3 ms·
As somebody who's in his 15th year in San Francisco, I think it's a reasonable concern. For me, it's not about change as such. One of the things that defines S
by wpietri 13y ago
As somebody who's in his 15th year in San Francisco, I think it's a reasonable concern.
For me, it's not about change as such. One of the things that defines San Francisco for me is its openness to change, its endless mutability. Change is great. It's about a specific sort of change that is destroying potential for future interesting change.
For me it goes back to why San Francisco is an important center of Internet innovation in the first place. It's a cultural center that is close to major universities and a major technology center. When a technological innovation (the Internet) became a cultural medium (the web), San Francisco had the right ingredients for incredible innovation.
Why was it well placed for that? I think it was San Francisco's 150 years of acceptance of seekers, immigrants, artists, bohemians, and freaks. Not just a cultural acceptance, but an economic one. You didn't need to be rich to move here. You could find a workaday job and an adequate place to live while having time for your writing, your art, your tinkering, your cultural experimentation. That's important: pioneers rarely fit in well to contemporary society; in a sense, they're already living in a possible future.
But the incredible shift in rents and the Gini coefficient here is wiping that out. To me the problem isn't change. It's the destruction of an incubator for new ideas, new ways of thinking.
- raldi 13y ago> One of the things that defines San Francisco for me is its openness to change I'm shocked that you say that. My impression of SF today is almost the exact opposite: that one of the most defining characteristics of the city's current population is its extraordinary resistance to change.
- wpietri 13y agoCould you say more about what you mean? And how you're getting that impression? I'm not following.
- raldi 13y agoProps B and C Discretionary Review CEQA abuse Nativism Height restrictions Bus protests U-Verse protests Articles about how the Mission is changing, and how that's a bad thing
- wpietri 13y agoSo your entire impression of San Francisco's history comes down to a few years of stuff related to the recent economic situation? You might want to expand your horizons a bit. Consider the beats, the hippies, the summer of love, the gay and lesbian rise, Burning Man, and the rise of cycling. And hey, the web. Having lunch in South Park with the Wired folks in 1997, I sure didn't notice any hostility from the neighbors. The obvious difference to me in these lists, beyond the time scale, is the use of power. That a ~$200 billion communications oligopoly gets a little pushback while trying to increase their market dominance is not something I'm going to shed a lot of tears over, and I don't think you can reasonably call it a smoking gun for generalized resistance to change.
- raldi 13y ago> So your entire impression of San Francisco's history... My comment was quite clearly addressed at SF's current population, not previous ones. In fact, that's one of my major gripes with them: they benefited by riding a previous wave of change, but now that they're the status quo, they want to stop the next one. It's the classic, "I got mine, now slam the door" mentality.
- wpietri 13y agoThe current population is by and large the one that has been quite welcoming to the tech industry -- when we aren't totally jacking the rents up, flooding neighborhoods, and paying for the eviction of long-term residents. So again, I think you're overgeneralizing.