8 ms·
Here is a thing that happened
- tptacek 13y agoIn case you're wondering: "Blue Sky" appears to be an alias used by LIMMT, a Chinese company that did business in the US while supplying the Iranian military with weapons material. OFAC publishes the contents of the SDN and updates to it. (This comment is descriptive, not normative).
- pizza 13y ago> The defendants, LI FANG WEI (a/k/a KARL LEE, a/k/a PATRIC, a/k/a SUNNY BAI, a/k/a K. LEE a/k/a KL, a/k/a DAVID LI, a/k/a F.W. LI) and LIMMT ECONOMIC AND TRADE COMPANY, LTD., (a/k/a LIMMT (DALIAN FTZ) METALLURGY AND MINERALS CO., LTD., a/k/a LIMMT (DALIAN FTZ) MINMETALS AND METALLURGY CO., LTD., a/k/a LIMMT (DALIAN FTZ) METALLURGY AND MINERALS CO., LTD., a/k/a ANSI METALLURGY INDUSTRY CO. LTD., a/k/a BLUE SKY INDUSTRY CORPORATION, a/k/a SC (DALIAN) INDUSTRY & TRADE CO., LTD., a/k/a SINO METALLURGY AND MINMETALS INDUSTRY CO., LTD., a/k/a SUMMIT INDUSTRY CORPORATION, a/k/a LIAONING INDUSTRY & TRADE CO., LTD., a/k/a WEALTHY OCEAN ENTERPRISES LTD.) (LIMMT) were indicted on charges of falsifying business records and conspiracy. [0] [0]: http://www.iranwatch.org/library/government/united-states/state-government/new-york-county-district-attorneys-office/indictment-chinese-citizen-and-his-company-violation http://www.iranwatch.org/library/government/united-states/st...
- brianbreslin 13y agothat is a crazy amount of aliases!
- PeterisP 13y agoCan we be sure that all the other evil, evil aliases - namely 'patric' and 'k. lee' - get the same treatement if mentioned in payments, since it's obviously neccessary for national security?
- gpvos 13y agoSDN = Specially Designated Nationals, OFAC = Office of Foreign Assets Control
- srl 13y ago"In conclusion, I love my country and like our lawyers and hate our bank, like all good Americans." Oh my sides. I get the dim sense, knowing nothing about this stuff, that the job of that office is one of the more headache-inducing ones in administrative government. Preventing people to sending money to (or receiving money from) a list of bad actors is a horridly difficult thing to begin with, but then when they screw up (either like this or in the more common case of money getting through), placing the blame is easy. On another note, I haven't the faintest idea what the meaning of "blue sky" is, and I can't find anything by searching. Anybody know?
- diziet 13y agoApparently it's a form of methamphetamine
- baking 13y agoMore like a fictional form from "Breaking Bad."
- gcb0 13y agoapparently not that difficult of a job, since i could literarily replace them with as shell script, as the joke goes.
- oakwhiz 13y ago"Blue sky" is a weather condition in which there are no clouds in the sky. /sarcasm
- anildash 13y agoYeah, to be clear, I wrote this up because it's unfortunate and weird, not to vilify folks at the Treasury Department who have an unenviably difficult job. I don't think this one false positive for me is a huge burden (and most of the inconvenience is due to my bank, not the Treasury Dept). On the other hand, I know that the next time I'm coming back gone to the U.S. from abroad, especially being a brown dude with a beard who has family in Sourh Asia, I'm gonna have to deal with this. That was part of my reason for publishing it now.
- gambiting 13y agoI believe that right now every American citizen should write "Blue Sky" in every possible field on their bank forms when setting a transfer. This is lunacy and incompetence at the highest level.
- alexeisadeski3 13y agoI'm not trying to be inflammatory: Would you expect anything else from the US gov't?
- jessedhillon 13y agoAre you trying to be hyperbolic to the point of obliterating all nuance then?
- alexeisadeski3 13y agoIf you accept the article as accurate, then it seems odd to consider my statement hyperbole.
- jessedhillon 13y agoGiven the text of the article, which entails only a single incident of a legitimate transaction being stopped based on automatic keyword filtering, we should conclude that it is entirely reasonable to state that the whole US government -- every single branch and agency -- is incapable of carrying out any action competently, at every level all the way to the very top? Yes, that's a hyperbolic statement.
- jasonlingx 13y agoAh, so this is the first time you've read about something like this...
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- callmeed 13y ago> In conclusion, I love my country and like our lawyers and hate our bank Why do you hate your bank? Chase is probably the best large bank I've ever dealt with and their online/mobile tools are excellent. It's very likely they're just complying with their legal obligations. If you're just using their standard online bill pay, I'd be curious to see what would happen if you simply added a new payee and slightly changed their name and attempted to pay them.
- anildash 13y agoIt blocked several simple variations as being duplicates, likely because the address is necessarily the same.
- zdw 13y ago> It's very likely they're just complying with their legal obligations. Legal != !stupid
- throwaway092834 13y agoThe bank didn't make the laws and doesn't run OFAC. The government does.
