money. It seems to just be a reaction to the "But, they don't make anything real," I mean heck, other large companies with far fewer users get purchased for far more and people don't bat an eyelid... /shrugs Who knows. Continually predict a bubble, and everyone forgets that you were wrong for over a decade when it finally happens...
- username223 13y agoSomeone reporting on this noted that Zuckerberg could have purchase the entire NBA. I'm not playing in this casino, but I do wonder who will end up with the tab. I suspect we'll find out soon.
- batiudrami 13y agoYoutube at the time had a massive marketshare in terms of video hosting and sharing (mostly because it was one of only a few which actually worked properly). Whatsapp is popular, definitely. But it's one of hundreds of messaging platforms, and I suspect it doesn't have anything like a majority share in the worldwide messaging space. The similarities are of course that they're both defensive aquisitions - the money is justified not on its earnings potential but that it could be the start of a new social network that ousts Facebook. If that really is the case, $16B is well worth it. Facebook's aquisition strategy at the moment appears to be 'overpay for anything that could be the next Facebook to their MySpace'. It'll probably work, too - at least for the near future. But that said Whatsapp is not very popular in Australia so I have a skewed perspective (current marketshare here seems to be roughly a 50/50 split between legacy SMS and Facebook mesenger).
- w1ntermute 13y ago> I suspect it doesn't have anything like a majority share in the worldwide messaging space. Whatsapp has 450 million users. The issue is that most Americans (and Australians, in your case) have never heard of it, so they assume that it's not very popular. http://www.wired.com/wiredenterprise/2014/02/whatsapp-rules-rest-world/ http://www.wired.com/wiredenterprise/2014/02/whatsapp-rules-...
- batiudrami 13y agoI have heard of it and have used it - I'm not surprised at the 450 million users figure, but the global messaging market is measured in in billions. Even people in third world countries use SMS - they do not have the ~90% marketshare which YouTube had when it was purchased. In Australia it just, for some reason, never caught on - many people I know have accounts (as many as say, Instagram, for comparison) - it just seems to be something people try but don't stick with. Which in a sense, is a pity, as it's demonstrably better than SMS. But in Australia Facebook Messenger already has the equivalent marketshare. Perhaps between Facebook Messenger and WhatsApp, Facebook would end with a majority marketshare [of IP-based messaging] as one app is popular where the other isn't. I honestly wouldn't know.
- 13y ago
- mempko 13y agoAnd then a year later the recession started and the crash a year after that......
- joegaudet 13y agoPeople have been crying bubble for the past n years... Seems pretty pointless by and large.