4 ms·
I think the concept is pretty neat, but the implementation leaves a lot to be desired. For one thing the inertial effects on the water should be contained (a li
by ChuckMcM 13y ago
I think the concept is pretty neat, but the implementation leaves a lot to be desired. For one thing the inertial effects on the water should be contained (a lid would help there) and secondly the response time is way too high. But given the mechanism, its possible to do some really interesting fish intelligence studies.
For example. set the cart to move very very slowly, so that basically the fish staying on the edge would move maybe 1 or 2 feet per minute. Second, use roller wheels so that the orientation of the tank stays the same regardless of direction, and only its position changes. Finally put different "scenes" around the room and see if the fish gets the tank to move over to the scene or not.
Then I would be LED lamps at different parts of the room, when one was the target color if the fish moved the tank to it, it would drop food in the water and the light would turn off. Then another of the lamps would turn the target color. Could you train the fish to move the tank to the correct light color?
- baddox 13y agoAny idea how well a fish can see (and process/understand) outside its aquarium?
- hcarvalhoalves 13y agoThe eyes vary with the adaptions of each species, but overall fish have a strong vision sense, similar to us. They can focus, have day and night vision (rods and cones), most see in color and some can see into the UV spectrum. So, in the vision department, fish are capable. I don't know how much a fish navigates the space based on vision alone (and I don't think it plays a big role, since visibility underwater is limited), but I know some from the Cichlidae family like the Oscar are able to recognize it's owner, which is quite a feat.
- ChuckMcM 13y agoNo, but after my experiments I would hope to be able to make some pretty definitive statements about that :-)
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- waps 13y agoA lid seems a pretty primitive solution plus it wouldn't help against feedback on the fish's position itself. Furthermore it would obstruct the vision of the camera. If you're designing a craft if possible you want to avoid the movement of the craft changing the control inputs. If not, and I'm betting this thing already experienced that, it can get into a feedback loop, either creating very "shocky" movement, or unbounded acceleration. Instead, prevent having waves in the first place. Just like a person can move a glass without generating (large) waves in the liquid. What you want to do is to avoid using the position of the fish directly as input to the motor voltage. Instead, use it as an input to the control circuitry. Then calculate the force generated on the fish : voltage is linearly related to speed. And the differential of voltage gives you the force on the boat/fish. So let the fish move and this sets a "target", then every timeframe you bring the voltage, say, 0.01V closer to what the fish "wants" to set it to, limiting the force exerted on the bowl. Btw: there will be a "resonant" value that will be relatively low in value, but will build massive waves. Avoid at all costs. In a project like this I might just assume I'm very unlikely to configure just the resonant value, but in a real project I'd make DAMN sure I knew what the resonant value(s) is/are and put in a warning. You probably think that this will restrict the movement a lot but it won't. Find the right values and you will hardly see any waves at all.