- terranstyler 13y agoDoesn't that imply a certain equivalence between the two terms or is this a notation I am not aware of? And if it is the former, am I contributing to your security for not posting the simplified version? :)
- 13y ago
- joedevon 13y agoThe comment about Time Warner Cable was the best part of this article: "I'm going to write "Blue Sky" on checks sent to Time Warner Cable so they can never take online payments from anybody."
- elwell 13y agoYou mean to Comcast?
- awakeasleep 13y agoDo you mean AmeriCommunicationsMonoploy Co?
- DanielBMarkham 13y ago"Hey, let's give wide, blunt political power to a bunch of un-elected functionaries, then we can start automating whatever their desires are! What could go wrong?" And so we're going to end up with a government like Google, where people come to HN to beg for attention just so they can be treated like a human being. I think it's time we just all acknowledge that the U.S. has the most onerous and insane financial laws in the world. The only reason other countries put up with them is because the U.S. is the sole remaining superpower. There really needs to be some kind of correction here, but I don't see it happening anytime soon. EDIT: Just to be clear, I am specifically referring to the Treasury Department handling of overseas payments and expats living abroad, not internal tax or financial regulations. There's a lot out there Google if you want to go look for it, including how various countries have protested being forced to comply with U.S. law, expats giving up citizenship at record rates (though still small in the grand scheme of things), and so on.
- anildash 13y ago"I think it's time we just all acknowledge that the U.S. has the most onerous and insane financial laws in the world. The only reason other countries put up with them is because the U.S. is the sole remaining superpower." I'm gonna guess you don't have a whole lot of stamps on your passport.
- alexeisadeski3 13y agoIt's almost certainly true. Examples: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Foreign_Account_Tax_Compliance_Act http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Foreign_Account_Tax_Compliance_... http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sarbanes%E2%80%93Oxley_Act http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sarbanes%E2%80%93Oxley_Act http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/International_taxation#Taxation_systems http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/International_taxation#Taxation...
- Sambdala 13y agoI'm an expat with a relatively large number of stamps on my passport, and I have loads of trouble anytime I try to open a new bank account or do anything remotely 'weird' with international banking.
- JoshTriplett 13y agoOn the bright side, it's hard to think of a faster way to get an insane law fixed than to have it prevent a law firm from getting paid (except perhaps to have it prevent Congress from getting paid). Perhaps they might want to take this one pro bono?
- maxerickson 13y agoA bunch of small blue sky political donations.
- yeukhon 13y agoIs it just me or does everyone has to do this: when you need to file more taxes (you need to pay more to the treasury), do you have to put your SSN in the memo field? My accountant said I have to which I dont't feel happy about it...
- maxerickson 13y agoIRS asks for it: http://www.irs.gov/Individuals/Pay-by-Check-or-Money-Order http://www.irs.gov/Individuals/Pay-by-Check-or-Money-Order You can probably arrange to make the payment electronically.
- tkrajcar 13y agoYep. The enrollment process is laborious, but it's worthwhile for those of us that deal with quarterly estimated tax payments. https://www.eftps.gov/ https://www.eftps.gov/
- pmorici 13y agoSo if this payment needed to be stopped in the eyes of the bank then why did they suggest a measure for circumventing their own rules by sending a paper check. This is kind of funny I recently purchased a bunch of second hard server parts from the excess department of a mid-sized bank and they insisted on checking my name against the OFAC list before completing the transaction. Insane.
- swombat 13y ago> So if this payment needed to be stopped in the eyes of the bank then why did they suggest a measure for circumventing their own rules by sending a paper check. Making everyone accept a system which doesn't make sense is just another step on the path to a dystopia. You'd be surprised at the number of such rules that existed in communist dictatorships.
- mcherm 13y agoWhat you're missing is that different players in this particular mess have different motivations. The goal of the OFAC regulators is to stop money from going to terrorists and other bad people. So they prohibit the banks from transferring money to "blue sky" and anyone else on the list. There is no leeway here -- if a bank does not comply the banking regulators have the authority to immediately close the bank an seize its assets and give them to a different bank. The goal of the IT and operations departments in the bank are to implement the requirements. The IT guys put a simple string match against the text of the online payments. There is no way to add a clause that checks whether it's "really" a payment to the prohibited individual or just someone who stuck a note in the memo field, because computers can't go out and interview the recipient to find out who they are. They also stuck in code to block that recipient from receiving payments in the future because otherwise anyone could circumvent the block completely by simply changing the name on the payment. The goal of the bank representative that Mr. Dash spoke with was to help her customer. So she suggested sending the paper check. For what it's worth, the OFAC office isn't too worried about the person collecting payment on the check because banks are also prohibited from giving bank accounts to people (or organizations) on the OFAC list.
- dinkumthinkum 13y agoAs a side note, I find the hyperbole of "killing trees" as a description for "writing checks" a little annoying and uneducated. Does one believe that the energy that makes the Internet possible is free?
- pangram 13y agoNot free, but I would suspect that paying electronically is at least a magnitude less impactful on the environment. That checkbook had to be produced, shipped to the bank, mailed to you, and then the individual check has to get moved around as well.
