5 ms·
Is San Francisco losing its soul?
- me2i81 13y agoThe idea of San Francisco losing its soul was much of the content of Herb Caen's columns in the San Francisco Chronicle for decades.
- gaius 13y agoLet's not forget SF was founded for one purpose: the Gold Rush. So in reality, it's getting its original soul back.
- __pThrow 13y agoAs an interesting data point, watch the settings and backgrounds crowds in Dirty Harry movies to see what San Francisco looked like in the 70s.
- stefan_kendall 13y agoDon't you just wish every city and place could just stay the same forever? No. "Losing its soul" = Changing in a way I don't agree with, and maybe I'll try and use government to stop the change. I'm more important than the people causing the change.
- dllthomas 13y ago'"Losing its soul" = Changing in a way I don't agree with, and maybe I'll try and use government to stop the change. I'm more important than the people causing the change.' Or equally important, if the attempt at change is democratic.
- raldi 13y agoSF lost its soul when the Native Americans settled the land. Then it lost its soul when the missionaries arrived and stamped out all the Native American culture. Then it happened again when the ranchers showed up. Then another time when the US won the Mexician-American war and got rid of the old "Yerba Buena" name. Then it really lost its soul in 1849. Then it happened again when the US Army and Navy made the bay into a military town. Then those hippies and gays showed up and ruined SF's tough "Iron in War" reputation. Then the Mexicans caused the Mission to lose its traditional German-Irish-Italian soul. Oh, and those groups killed its soul earlier when they moved in, too. And then they opened the ballpark and suddenly SOMA was no longer a charming cluster of warehouses anymore. Also when Noe Valley lost its working-class roots. Did I miss any other times the city lost its soul?
- wpietri 13y agoAs somebody who's in his 15th year in San Francisco, I think it's a reasonable concern. For me, it's not about change as such. One of the things that defines San Francisco for me is its openness to change, its endless mutability. Change is great. It's about a specific sort of change that is destroying potential for future interesting change. For me it goes back to why San Francisco is an important center of Internet innovation in the first place. It's a cultural center that is close to major universities and a major technology center. When a technological innovation (the Internet) became a cultural medium (the web), San Francisco had the right ingredients for incredible innovation. Why was it well placed for that? I think it was San Francisco's 150 years of acceptance of seekers, immigrants, artists, bohemians, and freaks. Not just a cultural acceptance, but an economic one. You didn't need to be rich to move here. You could find a workaday job and an adequate place to live while having time for your writing, your art, your tinkering, your cultural experimentation. That's important: pioneers rarely fit in well to contemporary society; in a sense, they're already living in a possible future. But the incredible shift in rents and the Gini coefficient here is wiping that out. To me the problem isn't change. It's the destruction of an incubator for new ideas, new ways of thinking.
- raldi 13y ago> One of the things that defines San Francisco for me is its openness to change I'm shocked that you say that. My impression of SF today is almost the exact opposite: that one of the most defining characteristics of the city's current population is its extraordinary resistance to change.
- wpietri 13y agoCould you say more about what you mean? And how you're getting that impression? I'm not following.
- raldi 13y agoProps B and C Discretionary Review CEQA abuse Nativism Height restrictions Bus protests U-Verse protests Articles about how the Mission is changing, and how that's a bad thing
- nugget 13y agoI wish this article had mentioned restrictions on development as the major cause of insane rental prices. Just build more high rises. It's not that hard. There is room for a dozen more Rincon and Infinity like towers around downtown.
- raldi 13y agoLet's keep an eye on the huge new proposal at 16th and Mission. If it gets to be a ten-story residential tower, as its developers propose, I think that's a very good sign. If it gets chopped down to 6 or 8, then it's a sign we're in for six more weeks of winter. (By winter I mean skyrocketing rents, and by weeks I mean years.)
- gamblor956 13y agoOnly in San Francisco would a 10 story residential building be considered huge...and that's part of the problem. Even when SF does try to add new residential units, it adds the bare minimum. (From a social POW, at least. The developers do this deliberately to maintain scarcity so they can derive greater profits.)
- Muzza 13y agoIt is with great schadenfreude I read articles like these. For 40+ years SF bohemians have been preaching diversity. Anyone who saw his own community ravaged was denounced as a racist, a bitter clinger, etc. And now the SF bohemians want to whine about people moving there? To all the "evil white men" who want to go to SF: give the bloody hypocrites a taste of their own medicine.