- dinkumthinkum 13y agoThat wasn't my claim but I don't think the online payments are as low energy as you may believe. In order to allow the Internet to exist such that online payments are so efficient, we must necessarily have all the servers, cables, routers, all the infrastructure, on all the time or otherwise not even a single online payment would go through. That's a lot of air conditioning, alone. So, fine but let's not think online payments use magnitudes less energy by using simplistic calculations.
- anildash 13y agoIt was supposed to be silly, not a literal consideration of the ecological impact.
- PeterisP 13y agoThe energy spent by the humans who have to touch/move/look/process this obsolete, unneeded artifact is more than the energy needed to process a thousand normal deals on the Internet.
- altero 13y ago... and thats why americans have troubles to open bank account abroad.
- sneak 13y agoBitcoin suffers from no such idiotic and arbitrary denial-of-service attacks by intermediaries.
- sergiotapia 13y agoThere's really no need to shoe-horn bitcoin into _every_ hackernews thread.
- PeterisP 13y agoOn the contrary, it's simply a property of being a consumer financial service provider in USA - if a company would offer the exact same bill settlement in bitcoins instead of dollars, all the same restrictions would apply.
- tsukikage 13y agoNo, it just suffers from having all your cash, hard-mined by skimming off the drug economy, regularly stolen by people breaking into poorly secured exchanges ;)
- raymondduke 13y agoHow do headlines like this get noticed? It boggles the mind.
- cromulent 13y agoIt's not the headline but the blogger. Anil Dash was in Six Apart back when the only real blogging platform around was their Movable Type, about 2001.
- bobwise 13y agoMan what a great title
- psychometry 13y agoWhy even title a post on a blog if it conveys zero information?
- renownedmedia 13y agoTitles are required for nearly all blogging software.
- alanh 13y agohttp://lmgtfy.com/?q=rhetorical+question http://lmgtfy.com/?q=rhetorical+question
- anildash 13y agoI had just wanted to document the moment and thought it was kind of funny to do sort of the anti-Upworthy headline.
- Houshalter 13y agoIt seems like HN has a ton of uselessly vague titles. I don't know if I should ignore them or click on all of them to find out what they are.
- beedogs 13y agoIt's because the powers-that-be decided, in their infinite wisdom, that any modification of a link's title is "editorializing". Thus we get ridiculous stuff like this, instead of something more illuminating.
- gus_massa 13y agoOfficial post: "Why we revert to original titles" https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6572466 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6572466 (414 points, by pg, 127 days ago, 220 comments) I agree that too much editorializing is bad, but textual titles are also bad. In the last weeks I feel that the rules had been relaxed a little, but I haven't done any systematic measurement.
- tw268 13y agoI feel bad for him, but his second most recent blog post is odious: why he only retweets females. http://dashes.com/anil/2014/02/a-checklist-of-stupid-things-men-will-say-when-they-find-out-i-only-retweet-women.html http://dashes.com/anil/2014/02/a-checklist-of-stupid-things-... Maybe karma works in mysterious ways
- zorpner 13y agoIt's funny how you can always pick out a sexist by how they refer to women as "females".
- tormeh 13y agoWhat? I use "females". I thought it was a clever way to get around having to choose between "girl" and "woman", as I would assume different females prefer different terms based on their self-image. I'm not quite comfortable with being called a man (it makes me think of my father), but "boy" is certainly incorrect. Male is a perfectly fine thing to say. Basically the girl/woman boundary involves sex, mental maturity, age and other things I don't really want to touch.
- kaybe 13y agoBut it sounds like you're labeling a member of some other species or something. In professional and unknown context, you can't really go wrong with woman for anyone above drinking age. (It's the most polite and neutral possible, I'd say.)
- alanh 13y ago> woman … is the most polite and neutral possible Probably true! > can’t really go wrong Hahaha. ha. I really wish you were right, but the thing about ladies/women/girls/females/dames/womyn/gals/femmes is, being individuals, they have individual opinions on the matter. And being human, they just may have specific fears and wishes regarding their perception. So some girls hear “woman” as “old!” and some women hear “girl” as “object!” and so on and so forth. Just as in anything else messy and human, there isn’t an easy answer.
- eskil 13y agoAmex has a credit card called Blue Sky. Now I kind of want one.
- sidcool 13y agoIt seems the paranoia is getting institutionalized.
- badman_ting 13y agoThe last paragraph is perhaps more crucial than it may seem.
- nikcub 13y ago"Blue Sky" is the name of an underground drug marketplace. It is one of the new[1] sites looking to replace Silk Road and is apparently popular. Onion link: http://blueskyplzv4fsti.onion/ http://blueskyplzv4fsti.onion/ edit: screenshot of the market homepage: http://imgur.com/O9fvlxI.png http://imgur.com/O9fvlxI.png [1] turns out it was launched in the first week of December, which makes it nearly 3 months old - enough time to get it noticed and flagged by the us.gov.
- geon 13y agoThat last line: > Customs when returning home to the United States. See? It was all just a harmless mixup. I suppose it was meant as a joke, but I find it chilling.